Resolved unanimously (by 7 votes to 0) to accept the officer recommendation to note that: i. The LGO has upheld a complaint relating to the determination of a planning application. ii. In these circumstances the Head of Legal Services as the Council’s Monitoring Officer has an obligation to report the findings to Council and that Committee is satisfied with the action that has been taken (set out in Section 4 of the Officer’s report).
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
Corporate Business Support Team T: 01223 457325 E: [email protected]
29th July 2016
Formal Complaint against Cambridge City Council (CCC) – Planning Services
I write further to your email of complaint sent to me on 27th May 2016 in respect of a service complaint 659472, concerning the retrospective planning permission granted for a barrier at
Your complaints have not been resolved at stage 2 of the City Council’s procedures and were passed to me for an independent review; I have now completed my review and set out my findings, conclusions and recommendations below.
My role
My role is to investigate complaints concerning administrative and procedural actions and decisions that have failed to be resolved at departmental level. As the Independent Complaints Investigator I try to resolve the matter as the final stage in the City Council’s internal complaints procedure.
Your complaint
Your complaints to me concerned the fact that in your view there were faults in the process of assessing and presenting the application to the Planning Committee which resulted in them reaching an unsound decision based upon an inaccurate assessment of the planning application. In that regard you feel overall that the City Council has been negligent in handling this planning application.
In terms of identifying specific complaints to support your view you have identified to me six areas where these failures have occurred. I have summarised these in the general complaint headings below and in the body of my report I have explored in some detail each area in order to arrive at an individual and collective finding.
PO Box 700, Cambridge, CB1 0JH www.cambridge.gov.uk • Switchboard: 01223 457000 Specific Complaints Summary
That Cambridge City Council in processing planning application 16/0117/FUL) made the following process errors which impacted on the Planning Committee being able to reach a sound decision:
1. The case officer failed to properly assess your photographic and video evidence which was not looked at and therefore not considered. If the case officer had looked at the evidence then the officer report would not have been incomplete, inaccurate and biased. 2. The case officer presented incorrect information in the verbal briefing to the committee. This information included incorrect numbers and location of objectors; lack of information about ‘yellow lines’ on the road, r statement about a ‘dead end’ should have been corrected and failure to mention a police report. 3. Comments by about lobbying should not have been posted online and the case officer report should have referred to police efforts in the past to stop mopeds riding on the pavement to avoid the barrier. 4. The Environmental Health Officer should have referred to your noise report in his comments. Why has the City Council not undertaken its own noise and disturbance survey if they remain unconvinced. How can the case officer criticise the absence of a noise study by the complainant before the barrier was installed when it was a retrospective application. 5. The case officer’s report incorrectly refers to the barrier replacing a gate that previously secured the site. 6. The case officer’s report should have referred to previous efforts by Councillor Tunnacliffe to mediate between the residents and
My Review
I have received and considered copies of the correspondence you have supplied to me and from the Council in respect of these matters. I have reviewed the Councils process in handling stages 1 and 2 of the complaints procedure and the written responses provided to you by
In addition, I have met and spoken with in terms of the overall processes applied and normal best practice, and who had knowledge of the application and reviewed the planning committee report by the planning officer before it was placed on the Committee Agenda.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.