Resolved
Resolved (by 7 votes to 1) to reject the officer recommendation to approve the application. The Chair decided that possible reasons for refusal should be voted on and recorded separately: i. Scale, mass and height of the application prejudiced the development of the Abbey Church site. Agreed unanimously to accept as a reason for refusal. ii. Impact of sense of enclosure and overbearing on Beche Road. Agreed by 6 votes to 0 to accept as a reason for refusal. iii. Scale, design, massing and streetscape did not enhance the character of the Conservation Area. Agreed by 7 votes to 1 to accept as a reason for refusal. (Reason (iii) was originally agreed without streetscene reference, so Committee voted 6-2 to annul the reason then re-voted 6-1 to include the streetscene reference.) iv. Poor quality of living and amenity space. Agreed by 7 votes to 1 to accept as a reason for refusal. Agreed by 6 votes to 1 to accept the reasons for refusal as listed above. Resolved (by 7 votes to 1) to refuse the application contrary to the officer recommendation for the following reasons: 1. By virtue of its scale, mass, and height adjacent to the boundary with the pan handle strip of land which forms part of the Abbey Church site, the proposal would prejudice the future development potential on the adjacent site and would therefore be contrary to Policy 3/6 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2006). 2. By virtue of its scale, mass, height, and proximity to the northern boundary of the site, the proposal would have an unacceptable enclosing, overbearing, overshadowing and overlooking impact on the gardens of dwellings in Beche Road to the north, which are approximately 3.5m lower than the application site. The proposal would therefore harm the amenities of occupiers of the adjacent dwellings contrary to Cambridge Local Plan (2006) policies 4/7 and 3/12. 3. By virtue of the scale, massing and design of the buildings, the development would have a detrimental impact on the streetscene of this part of Newmarket Road and would fail to preserve and enhance the character and appearance of the Conservation Area and would have a detrimental impact upon the setting of the adjacent Grade II Listed Abbey Church. The proposal would therefore be contrary to policies 3/4, 3/7, 3/12, 4/10 and 4/11 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2006) and the National Planning Policy Framework (2018). 4. The proposed development, by virtue of the overly cramped and small internal living spaces within the dwellings and the poor quality of external amenity space for all of the units, would fail to provide a satisfactory quality of living environment and standard of amenity for future occupiers. Consequently, the proposal would be contrary to the requirements of policy 3/7 of the Cambridge Local Plan (2006) which seeks to provide high quality living environments within new developments.