Resolved
Resolved (by 6 votes to 3) to reject the Officer recommendation to approve the application to excavate a trench to severe roots of protected trees and install a root barrier in accordance with the Officer recommendation. The Delivery Manager outlined minded to refuse reasons: i. The proposal requires development in the form of the excavation of a trench which would sever the roots of trees of outstanding, significant and special value, individually and as part of a group. These trees and the wider group of trees on St Matthew's Piece contribute significantly to public amenity, the urban forest and the character and appearance of the Mill Road Conservation Area, where special attention must be given to the desirability of preserving or enhancing its character and appearance. ii. The excavation and subsequent installation of a root barrier pose an unacceptable risk of harm to the health of the trees and there was no certainty that the root barrier would work as a solution to damage to the building 193 Sturton Street. The risk of harm to health was not considered to outweigh the trees’ amenity value (including but not limited to their visual, atmospheric, climate, biodiversity, historical and cultural benefits). A material loss of public amenity value, including harm to the Conservation Area, the urban forest and St Matthew's Piece - a highly valued protected open space in Petersfield ward with very limited open space – could arise from the works and result in a decline in the health of the trees and potentially their premature removal. iii. The proposal would, therefore, be contrary to Cambridge Local Plan policies 14, 55, 59, 61, 67 and 71, NPPF 2023 paras.131 and 174, NPPG guidance para. 090 Reference ID: 36 090-20140306 and para. 093 Reference ID: 36-093-20140306, Section 72 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 and other legislation, policies and guidance that seek to safeguard the environment. Unanimously resolved to accept the minded to refuse reasons. Resolved (by 8 votes to 0 with 1 abstention ) not to accept the Officer recommendation and to refuse the application for the reasons above.