CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cheltenham Borough Council
Planning Committee, Thursday 23 March 2017 at 6.00pm

17/00114/FUL 3 Church Street, Charlton Kings

Refused Planning 2 papers

Planning Committee refused this item on Thursday 23 March 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item111

Resolved

Permit Letters of Rep: 1 Update Report: Yes BH introduced the application as above, at Committee at the request of Councillor Paul McCloskey, in view of the special features of the plot. Officers have concerns about the impact of the proposed extension on the existing building and on the conservation area; revisions have been suggested, but the applicant wants the proposal to be considered as it is. The recommendation is therefore to refuse. Public Speaking: [name removed], neighbour, in objection Lives at Waterloo Cottage, one of three linked cottages built around 1815. The application next door is for a 1.5-storey contemporary extension to replace the single storey conservatory. This will impact on the conservation area – St Mary’s Charlton Kings was designated in 2009, and the adopted legislation specifically mentions Church Street for its historic buildings and architectural importance. The local authority has a statutory duty to ensure that the future enhancement and preservation of the area is taken into consideration when applications are assessed. If permitted, this application will encourage other contemporary extensions, which will gradually erode the area, making the designation meaningless. The owners of the three cottages were aware of these compliances when they bought their homes, and these should be upheld now. A 1.5-storey extension is inappropriate in size and style, with conflicting roof form and dominance, detracting from the appearance of the historical cottages when it should in fact be blending in with the local character and not of a contemporary design which stands out as too modern – it should complement the existing cottage in material and design. Strongly disagrees with the architect’s comment that the extension is insignificant compared to existing buildings, that it improves the general views, and that it will not be visible from the conservation area. If built, its size and differing materials certainly will impact on its surroundings, and will not comply with the conservation mandate to ‘enhance and preserve’. It will be clearly visible from Church Street and her own side garden. Has no objection to the replacement of the existing conservatory as a single storey on the original footings. Built of similar materials, it would enhance and preserve the existing buildings, within the guidelines of the conservation area and in line with character appraisals for the area. [name removed], architect, in support Has made hundreds of planning and listed building applications over the last 40 years, and this is only the second time has has felt the need to address committee, having usually been able to agree design alterations with officers. Feels the planning office has made an extreme and very subjective assessment of this proposal, and is being inappropriately protective of the conservation area – which goes against the planning principal that development should be permitted as long as it causes no substantial harm to the significance ... view the full minutes text for item 111.
Word for word from the decision Cheltenham published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cheltenham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cheltenham's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

APPLICATION NO: 17/00114/FUL OFFICER: [name removed] REGISTERED: 20th January 2017 DATE OF EXPIRY: 17th March 2017

WARD: Charlton Kings PARISH: Charlton Kings

APPLICANT: [name removed]: Michael Lumley Associates

LOCATION: 3 Church Street, Charlton Kings, Cheltenham

PROPOSAL: Two storey rear extension to form kitchen/dining and living space

RECOMMENDATION: Refuse

This site map is for reference purposes only. OS Crown Copyright. All rights reserved Cheltenham Borough Council 100024384 2007 1. DESCRIPTION OF SITE AND PROPOSAL 1.1 The application site relates to a mid-terraced residential property on Church Street, located within The St Mary’s conservation area.

1.2The applicant is seeking planning permission for the erection of a two storey rear extension to provide further living accommodation.

1.3The application has been called to committee on behalf of the applicant at the request of Councillor Paul McCloskey, who would like members to appreciate the specific features of the plot.

2. CONSTRAINTS AND RELEVANT PLANNING HISTORY

Constraints: Conservation Area Smoke Control Order

Relevant Planning History:

None applicable

3. POLICIES AND GUIDANCE Adopted Local Plan Policies CP 4 Safe and sustainable living CP 7 Design

Supplementary Planning Guidance/Documents Residential Alterations and Extensions (2008) St. Mary's conservation area character appraisal and management plan (June 2009)

National Guidance National Planning Policy Framework

4. CONSULTATIONS

Parish Council 7th February 2017

No objection

5. PUBLICITY AND REPRESENTATIONS

Number of letters sent 4 Total comments received 1 Number of objections 1 Number of supporting 0 General comment 0

5.14 letters were sent to neighbouring properties, a site notice was displayed and an advert was published in the Gloucestershire Echo. 5.2 One letter of objection has been received from the neighbouring property at number 5 Church Street whose concerns relate to the following:

 Impact on the conservation area

 Scale and form

 Design and materials

 Loss of light and over shadowing

6. OFFICER COMMENTS 6.1 Determining Issues

6.2The main considerations of an application of this nature are design, impact on neighbouring amenity and any impact on the character of the conservation area.

6.3Location and layout

6.4The application site forms the middle property in a row of 3 traditional cottages on Church Street which front on to St Mary’s Church and is centrally located in the St Mary’s Conservation area. Within the St Mary’s (Charlton kings) Conservation area character appraisal and management plan 2009, the application site is noted as a positive building.

6.5The application site has an unusual land allocation. The main private amenity space extends across the rear of the neighbouring property of number 5 Church Street. The proposed extension will sit behind this neighbouring property, but will not be attached to it.

6.6Design

6.7The existing property has an existing poor quality conservatory which is in no longer fit for purpose and therefore a replacement extension is being proposed. The existing conservatory is an inappropriate addition to the existing building and therefore its removal is considered to be a positive part of the scheme.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
17/00114/FUL 3 Church Street, Charlton KingsReport 142 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
3 Church Street: representationReport 2.7 MB Withheld: personal details

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

16 of 22 attended
GB
Councillor Garth BarnesChair, present
BF
Councillor Bernard FisherVice-Chair, present
PB
Councillor Paul BakerCommittee Member, present
MC
Councillor Mike CollinsCommittee Member, present
CH
Councillor Colin HayCommittee Member, present
KH
Councillor Karl HobleyCommittee Member, apologies
AL
Councillor Adam LillywhiteCommittee Member, present
HM
Councillor Helena McCloskeyCommittee Member, present
CN
Councillor Chris NelsonCommittee Member, present
TO
Councillor Tony OliverCommittee Member, present
LS
Councillor Louis SavageCommittee Member, present
DS
Councillor Diggory SeacomeCommittee Member, present

All 22 on the meeting page

On this subject at Cheltenham

Search all
  1. 17/00114/FUL 3 Church Street, Charlton KingsThis decision
  2. 17/00087/FUL Atherstone, 17 Church RoadRefused
  3. 16/01402/FUL 64 Church RoadRefused
  4. 15/00517/FUL Hesters Way Baptist ChurchAgreed
  5. 14/02152/FUL 113 Church Road, LeckhamptonApproved
  6. 14/02003/FUL Unit 3, Naunton Park Industrial Estate, Churchill RoadDeferred

More from Cheltenham Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
21 Aug 2025 Declarations of InterestIt was agreed that this does not constitute a prejudicial interest, and he was therefore not required to leave the Ch... Agreed Open
17 Jun 2021 Any other items the Chairman determines urgent and requires a decisionIt was agreed that it was not relevant, the Chair disagreed as he thought that it was good to see that it was a mix o... Agreed Open
17 Dec 2020 20/01371/FUL Balcarras School, East End Road, Charlton Kings, Cheltenham GL53 8QFAgreed that the proposal was positive and had to be supported to cover the capacity required. It was the best that co... Agreed Open
17 Sep 2020 Minutes of last meetingRESOLVED THAT The minutes of the meeting held on 20 th August 2020 were approved and signed as a correct record. Approved Open
18 Jun 2020 ApologiesRESOLVED THAT Councillor McCloskey be appointed as Vice-Chair on a temporary basis. Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies