Resolved
Permit Letters of Rep: 3 Update Report: None CC introduced the application to remove the whole horse chestnut tree, which takes up the whole front garden of the house. It has a TPO, so the recommendation is to permit, subject to a replacement tree of a more appropriate nature being planted in its place. Public Speaking: None. Member debate: BF: surely it would be unwise to plant a replacement tree in the same spot; the residents could end up with the same problem in 70 years. AH: would like to make the case to keep the tree. It has been there substantially longer than the buildings, and is one of very few trees in the area. Cheltenham is known for its trees; they are part of the town’s heritage. This is a healthy tree, and cannot agree with it being ripped away. MC: doesn’t like chopping down beautiful trees, and this has been there for ever. But has been on site and read the officer report; this tree has a few problems. The report talks about removing and replacing the tree, saying that it would have to be removed in 15 or so years anyway; if a tree is planted in its place now, it will be reasonably mature in 15 years. Will be sad to see it go, as it is beautiful tree; wouldn’t normally support its removal. SW: is a great tree lover, and will be sad to see this tree removed, but it does carry disease. It was there before the houses, before the current residents moved in – so it could be said that if they didn’t like the tree, they shouldn’t have moved in. However, CC wouldn’t recommend the removal of a tree without good cause. This tree is diseased and far too large for the site. Will vote for it to go, though reluctantly. Will be happier if something more suitable is planted in its place. LS: the report states that the horse chestnut has leaf miner. Is no expert in lepidoptery but the issue is the health of the tree, and there isn’t enough detail about this in the report. Is it likely to fall down, to fall on the house, will it recover from the leaf miner or not? Is it part of the eco system, or terminal for the tree? This is an important consideration, and is uncomfortable if a precedent is set to take trees down at the first sign of disease. HM: supports SW. CBC is fortunate to have a professional, dedicated tree officer who does his best to support and preserve trees wherever he can. If he says it should go, it should go. CC, in response: - horse chestnut leaf miner is a perennial problem, causing the leaves of the tree to turn brown and crispy. It will look healthy and verdant in Spring ... view the full minutes text for item 183.