Decision-making would move further away from each authority and therefore individual Members. It was essential for Members to be able to scrutinise decisions of the company and that they had all the necessary and relevant information available to them in order that they could uphold their duty to residents. The decision to keep customer services and revenues and benefits in house should be kept under strict review but it provided CBC with the opportunity to shape these front facing services with a different view in conjunction with other partners. There was a strong belief among some Members that keeping these services in house was in the very best interests of the council and its residents. A Member made particular reference to the £159k savings target identified in the Medium Term Financial strategy from including customer services and revenues and benefits in the proposals. He highlighted that CBC’s current collection rate was 98 % compared to the national average of 97% and questioned whether this rate could be maintained within a company model. Based on £45 million received by the council a year, a 1% decrease represented £450k which in his view illustrated the scale of the risk ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
Word for word from the decision Cheltenham published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cheltenham.gov.uk
Report on the Updated Business Case and Next Stage Development of the 2020 Partnership (Original June 2016 - Updated for Joint Committee 30 September 2016)
September 2016 1. Background 1.1 In June 2014 the four GO Shared Services Partner Councils approved a “Report and Outline Business Case for a “2020 Vision for Joint Working””. In that report there was an agreed proposition:
1.2“Four Independent Councils determining their own policies, priorities and decisions supported by a small number of expert advisors who commission and monitor services either from the private and voluntary sectors or from local authority owned service delivery companies.”
1.3It was recognised that the proposition could effectively lead to councils that do not directly employ any of their own staff, but rather, Councils will jointly own a local authority company which would provide services and deliver outcomes in line with the wishes of each individual council.
1.4Subsequently, in December 2014 the four 2020 Partner Councils approved a “Report on Options for Future Delivery Models and Interim Management Arrangements” prepared by Activist Ltd. In the report Activist carried out an option appraisal of the long-listed sourcing options, evaluating each option against the outcomes framework set out below:
Table 1.1: Outcomes Framework
Outcome Contributory outcomes Savings Delivers realistic and sustainable revenue savings. Provides a positive return on investment in the medium to long term. Enables us to make further savings through partnership and better asset management. Enables opportunities for income generation. Influence Respects our separate identities as individual authorities. Ensures our decision making will remain locally accountable. Strengthens our ability to exercise community leadership on behalf of our localities. Allows us to retain strong local knowledge in our frontline services. Each authority has impartial commissioning and client side advice from people they trust. Quality Enhances and maintains good quality services to the public. Allows us to nurture our partnerships and take advantage of new ones. Creates organisations that are flexible and adaptable to future changes. Has governance and structures that are streamlined and easy to understand. Is widely acknowledged to be socially responsible. Creativity Empowers staff to be creative, collaborative and enquiring. Supports our commitment to a public service that responds to and empowers our local communities. Fosters and rewards an innovative, can-do approach to delivering services. 1.5 The report was not designed to be a definitive final assessment of the merits of each option and acknowledged that more work should be conducted to confirm the final preferred option based on a business case which is both robust and realistic.
1.6The overall results of the option appraisal carried out by Activist are shown in the table below and suggest a clear advantage for either a sharing option or a local authority company.
Table 1.2: Summary of Option Appraisal of Long-listed Sourcing Options
Options Outcomes Shortlist? Key Issues Savings Sovereignty Quality Creativity In-house L H M L No Lacks scale transformation economies. Private sector L M L M No Poor ROI. joint venture Long lead- in. Sharing H H M M Yes Tried and tested. Local authority H H M M Yes Local company experience. Spin-out to L M M M No Poor ROI mutual or trust Long lead- in.
1.7The report concluded that whilst there was no significant difference in terms of the outcomes, based on the financial assessment the approach recommended was to establish a shared services arrangement under a Joint Committee and then move to a Local Authority owned company model, both dependent upon business cases.
1.8It is noted that the report set out the key differences between the shared service under a Joint Committee and the company model as follows:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Leisure and Culture Services ContractRESOLVED THAT: 1. an extension to the management agreement between the council and The Cheltenham Trust until 30 Sept...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.