Resolved
Resolved (by 7 votes to 0) to refuse the application for planning permission in accordance with the Officer recommendation, for the reasons set out in the Officer’s report and amended above (with delegated authority to Officers to make amendments to the reasons in consultation with the Chair, Vice Chair and Spokes). Draft reasons for refusal on application 23/04380/FUL (Ditton Walk): 1. Policy 27 refers to site specific development opportunities. The policy states that proposals shall be supported at these sites subject to any issues of flooding or contamination are addressed, design considerations, satisfactory access and other infrastructure and other requirements where policy dictates are provided. Policy 35 of the Cambridge Local Plan dictates developments will not lead to significant adverse effects and impacts on health and quality of life/amenity from noise and vibration. The proposal fails to appropriately address noise impact issues from the operation of the existing neighbouring oil depot on the future occupants of the proposed dwellings and is therefore contrary to policy 35. As the proposal fails to adhere to other requirements where other policy dictates, the proposal fails to accord with policy 27. Therefore, the principle of the development is unacceptable and is contrary to policy 27 of the Cambridge City Local Plan (2018). 2. There has been insufficient information submitted regarding the potential harm to the future occupants of the dwellings in relation to the neighbouring oil depot. In the absence of a robust BS4142 assessment it is not possible to establish if the package of noise mitigation proposed is satisfactory in mitigating the potential adverse noise impacts for future occupants both externally and internally. The proposal would fail to integrate into the area where existing businesses ( Certas Oil depot) operate. From the lack of a robust assessment and suitable mitigation measures to address the existing noise levels from the oil dept, future occupants would likely experience adverse levels of noise from the operation of the existing business which will likely result in complaints which the local authority have a duty to act upon. This action could result in unreasonable restrictions being placed on the operation of the depot. The proposal is contrary to policies 27 and 35 of the Cambridge City Local Plan (2018), paragraphs 125 c), 135. f), 187. e), 198. a) and 200 of the NPPF (2024), and the Greater Cambridge Sustainable Design & Construction SPD (2020). 3. The proposed development sees the removal of trees on site that are protected (TPO). Although the proposal sees the retention of a group of trees known as 'G1' (located along the boundary between the site and neighbouring oil depot) three other protected trees are being removed (Trees T 1,T 2 and T3). The layout of the proposal fails to respect the value of these trees and ultimately fails to respond to their retention. The application is therefore contrary to policies 59, 71 of the Cambridge City Local Plan (2018). 4. The proposal fails to provide adequate pedestrian walkways and footpaths throughout the site, resulting in pedestrians and vehicular traffic sharing an access. The lack of pedestrian walkways would not allow for safe manoeuvring around the site and poses an issue to those who are visually impaired as there would be no discernible difference in the paving proposed to those who may use an aid such as a cane when walking. The application fails to incorporate inclusive access and is therefore contrary to policies 56, 59 of the Cambridge City Local Plan (2018) and paragraph 117 of the National Planning Policy Framework (2024). 5. The proposal fails to provide adequate cycle storage in accordance with local policy and guidance. Plot 12 sees cycle parking provided exclusively to the front, cycle parking on all other plots are provided via a split arrangement with cycle storage to the front and rear of the plots. As per Appendix L of the Cambridge City Local Plan (2018), cycle parking should be located at the front of the house and should be as convenient as car parking. The split store arrangement does not accord with this requirement as the spaces to the rear of the dwellings are not to be considered as convenient as car parking. The plans provided show cycle storage would not be of a size that would be of an appropriate size to accommodate the number of cycles required. As the proposal fails to provide adequate cycle parking arrangements on site the proposal is contrary to polices 57, 82 and Appendix L of the Cambridge City Local Plan (2018) and the Cycle Parking Guide for New Residential Developments (2010).