Resolved (by 6 votes to 1 with 1 abstention) to grant the application for a Certificate of Lawfulness in accordance with the officer recommendation, for the reasons set out in the officer report, and subject to the conditions recommended by the officers.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
Application 14/2063/CLUED Agenda Number Item Date Received 6th January 2015 Officer Michael Hammond Target Date 3rd March 2015 Ward Newnham Site 15A Derby Street Cambridge CB3 9JE Proposal Application for a Certificate of Lawfulness under Section 191 for use as an independent dwelling (C3) Applicant [name removed] & [name removed] There is sufficient evidence to suggest, on the balance of probability, that the first floor studio of the application site building has been used as a separate dwelling (c3) for a continuous period of more than 10 years and that the continued residential use of it is lawful and immune from enforcement action.
RECOMMENDATION That a Certificate of Lawfulness be granted
15A Derby Street; Update to the report dated 29/04/15
0.1This update is in response to questions asked by Members of Planning Committee (29/04/2015) regarding the application for a Certificate of Lawful Use in respect of 15A Derby Street. At the meeting the matter was deferred for further information and advice.
0.2The two questions raised were:
Q1. Is the lack of a tenancy agreement for the periods of short or holiday lets fatal to the Applicant’s application? Q2. If there were short lets can these count towards the period of the unlawful use of the property as a separate dwelling house?
0.3A1.Advice from a City Legal Officer is as follows: The Applicant has to prove on a balance of probabilities that 15A Derby Street has been used as a separate C3 dwelling house for more than 4 years .The Applicant has provided a Statutory Declaration and copy leases (for most of the material period) but he has not produced any tenancy agreements or licenses in respect of the period of short lets. He states (under oath) that during summer periods (01/06/2003 – 13/09/2003, 13/06/2004 – 17/09/2004, 06/08/2005 – 17/09/2005, 09/08/2009 – 28/08/2009, 29/08/2010 – 30/09/2010, 01/07/2011 – 14/09/2011, 15/07/2012 – 30/09/2012) he has let out the property to visitors etc. The Council has no evidence to contradict this and given the strength of the Cambridge rental market, especially for short term lets over the summer months, it appears to the Planning Officer unlikely that the Applicant would leave empty a fully furnished and self-contained unit whilst continuing to pay Council tax in respect of the property. Therefore, on the balance of probabilities the Legal Officer accepts the contents of the Statutory Declaration.
0.4Notwithstanding a lack of documentary evidence for the short term lets the Planning Officer having made a site visit, is of the opinion that the unit has been functionally set up and used as a dwelling house for some time and has no reason to doubt the Applicant’s assertion in his Statutory Declaration that it has been so used since 1st April 2000. To emphasise the importance of a Statutory Declaration, if the information contained in it were false, the Applicant would be liable for perjury.
0.5A2.The case of Gravesham Borough Council v Secretary of State for the Environment and Another (1984) 47 P & CR 142 provides a helpful definition of a dwelling house. It is a building which ordinarily affords the facilities required for day-to-day existence. (There is no requirement that the dwelling house must be used as a permanent residence nor is the nature of the type of tenancy relevant). Applying that test to 15A Derby Street and the facilities present (a kitchen bathroom lounge /bedroom) the Planning Officer is satisfied that 15A is a dwelling house.
0.6The Planning Officer accepts that the building has been let as an independent dwelling for more than 4 years continuously prior to the date of the application taking all the above factors into account and the fact that that Council Tax has been paid by the tenants (during the tenancy agreements) and by the Applicant at the other times.
1.0SITE DESCRIPTION/AREA CONTEXT
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.