Resolved
Agreed with the points made by Councillor Bick. ii. Did not accept the viability assessment, affordable housing was needed in the City. iii. Did not like 8 storey buildings and did not want the skyline to be full of buildings, he wanted to be able to see the sky. iv. Additional traffic would be a problem. v. Reliance on cars took a step back from the Council commitment made at the Full Council meeting in October 2015. Councillor Price’s representation covered the following issues: i. Viability issues had been raised by Councillor Bick. ii. Block H had a dominant presence; the affordable housing did not appear to be tenure blind. iii. Unacceptable that Block H did not benefit from combined power. iv. Questioned whether Block H had photo voltaic cells. v. Questioned the parking arrangements for Block H. vi. The Housing Allocations Policy meant that flats could not be under-occupied therefore children would live in the flats and there was insufficient play area provision. vii. Cambridge was low risk for sales of properties; many properties were sold off plan. viii. A reduction in the provision of affordable housing was not acceptable given the pressure already on affordable housing. Councillor Blencowe proposed an additional condition to the Officer’s recommendation that the materials used on Block H were to be of a similar quality and design as those used for the rest of the development. The Committee agreed to accept the addition of this condition to the recommendation. The Committee voted that they were minded to go against the Officer’s recommendation (and therefore refuse the application) by 6 votes to 1 . The Legal Advisor advised the Committee of the Adjourned Decision Making Protocol. The Committee: Resolved not to accept the officer recommendation of approval, as the committee were minded to refuse the application, a decision on whether to approve or refuse the application was subsequently deferred under the Adjourned Decision Protocol Under the Council’s agreed Adjourned Decisions Protocol this application will be brought back to a future meeting of the Committee to allow further discussion of reasons for refusal. The following matters may form the basis for detailed reasons for refusal. 1. The affordable housing block is by virtue of its external treatment which contrasts with the rest of the development, not ‘tenure blind’. 2. Lack of amenity space/ play space to serve the affordable housing units and the development more generally. 3. The height of Block G in the context of the height of surrounding buildings. 4. The scheme does not deliver 40% affordable housing. 5. That the renewable energy provisions do not extend to the affordable housing units. 6. That the development is contrary to the Eastern Gateway Supplementary Planning Document on the basis that it does not provide ‘connectivity’ with the surrounding parts to the SPD area. The Officer recommendation of approval was subject to the completion of a section 106 Agreement to secure off site mitigation of development impacts. In the event of a refusal of planning permission, a refusal reason to the lack of a legal agreement to secure these mitigation measures will also be recommended.