Resolved (by 6 votes to 0 - unanimously) to accept the officer recommendation and offer no objection to the removal of the Horse Chestnut tree and its replacement with the Himalayan Birch or another tree as recommended by the Arboricultural Officer.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
REPORT OF: Arboricultural Officer TO: Planning Committee 17/07/12 WARD: Market
TREE WORKS APPLICATION 12/204/TTPO NOTIFICATION TO FELL T1, HORSE CHESTNUT AT DENMORE LODGE, BRUNSWICK GARDENS
1.0INTRODUCTION 1.1 A 211 notice has been received to fell a Horse Chestnut in the garden of Denmore Lodge, Brunswick Gardens protected by its location within a Conservation Area.
1.2The item is brought before Members because objections have been received to the removal of the tree.
1.3The Local Planning Authority can deal with this application in one of three ways: (1) Offer no objection to the works, (2) Object to the works and Place a Tree Preservation Order on the tree.
2.0RECOMMENDATION 2.1 The Council offer no objection to the removal of the tree and its replacement with the Himalayan Birch.
3.0BACKGROUND 3.1 As part of a pre-development tree survey in January, it was noted by the applicant’s consultant that the Horse Chestnut, T1 on the plan, contained a number of structural defects sufficient to compromise the structural integrity of the tree. Given the tree’s residential location and the number of ‘targets’ within range of falling limbs, the tree was considered to be a hazard. In order to remove the hazard an application has been made for the tree’s removal.
3.2The pre-development survey was carried out in order to assess the suitability of an extension to the house. Planning Application no. 11/0856/FUL was granted permission subject to a number of conditions including the protection of nearby trees. The removal of the tree may be considered by the applicant to be beneficial but this has not been given as a reason. Officers have therefore considered this notification on the grounds of health and safety only.
3.3While the notification was registered as a TPO application, the Tree Officer could find no record of a TPO in the Horse Chestnut and makes recommendations accordingly.
4.0CONSULTATIONS 4.1 Residents of Brunswick Terrace and Gardens and Maids Causeway were consulted and a Site Notice was issued for display.
Report Page No: 1 Agenda Page No: 4.2 9 objections to the removal of T1 have been received from residents in Maids Causeway and Brunswick Terrace and Gardens.
5.0CONSIDERATIONS 5.1. Is a TPO appropriate Amenity Does the tree still make a significant contribution to the character and appearance of the area Condition Has the tree’s condition deteriorated sufficiently to make it exempt from the TPO
Justification for Removal Are there sound practical or arboricultural reasons to remove trees or carry out tree works. • What is the justification • Is there a financial consideration • Is there a health and safety consideration • Does the nuisance out way the benefit of retention
5.2The Arboricultural Officer’s assessment of the tree.
Amenity T1 is sandwiched between two mature Lime trees protected by TPO 06/1988 one within the garden of Denmore Lodge and one just over the north boundary and in an adjacent garden. Given the close spacing of the three trees, they have formed a single ‘group’ canopy, with the two Limes forming the dominant part. While T1 can clearly be seen if viewed from a generally southerly aspect, its individual significance in visual terms is limited as viewed from public space. It is however acknowledged that its individual significance as viewed from adjacent properties to the east, south and west will be greater. However current guidance ‘Guide to the Law and Good Practice’ gives limited importance to private view in terms of Tree Preservation Orders. Furthermore the loss of T1 would allow the two adjacent Limes to grow into the space created by its loss.
Condition Given the tree’s mature age, historic tree work, the presence of leaf miner and evidence of historic canker, its vigour is relatively good. The crown contains a number of medium sized dead branches but this is typical given the shading caused by the close proximity of the two Limes.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.