CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cheltenham Borough Council
Planning Committee, Thursday 19 January 2017 at 6.00pm

16/01790/FUL Cheltenham Ladies College, Malvern Road

Refused Planning 6 papers

Planning Committee refused this item on Thursday 19 January 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item87

Resolved

Permit Letters of Rep: 11 Update Report: (i) Officer Comments (ii) Additional representation EP introduced the application as above, to add six retractable floodlights to the existing hockey pitch. These would to 15m high when extended, 3.5m when retracted, with controls on usage – until 7.00pm Monday to Friday, and until 6.00pm on Saturdays. A lighting report was submitted with the application; its findings have been verified and are acceptable. Officers accept that the proposal will have some impact on neighbours, but deem this to be temporary. There are no objections from highways officers. On balance, the application is considered to be acceptable. Public Speaking [name removed], neighbour, in objection Although this proposal will cause personal distress to those living close to the site due to light intrusion to their properties, neighbours are more concerned about the harm to the conservation area brought about by 15m-high floodlights, which will dwarf houses and trees and dominate the skyline. This will have an overwhelmingly negative impact and be quite out of keeping with the conservation area. The NPPF sets out that new development should have positive impact, but there is no public benefit from this application, and the school’s undoubted economic success is clearly not dependant on the installation of these floodlights. On the contrary, the proposal will cause harm, and in conditions of mist and drizzle, the light level will be as much as 50 lux. Any need for these lights has not been demonstrated – the school desires them rather than needs them, even though pupils prefer indoor sports to outdoor team-based activity. If hockey was timetabled for the morning, the question could be asked as to why a second pitch is needed at all? In addition to this, there are potential road safety concerns when the floodlights are illuminated, causing bright light and dark shadow to fall between buildings on the adjacent road near the junction. This can be lethal, as the eye takes time to react. With additional traffic from visiting schools, all road users will be at risk from accident and injury. If this application is permitted, in an E2 zone in a conservation area, it will set a new precedent for Cheltenham, and floodlights will be allowed anywhere by referencing this decision. For these reasons, the application must be refused. [name removed], applicant, in support The subject of this application was first introduced as part of integrated plan for all sport, health and fitness facilities, in November 2015. The floodlighting element of the scheme was subsequently withdrawn before Planning Committee, to allow for the College’s lighting consultant to respond to questions from the independent lighting consultant appointed by CBC officers – did not want to put the College’s name to an application whose technical specifications were ... view the full minutes text for item 87.
Word for word from the decision Cheltenham published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cheltenham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cheltenham's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

APPLICATION NO: 16/01790/FUL OFFICER: [name removed] REGISTERED: 4th October 2016 DATE OF EXPIRY: 29th November 2016

WARD: Lansdown PARISH:

APPLICANT: Cheltenham Ladies' College

AGENT: Evans Jones Ltd

LOCATION: Cheltenham Ladies College, Malvern Road, Cheltenham

PROPOSAL: Erection of 6no. retractable lighting columns to provide illumination of the 'old astro pitch' at Cheltenham Ladies' College Playing Field.

RECOMMENDATION: Permit

This site map is for reference purposes only. OS Crown Copyright. All rights reserved Cheltenham Borough Council 100024384 2007 1. DESCRIPTION OF SITE AND PROPOSAL 1.1 The application site is an existing astroturf hockey pitch – commonly referred to as the ‘old astro pitch’. It is located within the Cheltenham Ladies College (CLC) playing fields which adjoin the sports centre facilities which are currently being extended (approved by ref: 15/01171/FUL). The site is accessed off Malvern Road.

1.2The site is within the Eldorado character area of the central conservation area. The Glenlee Boarding House and the swimming pool building which front Malvern Road are locally indexed.

1.3Planning permission is sought for 6 floodlighting columns at the old astro pitch; 3 on each side of the pitch. These are a maximum of 15m high however they retract to 3.5m. Each column would support 3 lamps. The floodlight model is Abacus Challenger 1 sports floodlights. They feature flat style optics and use compact double ended 2kw metal halide lamps. They also include side and rear spill screening shields.

1.4Planning application ref: 15/01171/FUL was approved by committee in November 2015. This proposal was for:

Erection of new sports hall building to provide multi use sport hall, replacement squash courts and ancillary facilities. Demolition of existing squash court building and partial demolition of single storey structure attached to Glenlee House. Alterations to piers to side of access onto Malvern Road.

This application originally included 6 floodlights, however these were withdrawn from the scheme prior to the committee determination in order to allow for further work to be carried out to respond to the queries which had been raised.

1.5The proposed floodlight is the same model as previously proposed with the main change being that it now retracts to 3.5m as opposed to 4.5m. However further information has been provided which has allowed for more detailed analysis and scrutiny of the proposal.

1.6This application is being determined by committee at the request of Cllr Mason.

2. CONSTRAINTS AND RELEVANT PLANNING HISTORY Constraints: Conservation Area Honeybourne Line Smoke Control Order

Relevant Planning History:

95/00342/PF 24th June 1996 REF APPEAL To Provide Floodlighting To The Existing All Weather Sports Pitch

96/00158/PF 21st March 1996 REF Provision Of Floodlighting To The Existing All Weather Sports Pitch

11/01125/FUL 31st October 2011 PER Erection of new sports hall building to provide three indoor tennis courts and ancillary facilities, revised parking and replacement squash court building following demolition of existing squash court building 11/01126/CAC 31st October 2011 GRANT Demolition of existing squash court building

15/01171/FUL 20th November 2015 PER Erection of new sports hall building to provide multi use sport hall, replacement squash courts and ancillary facilities. Demolition of existing squash court building and partial demolition of single storey structure attached to Glenlee House. Alterations to piers to side of access onto Malvern Road.

16/00433/DISCON 20th April 2016 DISCHA Discharge of conditions 6 (landscaping scheme) and 10 (surface water drainage) of Planning Permission 15/01171/FUL, Erection of new sports hall building to provide multi use sport hall, replacement squash courts and ancillary facilities. Demolition of existing squash court building and partial demolition of single storey structure attached to Glenlee House. Alterations to piers to side of access onto Malvern Road.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
16/01790/FUL Cheltenham Ladies College, Malvern RoadReport 335 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Additional representation, 17th JanuaryReport 611 KB Withheld: personal details
PDF
CLC rebuttal statement, 19th JanuaryReport 610 KB Download
PDF
Cheltenham Ladies College: report update, 19th JanuaryReport 70 KB Download
PDF
Cheltenham Ladies College: representationsReport 9 MB Withheld: personal details
PDF
LOR 17 Christ Church Road 18.01.17Report 277 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting
84Minutes of last meetingApproved 8616/01756/CONDIT Travis Perkins, Brook RoadRefused
8716/01790/FUL Cheltenham Ladies College, Malvern RoadThis decision

Who was there

18 of 19 attended
GB
Councillor Garth BarnesChair, present
BF
Councillor Bernard FisherVice-Chair, present
PB
Councillor Paul BakerCommittee Member, present
MC
Councillor Mike CollinsCommittee Member, present
CH
Councillor Colin HayCommittee Member, apologies, sent representative
KH
Councillor Karl HobleyCommittee Member, present
AL
Councillor Adam LillywhiteCommittee Member, present
HM
Councillor Helena McCloskeyCommittee Member, present
CN
Councillor Chris NelsonCommittee Member, present
TO
Councillor Tony OliverCommittee Member, present
LS
Councillor Louis SavageCommittee Member, present
DS
Councillor Diggory SeacomeCommittee Member, present

All 19 on the meeting page

On this subject at Cheltenham

Search all
  1. 16/01790/FUL Cheltenham Ladies College, Malvern RoadThis decision
  2. 20/01371/FUL Balcarras School, East End Road, Charlton Kings, Cheltenham GL53 8QFAgreed
  3. 18/02053/FUL, 48 Swindon Road, CheltenhamDeferred
  4. 19/00388/FUL, Berkhampstead School, Pittville Circus Road, CheltenhamRefused
  5. 19/00550/FUL,103 Linden Avenue, Prestbury, CheltenhamRefused
  6. 19/00088/FUL 16 Rowena Cade Avenue, Cheltenham, GloucestershireDecided

More from Cheltenham Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
21 Aug 2025 Declarations of InterestIt was agreed that this does not constitute a prejudicial interest, and he was therefore not required to leave the Ch... Agreed Open
17 Jun 2021 Any other items the Chairman determines urgent and requires a decisionIt was agreed that it was not relevant, the Chair disagreed as he thought that it was good to see that it was a mix o... Agreed Open
17 Dec 2020 20/01371/FUL Balcarras School, East End Road, Charlton Kings, Cheltenham GL53 8QFAgreed that the proposal was positive and had to be supported to cover the capacity required. It was the best that co... Agreed Open
17 Sep 2020 Minutes of last meetingRESOLVED THAT The minutes of the meeting held on 20 th August 2020 were approved and signed as a correct record. Approved Open
18 Jun 2020 ApologiesRESOLVED THAT Councillor McCloskey be appointed as Vice-Chair on a temporary basis. Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies