Resolved (3 votes to 3 – and on the Chair’s casting vote) to refuse the application contrary to the officer recommendations for the following reason: The proposed development would, by virtue of its unsympathetic scale, bulky design and loss of trees, have a significantly detrimental impact on the character and setting of this edge of city site and surrounding rural context. The proposed development would result in an alien form of development and unduly diminish the rural character of this green edge from Lime Kiln Road. The proposal therefore fails to sympathetically respond to the site context and setting of the city. For these reasons the proposed development conflicts with policies 3/2, 3/4, 3/12 and 4/4 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2006) and government guidance contained in the National Planning Policy Framework 2012.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
Application 15/2063/FUL Agenda Number Item Date Received 4th November 2015 Officer [name removed] Date 30th December 2015 Ward Cherry Hinton Site Land Rear Of 268 Queen Ediths Way Cambridge Cambridgeshire CB1 8NL Proposal Erection of 3.No four bed houses, internal access road, car and cycle parking and hard and soft landscaping. Applicant C/O Agent United Kingdom
Update Report: 15/2063/FUL, Land Rear of 268 Queen Edith’s Way
0.0Introduction
0.1This application was reported to the 3 February 2016 Planning Committee with an officer recommendation of approval. During the consideration of the application, Members of the Committee raised a number of concerns about the proposal. The Committee voted not to accept the officer recommendation.
0.2Following legal advice received during the meeting, the City Development Manager advised the Committee that the Adjourned Decision Protocol (ADP) could apply in this case because further investigation was required with reference to the previous decision made by the Planning Committee for a similar proposal and legal advice was required.
0.3Members agreed to defer a decision on the application in accordance with the ADP and agreed a motion that they were minded to refuse the application on the grounds of context and character. The Committee agreed that a report should be brought back to the next meeting to help inform making a decision.
0.4To ensure safe decision making, Members of the Planning Committee absent from the previous discussion, Ward Members and third parties cannot not take part in the resumed debate. The purpose of the resumed debate is for Committee to determine if their original minded-to resolution is still appropriate, should be amended, or whether the original officer recommendation should be followed.
0.5Further analysis is therefore required to understand the policy framework for the potential issues and possible reason for refusal, to consider any relevant legal advice, how an appeal might be considered and any other guidance available to members to help inform a decision.
Key Issue
0.6As set out above, the issue of character and context was raised by Members of the Planning Committee as potentially forming the basis for a detailed reason for refusal. The refusal reason was similar to that put forward as part of the previous refused application for 15/0596/FUL. This would read as follows:
‘The proposed development would, by virtue of its unsympathetic scale, bulky design and loss of trees, have a significantly detrimental impact on the character and setting of this edge of city site and surrounding rural context. The proposed development would result in an alien form of development and unduly diminish the rural character of this green edge from Lime Kiln Road. The proposal therefore fails to sympathetically respond to the site context and setting of the city. For these reasons the proposed development conflicts with policies 3/2, 3/4, 3/12 and 4/4 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2006) and government guidance contained in the National Planning Policy Framework 2012’
0.7The Committee also requested clarification of the relevance of the status of the ‘East Green Corridor’ referred to by the Ward Councillor, Councillor Ashton.
Assessment
0.8The application is for the erection of three dwellings in a back- land position adjacent to the Green Belt, a SSSI and local nature reserves. The site is on the edge of the City and is undoubtedly in a sensitive position. Proposals on this site have attracted numerous objections on grounds of residential amenity and character and context. The application is in effect a resubmission of a refused planning application (15/0596/FUL), also for three houses, that was presented to Planning Committee in October 2015. As part of the officer recommendation in October of last year, a refusal of planning permission was recommended on the grounds of context and character, as set out at paragraphs 8.4 – 8.19 of that report, which I quote below:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.