CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cambridge City Council
Planning, Wednesday 7 November 2018 at 10.00am

17/1484/OUT - Planning Report Land adjacent to Barnwell Lake

Refused Planning 2 papers

Planning refused this item on Wednesday 7 November 2018. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item18/155/Plan

Resolved

Resolved (by 6 votes to 4) to reject the officer recommendation to refuse the application. Resolved (by 9 votes to 0) an additional condition regarding opening hours of 6am to 8pm. Resolved (by 7 votes to 3) to approve the application contrary to the officer recommendation for the following reasons, subject to referral to the Secretary of State for the following reasons: The very special circumstances advanced by Committee include that the development would result in increased recreational use of a private area of Green Belt land which would result in considerable public benefit. The development would support recreational and commuting cyclists and encourage others to make sustainable travel choices in the interests of reducing congestion in the City and promoting wellbeing. This includes expanding opportunities for social interaction and healthy lifestyles, principles set out in paragraph 91 of the NPPF (2018). The development is considered to provide essential refreshment and cycle repair facilities to meet the needs of users of the Chisholm Trail and the angling club, thereby providing an essential resource for community use at a strategic location along the Trail. The proposed café facility would increase public access to a private site to the benefit of the surrounding community, this is by reason of the picnic and recreation areas which would be created and a layout which would encourage walking and cycling. The development would have limited visual impact due to the sunken nature of the site and the low impact design of the building, which includes the single storey design of the building and the use of a green roof. This would ensure the visual impacts of the development would not be harmful and would not conflict with the purposes of including land within the Green Belt. The very special circumstances are unique to this site because of the combination of the lakeside setting, its relationship with the new Chisholm Trail strategic cycle route and the benefit to the immediate surrounding local community. The development would provide a new facility open to the community which would positively enhance the beneficial use of the land through public access, providing opportunities for recreation, which is a principle set out in paragraphs 91 and 141 of the NPPF (2018). These very special circumstances are considered to clearly outweigh the harm by reason of inappropriate development which satisfies the test of paragraph 144 of the NPPF (2018) and Cambridge Local Plan (2018) policy 4. Necessary planning conditions include those relating to the ecology and the Ecological Design Statement; ‘permitted development’ restrictions; hours of use; restrictions on lighting and advertisements; drainage related conditions; Environmental Health conditions; delivery restrictions and a site management plan. The final drafting of the reason for approval and planning conditions is to be agreed through consultation with Chair, Vice Chair and Spokes.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cambridge's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning

PLANNING COMMITTEE DATE: 7TH November 2018

Application 17/1484/OUT Agenda Number Item

Date Received 22nd August 2017 Officer John Evans

Target Date EoT 10th November 2018

Ward Abbey

Site Land Adj to Barnwell Lake, Newmarket Road, Cambridge

Proposal The erection of a cycle themed cafe with ancillary kitchen, storage area, WCs, bin enclosure and cycle repair outlet along with associated infrastructure including 24 car parking spaces, 100 cycle parking spaces, a partly new and upgraded internal road, public open space and associated picnic / play areas.

Applicant Barnwell Café Ltd.

SUMMARY 1) The additional and amended information addresses some of the previous reasons for refusal recommended by officers. 2) Highway safety, flood risk and retail matters have been satisfactorily addressed and no longer form reasons for refusal. The development does not accord with the Development Plan for the following reasons: 3) The proposal is inappropriate development, will result in significant visual harm and conflicts with the purposes of including land in the Green Belt. There are no very special circumstances which outweigh the harm approval would create. 4) The proposal would lead to the loss Protected Open Space which forms reason for refusal 2. 5) The development will result in the net loss of ecology on the site, which forms reason for refusal 3.

RECOMMENDATION REFUSAL

A.1 BACKGROUND

A.1 The application was presented at Planning Committee on 1 November 2017 with an officer recommendation of refusal. The adjourned decision protocol was initiated and the application was deferred following a ‘minded to approve’. Planning Committee was clear that the technical deficiencies with the application submission should be addressed before the application is presented to Committee for determination. Following deferral, the applicant has submitted three packages of additional and amended information which is set out in the description of proposal below.

A.2 The application is a ‘minor development’ because the site area is under 1 ha and not a ‘major’; an error in the previous report to Committee. As such, the application would not generally trigger the Adjourned Decision Protocol. Notwithstanding, Committee members have the right to defer or adjourn making a decision on any planning application for the purposes of requiring further information to enable a decision to be made. The application now falls to be considered on its merits only, based upon all of the information in front of the Committee. The planning application will need to be considered against all of the material submitted, including that submitted since the previous Committee meeting.

A.3 Outline planning permission C/5007/16/CC was approved on 19 July 2017 for phase 1 of the Chisholm Trail (The Trail). The Trail has been approved to traverse the site, entering through an underpass approximately halfway along the northern boundary of the site and Newmarket Road. The Trail will exit the site at the south east corner of the redline boundary, at the north east corner of Barnwell Lake. The Trail development proposes to use the site for temporary storage as a site compound for the construction of the Newmarket Road underpass, as well as the Trail Phase 1 linking Newmarket Road underpass to Coldhams Common. The construction work main site compound is located between Ditton Walk and Ditton Meadows. The Trail is yet to be commenced.

A.4 Planning application C/93/0242 was approved on 2 August 1993 for the formation and stabilisation of banks to Barnwell Lake, provision of fishing platforms and steps, improvement of access, footpaths and parking area, and erection of a shelter. This application provided for much of the existing infrastructure on the site, including the car park and platforms, as well as the general form of the lake including planting and bank stabilisation.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
17/1484/OUT: Planning Report Land adjacent to Barnwell LakeReport 381 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
181107 Barnwell Lakes, 17-1484-OUT agreed conditions which form part of the resolution to approve /155/PlanReport 258 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

11 of 11 attended
MS
Councillor Martin Smart Labour SpokesChair, apologies, sent representative
KB
Councillor Kevin BlencoweVice-Chair, in the Chair, present
DB
Councillor Dave BaigentCommittee Member, present
KG
Councillor Kelley GreenCommittee Member, present as substitute
CH
Councillor Caroline HartCommittee Member, present
JH
Councillor John Hipkin Independent / Green SpokesCommittee Member, present
CM
Councillor Carla McQueenCommittee Member, present
LN
Councillor Lucy NethsinghaCommittee Member, present
JP
Councillor Jennifer Page-CroftCommittee Member, present
KT
Councillor Katie ThornburrowCommittee Member, present
DT
Councillor Damien Tunnacliffe Lib Dem SpokesCommittee Member, present

On this subject at Cambridge

Search all
  1. 17/1484/OUT - Planning Report Land adjacent to Barnwell LakeThis decision
  2. 2016/17 Revenue and Capital Outturn, Carry Forwards and Significant Variances - Planning Policy & TransportApproved
  3. Neighbourhood Planning – Application and designation of a Neighbourhood Area and Forum for South NewnhamApproved
  4. 2015/16 Revenue and Capital Outturn, Carry Forwards and Significant Variances - Planning Policy and Transport PortfolioApproved
  5. Consultation Review of South Cambridgeshire Planning Committee Scheme of DelegationDecided
  6. 2014/15 Revenue and Capital Outturn, Carry Forwards and Significant Variances - Planning Policy and Transport PortfolioAgreed

More from Cambridge Planning

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
4 Nov 2026 26/02186/FUL Coldham's Common, Pool Way, Whitehill RoadResolved (by 7 votes to 0) to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommenda... Decided Open
24 Jun 2026 25/04187/FUL Hanover Court and Princess CourtResolved (by 4 votes to 3) to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommenda... Agreed Open
24 Jun 2026 25/03323/FUL 73 Newmarket RoadResolved (4 votes to 4 – and on the Chair’s casting vote) to grant the application for planning permission in accorda... Agreed Open
24 Jun 2026 26/01081/FUL 9, 11, 15 and 17 Ashfield RoadResolved (by 6 votes to 0) to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommenda... Decided Open
24 Jun 2026 26/01400/FUL 1, 2, 3, 4, 11, 12 The GreenResolved (by 5 votes to 0) to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommenda... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies