Resolved (unanimously) to endorse the Officer’s minded to refuse position for the reasons set out in the Officer’s report subject to: i. an amendment to reason for refusal 2 to include a reference to air source heat pumps; ii. an amendment to reason for refusal 4 to include a reference to gated communities and social cohesion; iii. an amendment to reasons for refusal 2 and 4 regarding stepped access; iv. the amendment to paragraph 10.166 of the Officer’s report as recommended by the Interim Development and Planning Compliance Manager; and v. delegated authority to Officers to draft the amendments detailed above and to include reference to the appropriate NPPF policies.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
Planning Committee Date 6th July 2022 Report to Cambridge City Council Planning Committee Lead Officer Joint Director of Planning and Economic Development
Reference 21/01065/FUL
Site Land Adjacent to Sandy Lane Cambridge Cambridgeshire
Ward / Parish West Chesterton
Proposal Construction of 26 new private homes
Applicant Sandy Lane 2021 Limited
Presenting Officer Alice Young
Reason Reported to Third party representations Committee Member Site Visit Date N/A Key Issues 1. Affordable housing and housing mix 2. Public realm, open space and landscaping 3. Amenity for future occupiers 4. Car and cycle parking 5. Extant consent
Recommendation Members endorse officer position of minded to REFUSE in light of non-determination appeal 1.0 Executive Summary
1.1The application seeks planning permission for 26 dwellings with a mix of four 4-bed and twenty two 5-bed and an offer of 9 affordable housing units delivered on a site adjacent. The application has recently been appealed against non-determination and can no longer be determined by the local planning authority. Thus, this report from officers seeks members’ endorsement of a minded-to position of refusal. Subject to members’ endorsement, officers would then seek to submit a Statement of Case to the Planning Inspectorate recommending the application be dismissed on the grounds specified.
1.2Section 38(6) of the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004 states that applications for planning permission should be determined in accordance with the development plan unless material considerations indicate otherwise. The site has three extant consents – by virtue of implementation of an access road - which form a patchwork of 24 dwellings (C/03/0406 C/03/1241 and 06/0544/FUL). This is a material planning consideration.
1.3In assessing how much weight to give these extant consents, officers have considered whether there is a realistic prospect of the extant consents being fully implemented. The prospect does not have to be probable or likely to be given weight, it can be just more than theoretical. The correct test to be applied in considering a fallback argument is whether there is a possibility that if planning permission was refused, use of the land, or a development which had been permitted, would take place, and whether such use or development would be less desirable than for which planning permission is sought.
1.4Officers originally considered that there was only a theoretical prospect of the extant permissions (C/03/0406, C/03/1241 and 06/0544/FUL) being fully implemented as officers were uncertain whether the scheme was viable and given the substantial length of time since works started on site. However, the Council has commissioned a third-party Viability Assessment which demonstrates that both the extant and proposed schemes are financially viable. Officers consider that this has tilted the balance for the prospect of implementing the extant schemes to now be considered more than theoretical, despite the length of time since works commenced on site. Therefore, the extant consents are given moderate weight.
1.5When assessed against the development plan, the proposed development conflicts with various local plan policies and aims because of the under delivery of affordable housing, lack of an adequate housing mix, poor outlook and light levels internally at lower ground floor, lack of adequate external amenity space, failure to provide a housing scheme which would create an inclusive and accessible environment and which has demonstrated it would be M4(2) compliant, over provision of car parking and inconvenient and unsafe cycle parking. These individual conflicts with the development plan are given moderate weight.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.