Resolved (3 votes to 3 – and on the Chair’s casting vote to approve the application in light of the further advice and the additional/amended conditions recommended plus those set out in the original officer report and amendment sheet, together with a S106 agreement (including a claw-back clause) as below: Those conditions as recommended as part of the 6 January 2016 Planning Committee Report. · revised conditions 32 and 34 as set out on the amendment sheet to the 6 January 2016 Planning Committee. · an additional condition (18) as set out at paragraph 0.8 of the 3 February 2016 Committee report regarding the treatment of Block H. · revised condition 14 as set out at paragraph 0.51 of the 3 February 2016 Committee report regarding renewable energy technologies. · An S106 agreement, including a claw-back clause, for terms as set out in the 6 January 2016 Planning Committee Report.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
Application 14/1905/FUL Agenda Number Item Date Received 5th December 2014 Officer [name removed] Date 6th March 2015 Ward Market Site 64 Newmarket Road Cambridge CB5 8DZ Proposal Demolition of existing buildings and erection of a mixed used development comprising 84 dwellings, circa 152m2 A1-A3 commercial space, and associated access, car and cycle parking, and public realm enhancement Applicant [name removed] Report: 64 Newmarket Road, 14/1905/FUL
0.0Introduction
0.1This application was reported to the 6 January 2016 Planning Committee with an officer recommendation of approval. During the consideration of the application, Members of the Committee raised a number of concerns about the proposal. The Committee voted not to accept the officer recommendation of approval and a decision on whether to approve or refuse the application was subsequently deferred because the Adjourned Decision Protocol (ADP) was triggered. The Committee agreed a motion that they were minded to refuse the application for a number of reasons. The City Development Manager advised the Committee that the ADP applied because the risks of refusing planning permission on the basis of the areas of concern expressed by Committee members was greater than low and further investigation of the issues was required. The Committee agreed that a report should be brought back to the next committee meeting to help inform making a decision. This report includes at appendix 1, an update report from BPS Chartered Surveyors (the Council’s Viability Consultant) which provides further guidance in relation to the relevance of a recent appeal decision at Islington, land value and comparable sales values.
0.2To ensure safe decision making, members of the planning committee absent from the previous discussion should not take part in the resumed debate. The purpose of the resumed debate is for Committee to determine if their original minded-to resolution is still appropriate, should be amended, or whether the original officer recommendation should be followed.
0.3Further analysis is therefore required to understand the policy framework for the potential issues and possible reasons for refusal, to consider any relevant legal advice, relevant appeals and any other guidance available to members to help inform a decision. Officers have also had an opportunity to discuss the issues with the applicants, who have provided a short letter, which summarises their response. This is attached as appendix 2. As part of this assessment, where certain issues are considered capable of becoming reasons for refusal and being defended at appeal, draft reasons for refusal are suggested.
Key Issues
0.4The following issues were raised by Members of the Planning Committee as potentially forming the basis for detailed reasons for refusal:
1. The affordable housing block is, by virtue of its external treatment which contrasts with the rest of the development, not ‘tenure blind’.
2. There is a lack of amenity space/play space to serve the affordable housing units and the development more generally.
3. Block G is too high in the context of the height of surrounding buildings.
4. The scheme does not deliver 40% affordable housing.
5. The renewable energy provisions do not extend to the affordable housing units.
6. The development is contrary to the Eastern Gate SPD on the basis that it does not provide ‘connectivity’ with the surrounding parts to the SPD area.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.