Resolved
Resolved (unanimously) to accept the officer recommendation to refuse planning permission for the following reasons: 1) No. 6 Belvoir Terrace is a Building of Local Interest, and in these circumstances policy 4/12 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2006) apply. The tests that must be met are that that the building is demonstrably incapable of beneficial use or reuse and that there are clear public benefits arising from the proposed redevelopment. The building is reasonably capable of repair and retention and in so doing of maintaining its status as a Building of Local Interest. The proposed works would amount to a replica building and in so doing would result in the loss of the building's status as a heritage asset of the City. There are no wider benefits arising from its demolition/rebuilding. The demolition of No. 6 Belvoir Terrace is therefore not justified. The proposal is therefore contrary to policy ENV6 of the East of England Plan (2008), policy 4/12 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2006) and government guidance in Planning Policy Statement 5 Planning for the Historic Environment (2010). 2) This house is situated in a very prominent position, clearly visible when entering the City along Trumpington Road, and it makes a positive contribution to the character and appearance of City of Cambridge Conservation Area 1 (Central), being a Building of Local Interest forming the end of a Grade II Listed terrace. Conservation Area Consent was previously refused and would be required in the case of demolition and in so doing it has not been demonstrated that the proposed demolition and rebuilding of 6 Belvoir Terrace would either preserve or enhance the character or appearance of the Conservation Area. It would result in the loss of a Building of Local Interest which contributes positively to the character and appearance of the Conservation Area. A replica building would likely fail to retain the heritage status of the existing building and the rebuilding would result in a replica with none of the character or history of the original building. This proposal would result in the loss of a Building of Local Interest. As such, the application is contrary to policy 4/11 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2006).