RESOLVED – That the minutes of the above meeting be received. When making its decision a record of the voting was taken as follows:- For the proposal Councillors A Baker, B Baker, N Baker, Baldock , Brazier, Butcher, Clark, A Cook, S Cook, Dixey, Doyle, Eden-Green, Fawcett, Fitter-Harding, Hirst, Howes, R Jones, MacCaul, Samper, Sonnex, Spooner, I Stockley, J Stockley, A Taylor, I Thomas, R Thomas, Todd, Walker, Waters, Westgate and Williams (31) Against the proposal None Abstained from voting Councillor Metcalfe (1) Absent from the meeting during the voting on this item Councillor L Jones (1)
Word for word from the decision Canterbury published for this meeting.Source: democracy.canterbury.gov.uk
Minutes of a meeting held on Wednesday, 16th November, 2016 at 1.00 pm in The Guildhall, St Peter's Place, Westgate, Canterbury
Present: Councillor S Cook (Chairman) Councillor N Baker Councillor Bartley Councillor Eden-Green Councillor Fitter-Harding Councillor L Jones (In place of Councillor Fawcett) Councillor R Jones (In place of Councillor A Taylor) Councillor Todd Councillor Wimble
In attendance
Officers: Colin Carmichael - Chief Executive Matthew Archer - Head of Democratic Services Edmund Baird - Trainee Strategy and Democracy Officer
357 APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE
Apologies for absence had been received from Councillors A Taylor, Baldock and Fawcett.
358 SUBSTITUTES MEMBERS
Councillor R Jones was present as a substitute for Councillor A Taylor and Councillor L Jones was present as a substitute for Councillor Fawcett.
359 DECLARATIONS OF INTERESTS BY MEMBERS OR OFFICERS
The following voluntary announcements were made:
Councillor Eden-Green was a member of the Oaten Hill and District Society, South Canterbury Residents’ Association, St. Mildred’s Area Community Society and the Wincheap Society.
Councillor N Baker was an alumnus of Simon Langton Grammar School for Boys.
Councillor L Jones was a member of the Licensing Committee.
360 PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
There were no public speakers for the meeting.
-1- 361 MINUTES OF THE LAST MEETING
The minutes of the meeting held on 10 October 2016 were confirmed as a true record and signed by the Chairman.
362 GOVERNANCE REPORT OCTOBER 16 - MOUNTFIELD PARK
The Assistant Director of Planning and Regeneration introduced the report, which proposed alternative speaking arrangements at the special meeting of Planning Committee that will consider the South Canterbury planning application. It was noted the Governance Committee had previously agreed a recommendation on alternative speaking arrangements, which had been referred to full Council. The Chief Executive had pointed out to Council that there were some concerns about the allocation system, which were intended to enable local residents groups to make representations. He asked that the matter be deferred. Council resolved to refer the issue back to the Governance Committee and gave the Committee delegated authority to agree alternative public speaking arrangements. The revised proposals sought to address the concerns by introducing new qualifying criteria whereby a residents’ group that had submitted a representation during the consultation period could be allocated a speaking slot.
Councillors asked for clarity on the speaking rights of Ward Councillors and County Councillors. It was advised that Ward Councillors are not counted as public speakers and that County Councillors have no direct right to speak, but could register as a member of public.
There was a suggestion that because the implications impacted on Kent County Council functions, County Councillors should be invited to speak. It was advised that there had already been a formal submission from the officers of Kent County Council in response to the consultation.
There was a discussion about the qualifying criteria and whether the ‘tiers’ of residents groups offered some representatives more than one opportunity to make their points. It was noted that the Chairman of the Planning Committee would encourage those speaking on the application to make separate points to ensure arguments are not being repeated.
There were three options available to Councillors:
Option 1 – to set aside the normal speaking arrangements as set out in the Constitution for the purposes of this planning application, and to adopt the proposals set out in paragraph 2.4 of the report.
Option 2 – agree the arrangements presented to the Governance Committee on 10 October 2016 which are referred to in paragraph 1.5 of the report.
Option 3 – to retain existing public speaking arrangements.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Council - Thursday, 16 July 2026RESOLVED Record of voting For (34): Councillor Alan Baldock, Councillor Mike Bland, Councillor Keith Bothwell, Counci...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.