CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cambridge City Council
Planning, Wednesday 6 November 2024 at 10.00am

24/0413/TTPO Sturton Street

Refused Planning 3 papers

Planning refused this item on Wednesday 6 November 2024. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item24/111/Plan

Resolved

Resolved (by 6 votes to 3) to reject the Officer recommendation to approve the application to excavate a trench to severe roots of protected trees and install a root barrier in accordance with the Officer recommendation. The Delivery Manager outlined minded to refuse reasons: i. The proposal requires development in the form of the excavation of a trench which would sever the roots of trees of outstanding, significant and special value, individually and as part of a group. These trees and the wider group of trees on St Matthew's Piece contribute significantly to public amenity, the urban forest and the character and appearance of the Mill Road Conservation Area, where special attention must be given to the desirability of preserving or enhancing its character and appearance. ii. The excavation and subsequent installation of a root barrier pose an unacceptable risk of harm to the health of the trees and there was no certainty that the root barrier would work as a solution to damage to the building 193 Sturton Street. The risk of harm to health was not considered to outweigh the trees’ amenity value (including but not limited to their visual, atmospheric, climate, biodiversity, historical and cultural benefits). A material loss of public amenity value, including harm to the Conservation Area, the urban forest and St Matthew's Piece - a highly valued protected open space in Petersfield ward with very limited open space – could arise from the works and result in a decline in the health of the trees and potentially their premature removal. iii. The proposal would, therefore, be contrary to Cambridge Local Plan policies 14, 55, 59, 61, 67 and 71, NPPF 2023 paras.131 and 174, NPPG guidance para. 090 Reference ID: 36 090-20140306 and para. 093 Reference ID: 36-093-20140306, Section 72 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 and other legislation, policies and guidance that seek to safeguard the environment. Unanimously resolved to accept the minded to refuse reasons. Resolved (by 8 votes to 0 with 1 abstention ) not to accept the Officer recommendation and to refuse the application for the reasons above.
Word for word from the decision Cambridge published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cambridge.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cambridge's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning

Planning Committee Date 6 November 2024 Report to Cambridge City Council Planning Committee Lead Officer Joanna Davies Reference 24/0413/TTPO Site Sturton Street Ward / Parish Petersfield Proposal Excavate a trench to severe roots of protected trees and install a root barrier to prevent future growth in the vicinity of 193 Sturton Street Presenting Officer Joanna Davies Reason Reported to Application was called in, objections to the proposed Committee removals have been received from residents, and Friends of St Matthew’s Piece. Decision was deferred at July Committee.

Recommendation Grant consent subject to conditions 1.0 Executive Summary

1.1In 2022 tree work application 22/0271/TTPO was received to reduce the height by 5m and spread by 4m of three London Plane trees located within the grounds of St Matthews Centre opposite 193 Sturton Street. This application was refused at committee because of incomplete data supporting the application, the lack of heave assessment and the lack of information regarding the installation of a root barrier.

1.2In 2023 the subsequent application 23/0119/TTPO was received to fell the three London plane trees opposite 193 Sturton Street. This application was also refused at planning committee because the damage associated with the retention of the trees was not considered to outweigh their amenity value and a material loss of public amenity value, including harm to the conservation area would result from their loss.

1.3The current application concerns the same three trees and the subsidence damage to 193 Sturton Street. However, following the refusal of previous applications to manage the trees above ground the current application seeks to manage the trees below ground by removing and preventing the regrowth of roots in close proximity to 193 Sturton Street. The current application was brought before members at 24 July but the decision was deferred to allow a site visit and additional questions regarding the location of the barrier to be answered.

1.4Numerous objections to the trees’ removals have been received from residents, and other groups but this application does not seek to remove or prune the trees.

1.5As part of the previous application an independent chartered structural engineer, confirmed technical data supports a causal link between the trees and damage to the building and that the risk of heave associated with tree removal is minimal. This led to the previous decision not refuting the alleged damage, however, following 24th committee members remain unsatisfied that the level of damage requires the extent of mitigation proposed and that there is a causal link between damage and the subject trees.

1.6Authorities are encouraged to bear in mind that they may be liable to pay compensation for loss or damage as a result of refusing consent or granting consent subject to conditions. Underpinning 193 Sturton Street is a likely result of refusing permission to install a root barrier. Therefore any claim for compensation would be expected to increase.

1.7Members may refuse consent, grant consent unconditionally or grant consent subject to conditions/informatives. Officers’ recommendation consent is granted subject to conditions.

2.0Site Description and Context

None-relevant Tree Preservation Order X

Conservation Area X Listed Building NA

*X indicates relevance

2.1The St Matthews Centre is located on the corner of Sturton Street and New Street within the Mill Road conservation area. The TPOd trees on the west, north and east boundaries of St Matthews Centre form part of a larger group that extends into the adjacent St Matthews Piece, one of the three open spaces cited to have significance in the conservation area appraisal.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
24/0413/TTPO Sturton StreetReport 472 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
App3 24_0413_TTPO /111/PlanReport 116 KB Download
PDF
App4 24_0413_TTPO /111/PlanReport 65 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

10 of 10 attended
MS
Councillor Martin SmartChair, present
DB
Councillor Dave BaigentVice-Chair, present
NB
Councillor Naomi Bennett Green (Spokes)Committee Member, apologies, sent representative
RD
Councillor Robert DrydenCommittee Member, present
AG
Councillor Alice GilderdaleCommittee Member, present
MH
Councillor Matthew HowardCommittee Member, present as substitute
NL
Councillor Nadya LokhmotovaCommittee Member, present
KP
Councillor Katie Porrer Lib Dem (Spokes)Committee Member, present
KT
Councillor Katie ThornburrowCommittee Member, present
MT
Councillor Mike Todd-JonesCommittee Member, present

On this subject at Cambridge

Search all
  1. 24/0413/TTPO Sturton StreetThis decision
  2. 24/0413/TTPO Sturton StreetDeferred

More from Cambridge Planning

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
4 Nov 2026 26/02186/FUL Coldham's Common, Pool Way, Whitehill RoadResolved (by 7 votes to 0) to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommenda... Decided Open
24 Jun 2026 25/04187/FUL Hanover Court and Princess CourtResolved (by 4 votes to 3) to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommenda... Agreed Open
24 Jun 2026 25/03323/FUL 73 Newmarket RoadResolved (4 votes to 4 – and on the Chair’s casting vote) to grant the application for planning permission in accorda... Agreed Open
24 Jun 2026 26/01081/FUL 9, 11, 15 and 17 Ashfield RoadResolved (by 6 votes to 0) to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommenda... Decided Open
24 Jun 2026 26/01400/FUL 1, 2, 3, 4, 11, 12 The GreenResolved (by 5 votes to 0) to grant the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommenda... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies