Resolved (6 votes to 0) to reject the application for tree felling and treatment of the stumps preventing regrowth at 193 Sturton Street. The reason for refusal was agreed by 6 votes to 0 with delegated authority to Officers in respect of minor modifications / grammatical errors etc. Resolved (by 6 votes to 0) to refuse the application for the following reason : The proposal requires the felling of three trees of outstanding and special value , both individually and as part of a group. These trees and the wider group of trees on St Matthew’s Piece contribute significantly and positively to public amenity, the urban forest and to the character and appearance of the Mill Road Conservation Area, where special attention must be given to the desirability of preserving or enhancing its character and appearance. The damage associated with the retention of the trees is not considered to outweigh their amenity value (including but not limited to their visual, atmospheric, climate, biodiversity, historic and cultural benefits). A material loss of public amenity value including harm to the Conservation Area, the urban forest and to St Matthew’s Piece - a highly valued protected open space in Petersfield ward which has very limited open space - would arise from their proposed removal. The proposal would therefore be contrary to Cambridge Local Plan policy 61, NPPF 2023 paras.131 and 174, NPPG guidance para. 090 Reference ID: 36-090-20140306 and para. 093 Reference ID: 36-093-20140306, Section 72 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 and other legislation, policies and guidance that seek safeguard the environment.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk
Planning Committee Date 1st November 2023 Report to Cambridge City Council Planning Committee Lead Officer Joanna Davies Reference 23/0119/TTPO Site St Matthews Centre, Sturton Street Ward / Parish Petersfield Proposal Remove (fell) to ground level and treat stumps to prevent regrowth Presenting Officer Joanna Davies Reason Reported to Objections to the proposed removals have been Committee received from residents, ward cllrs and Friends of St Matthew’s Piece
Options Grant consent Grant consent subject to conditions Refuse consent 1.0 Executive Summary
1.1In 2022 a tree work application was received to reduce the height by 5m and spread by 4m of three London Plane trees located within the grounds of St Matthews Centre opposite 193 Sturton Street. This application was refused at committee because of incomplete data supporting the application, the lack of heave assessment and the lack of information regarding the installation of a root barrier.
1.2The current application concerns the same three trees. It is alleged that following additional movement of foundations the removal of the three trees is now necessary.
1.3Numerous objections to the trees’ removals have been received from residents, councillors and other groups. Officers have been requested to seek independent expert assessment of the application submissions.
1.4Expert opinion has been requested from an independent structural engineer. The structural engineer has confirmed technical data supports a causal link between the trees and damage to the building and that the risk of heave associated with tree removal is minimal.
1.5Legal advice has also been sort from counsel and the advice supports the information contained in this report.
1.6Consideration has been given to underwriting possible cost associated with refusing permission but the financial consequences of doing so, or of refusing consent were, at the time of the previous committee report not considered to be justified.
1.7Members may refuse consent, grant consent unconditionally or grant consent subject to conditions/informatives
2.0Site Description and Context
None-relevant Tree Preservation X Order Conservation Area X Listed Building NA
*X indicates relevance
2.1The St Matthews Centre is located on the corner of Sturton Street and New Street within the Mill Road conservation area. The TPOd trees on the west, north and east boundaries of St Matthews Centre form part of a larger group that extends into the adjacent St Matthews Piece, one of the three open spaces cited to have significance in the conservation area appraisal.
2.2The three subject trees are located on the west boundary of St Matthew’s Centre. They form part of the visually significant group that bounds the Centre and the adjacent St Matthew’s Piece. The three subject trees are located within the line of 13 trees that run the full length of the combined boundary with Sturton Street.
3.0Relevant Site History
Reference Description Outcome 22/0271/TTPO Reduce the height of 3 London Refused Plane trees by 5m and spread by 4m
4.0Legislation and Policy
4.1Town and Country Planning Act 1990 Part VIII Chapter I and Town and Country Planning (Tree Preservation)(England) Regulations 2012. Tree Preservation Order number 04/2005. National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF). Planning Practice Guidance (PPG)
5.0Consultations
5.1The application was published on public access in addition to standard councillor and extended resident consultation. A Site Notice was issued for display.
6.0Third Party Representations
6.1Comments have been received from a large number of local residents, councillors, Cambridge Past, Present and Future and The Friends of St Matthew’s Piece. These can be viewed in full via Public Access using the reference 23/0119/TTPO. Objections are consolidated and summarised in the table at Appendix 1 and a response provided.
6.2Additional comments and questions have been received following the independent structural engineer review. These are provided below at Appendix 2 in full along with the officer response in italics.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.