Resolved
On the 25 th July 2011, the Government published the draft National Planning Policy Framework for consultation, hereafter referred to as the draft framework. The draft framework was intended to streamline the national planning policies and to provide a clearer, simpler, more coherent framework that was easier to understand and put into practice. The Officer’s report sought a decision on the Council’s response to the draft framework to be submitted to the Department of Communities and Local Government (DCLG). Decision of Executive Councillor for Planning and Sustainable Transport: (i) Agreed the comments set out in the response form attached to Appendix A of the Officer’s report and that these would be submitted to the DCLG as the City Council’s formal response to the draft framework. Reason for the As set out in the Officer’s report. Any alternative options considered and rejected: Not applicable. Scrutiny Considerations: The committee received a report from the Senior Sustainability Officer regarding the draft National Planning Policy Framework . The committee made the following comments in response to the report. (i) Members generally supported Officer comments in the report and thanked them for their efforts. (ii) Historically, the planning system has balanced the competing needs of housing, growth, transport, employment and recreation. It also sought to balance out market fluctuations to ensure a considered (as opposed to knee jerk) response to local market trends. The draft framework appeared to give housing/economic needs the dominant interest (i.e. priority). Councillors wished to avoid a system that encouraged a light touch approach in conjunction with a presumption in favour of sustainable development, which may lead to difficulties in refusing unsuitable applications under new ambiguous guidance (i.e. unscrupulous developers deliberately seeking planning permission through the appeal process). (iii) Businesses chose to locate in Cambridge for a variety of reasons, such as housing availability, the historic environment of Cambridge and quality of sites. It was felt that the draft framework failed to consider the different timescales held by the variety different stakeholders in the planning system. For example, universities and some businesses would have longer term interests and needs than a housing developer. An over simplified draft framework policy document may not reflect these needs. (iv) The planning system was not an impediment to growth. Housing growth reflects economic growth in so far that more occurs in times of growth than recession. (v) Local authorities should be forthright in lobbying on behalf of local needs to ensure that the draft framework’s sustainable development presumption does not overrule other presumptions. Members wished to avoid the removal of discretion of local planners by a generic national policy that may not reflect local needs. The City would aim to meet practicable local target levels where it was not possible to meet the full national policy allocation (e.g. for housing). (vi) It was felt that there could be an opportunity for an alliance of local authorities with heritage assets to seek to modify these proposals. It was felt that such an approach could be dealt with via political processes. (vii) The transitional period should be protected so that Local Plans would stay in place until the new Planning Policy was implemented. The draft framework failed to recognise the considerable amount of work in consultation with local communities that has gone into the development of existing local planning policy, and this should not be swept away by the proposals. (viii) Greater emphasis should be placed on the reference that risks from property development/speculation were the responsibility of landowners and developers rather than the planning system. (ix) Cambridge City, Cambridgeshire County and South Cambridgeshire District Councils addressed cross-boundary planning issues through the Joint Development Control Committee. The authorities have a long history of joint working. In response to Member’s questions the Senior Sustainability Officer, Senior Planning Policy Officer and Planning Policy Manager confirmed the following: (i) Current local, regional and national planning policy has been written to avoid duplication between the different layers. There was a danger that gaps in policy may arise if guidance was stripped away before a comprehensive replacement system was in place. (ii) There was no expected change in policy between Local Plans and the draft framework concerning listed buildings and conservation areas. (iii) There was no significant change in policy concerning Green Belt land between PPS2 and the draft framework . In terms of Green Belt land and other areas of open space, the Local Plan currently has a caveat that open space would be protected if it met criteria, even if a specific Protected Open Space designation had not been made. The Senior Sustainability Officer, Senior Planning Policy Officer and Planning Policy Manager undertook to: (i) Amend elements of the draft response to the draft framework in light of Members concerns (ii) Liaise with Directors to seek both Cambridge MPs support in lobbying Central Government concerning Cambridge’s local issues in relation to the draft framework and the need for transitional arrangements to be put in place. The Committee resolved unanimously (4 votes to 0) to adopt the recommendations in the Officer’s report on the understanding that Officers would amend the response to the draft National Planning Policy Framework in line with Members’ comments made at DPSSC . Final wording would be agreed by Chair and Spokes. The Executive Councillor approved the recommendations. Conflicts of interest declared by the Executive Councillor (and any dispensations granted) Not applicable .