Resolved (by 6 votes to 0) to reject the Officer recommendation to refuse the application. Members were reminded by the Interim Development and Planning Compliance Manager of the public benefit exercise assessment to now be considered relative to a heritage asset and potential harm demanded by the NPPF regarding the balancing exercise and the public benefit a scheme brings against the less than substantial harm identified. Members then discussed the harm vs public benefits the scheme would bring prior to a move to vote to approve the application made by Cllr Smart and seconded by Cllr Baigent. Resolved (by 6 votes to 0) to approve the application contrary to the Officer recommendation with : i. delegated authority to Officers to draft appropriate conditions in consultation with the Chair, Vice Chair and Spokes; ii. discretion to Officers to draft a specific glint and glare (control) condition if deemed necessary after a further consultation with the Airport Authority ; and iii. discretion for Officers to draft and include a specific condition that broken/redundant solar panels should be removed from the roof .
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
Planning Committee Date 7 February 2023 Report to Cambridge City Council Planning Committee Lead Officer Joint Director of Planning and Economic Development Reference 22/03811/FUL Site Kings College, Kings Parade, Cambridge Ward / Parish Newnham Proposal Installation of photovoltaic panel arrays on the north and south slopes of Kings College Chapel and related infrastructure. Applicant King's College Cambridge Presenting Officer Mary Collins Reason Reported to Application raises special planning policy or Committee other considerations
Member Site Visit Date Key Issues 1. Impact on significance of Grade I and setting of Grade II Listed Buildings 2. Impact on Park/Garden of special interest 3. Impact on Historic Core Conservation area 4. Carbon reduction 5. Public benefits
Recommendation REFUSE 1.0 Executive Summary
1.1The application seeks planning permission for the installation of 492 photovoltaic (PV) panel arrays on the north and south slopes of Kings College Chapel and related infrastructure.
1.2Having considered the proposals carefully and considering the impact of the PV panels on the significance of the Grade I Listed chapel; Officers are of the view that the magnitude of the public benefit derived from the solar panels in this case does not outweigh the less than substantial harm identified to the heritage interests of the Grade I listed chapel.
1.3The recommendation is accordingly that the application be refused.
2.0Site Description and Context
None-relevant Tree Preservation Order
Conservation Area x Local Nature Reserve
Setting of Listed Building x Flood Zone 1
Building of Local Interest Green Belt
Historic Park and Garden x Protected Open Space x Scheduled Ancient Monument Controlled Parking Zone Local Neighbourhood and Article 4 Direction District Centre
2.1The application site is on the western side of King’s Parade and falls with the Historic Core Conservation Area. The Chapel is a Grade I listed building. The Chapel and all the buildings of King’s College sit within the Grade II* Registered Park and Garden of Special Historic Interest which encompasses all the College’s Courts and Gardens (including those west of the river and therefore forming part of ‘The Backs’.
2.2The Chapel forms the north side of First Court which is enclosed by buildings which are all Grade I listed. They are The Fellows’ (or Gibbs) Building which forms the west side; The Screens and entrance gateway on King’s Parade which forms the east side and the South Range of First Court. Within First Court are Twelve lampposts and a Fountain in the centre, all of these are Grade II listed.
2.3The chapel roof is nearly 300ft long and laid without steps in mini-roll lead, falling to lead parapet gutters. Although a large expanse, it is a plain, practical roof with no decorative leadwork and largely concealed by the openwork parapet, pinnacles, upper turrets and battlements.
2.4To the east of the Chapel on the east side of King’s Parade is the Grade I Listed Church of St Mary the Great. South of this are a number of Grade II listed ‘town’ buildings, generally shops and cafes with King’s College student accommodation above. These form a continuous and attractive group along the east side of King’s Parade and turn the corner into St Mary’s Passage.
2.5The site is within the city centre, Air Quality Management Area and located within the strategic district heating area.
3.0The Proposal
3.1The application seeks planning permission for the installation of photovoltaic panel arrays on the north and south slopes of Kings College Chapel and related infrastructure.
3.2The panel specification is an all-black panel and frame and a panel with low reflectivity. The 492 solar panels are to be split over both the north and south roof slopes of the Chapel and would be carried on a frame fixed just above the renewed lead roof covering currently being installed.
3.3The PV panels would not extend across the full roof length of the roof, each end would have an area of lead roof towards the corner turrets.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.