Resolved (by 6 votes to 0) to accept the officer recommendation and grant permission to undertake tree works subject to a condition limiting the works to a 20% lateral reduction and the removal of the limb leaning on the bridge for the tree that was the subject of the application.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
REPORT OF: Arboricultural Officer TO: Planning Committee 12 December 2012 WARD: West Chesterton
TREE WORKS APPLICATION 12/414/TTPO APPLICATION TO PRUNE WILLOW AT 48 PRETORIA ROAD
1.0INTRODUCTION 1.1 A tree work application has been received to crown reduce a willow on the river bank to the rear of, but still in the ownership of 48 Pretoria Road as the tree is leaning over the river and resting on the pedestrian bridge.
1.2The item is brought before Members on the request of Cllr Tunnacliffe. There are no additional objections to the tree works.
1.3The Local Planning Authority can deal with this application in one of three ways: (1) Refuse permission (2) Grant permission (3) Grant permission subject to condition.
2.0RECOMMENDATION 2.1 The Council grant permission subject to condition limiting the extent of works.
3.0BACKGROUND 3.1 As the tree is protected by a TPO an application has been made to grant consent for a height reduction of 25% and a lateral reduction of 35% to reduce the weight over the river and to clear the adjacent bridge, which the tree is leaning on.
4.0CONSULTATIONS 4.1 Ward Councillors and residents of Pretoria Road, Aylestone Road, Midsummer Common and Banhams Close were consulted and a Site Notice was issued for display. 4.2 Comments were received from Cllr Tunnacliffe, concerned about the extent of works proposed.
5.0CONSIDERATIONS 5.1. 5.0 CONSIDERATIONS 5.1. Is the TPO still appropriate Amenity Does the tree still make a significant contribution to the character and appearance of the area Condition Has the tree’s condition deteriorated sufficiently to make it or works to it exempt from the TPO
Report Page No: 1 Agenda Page No: Justification for Remedial works Are there sound practical or arboricultural reasons to carry out trees works. • What is the justification • Is there a financial consideration • Is there a health and safety consideration • Does the nuisance out way the benefit of retention
5.2The Arboricultural Officer’s assessment of the tree.
Amenity The Willow is located on the north bank of the Cam opposite Midsummer Common and adjacent to the public footpath and bridge over Cam. It is therefore clearly visible and has a high amenity value. Condition The tree is showing normal vigour and shows no indication of significant defect or other instability. The tree is however leaning over the river and is resting on the adjacent bridge. Justification for Remedial Works • What is the justification Limited individual public amenity contribution Significant structural defects with the crown Size of limbs over these defects Lack of suitable, long-term alternatives to removal and Proximity of targets • Is there a financial consideration No • Is there a health and safety consideration Yes, should any of the limbs fail, there will be a risk of harm to persons and/or damage to property. • Does the risk out way the benefit of retention For the reasons detailed above the Tree Officer considers the risk to out way the benefit of retention.
5.3Applicants reasons for wishing to reduce the size of the tree As the tree is leaning over the river and is resting on the bridge there is potential for the tree to cause damage to the bridge. As the tree is getting some support from the bridge and has done for some years, removing the limbs touching the bridge could increase the tree’s susceptibility to damage in string weather.
5.4Objections with Officer Comments • The previous loss of a tree along the same stretch of river resulting in an unattractive stump. • Each application needs has to be assessed on its own merits. However consideration is also given the presence of other trees and this affect an individual value. • The extent of the proposed works, which will open view to the adjacent house. • Officers agree with this concern and feel that there is insufficient evidence to justify such a drastic reduction. Officers do however agree that the
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.