Resolved
Resolved (by 7 votes to 0 - unanimously) to accept the officer recommendation to refuse planning permission as per the agenda. Reasons for Refusal 1. Paragraph 70 of the National Planning Policy Framework states that Local Planning Authorities must 'guard against' the unnecessary loss of valued facilities and services. The site has not been adequately marketed and therefore there is no clearly substantiated evidence to demonstrate that there is no longer a need for the public house. The proposal is therefore contrary to the guidance provided by paragraph 70 of the National Planning Policy Framework (2012). 2. The site layout fails to make provision for vehicles to turn within the site to enable access/egress to the site in a forward gear. In so doing, the use of the site would be likely to generate conditions that would be detrimental to highway safety and residential amenity contrary to policies 3/7 and 8/2 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2006). 3. The proposed design by virtue of the use of the gull wing roof design, the inconsistent eaves line, the poor visual relationship between the terraced houses and the corner block and the variation in heights of the units would appear as a discordant and alien feature in the streetscene. In so doing, the development fails to identify and respond positively to the local character of the surrounding area and does not have a positive impact on its setting, and is therefore in conflict with policies ¾ and 3/12 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2006). 4. Because of the layout of the site and the provision of a large courtyard car park to the rear, the proposed development has not been designed to provide an attractive or high quality living environment, which is enjoyable to use. The car parking area would be a large, uninviting and anonymous space, which would be poorly lit, and surrounded by buildings which have not been designed to overlook it to provide natural surveillance. The proposal does not provide usable or attractive open space, or a high quality living environment and is therefore in conflict with policy 3/7 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2006). 5. The proposed development by virtue of the scale of the buildings and the proximity to the boundary would be likely to lead to the overshadowing, enclosure and dominance of houses on Hatherdene Close. For this reason the proposal are unacceptable and in conflict with Cambridge Local Plan 2006, policy 3/7. 6. Due to the positioning of the access road, adjacent to the boundary with 1 Rosemary Lane, the occupiers of this property would suffer from an unreasonable level of noise and disturbance associated with comings and goings to and from the development. For this reason the proposal are unacceptable and in conflict with Cambridge Local Plan 2006, policy 3/7. 7. The proposal fails to make provision for the use of renewable energy sources to meet at least 10% of the energy requirements of the development and is therefore in conflict with policy 8/16 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2006). 8. The proposed development does not make appropriate provision for public open space, community development facilities, life-long learning facilities, public art, waste storage, waste management facilities and monitoring in accordance with Cambridge Local Plan 2006 policies 3/7, 3/12, 5/14, and 10/1, Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Structure Plan 2003 policies P6/1 and P9/8 and as detailed in the Planning Obligation Strategy 2010, the Public Art Supplementary Planning Document 2010, the RECAP Waste Management Design Guide SPD 2012, and the Open Space Standards Guidance for Interpretation and Implementation 2010.