CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cheltenham Borough Council
Planning Committee, Thursday 17 August 2017 at 6.00pm

17/01369/TPO 37 Griffiths Avenue

Agreed Planning 3 papers

Planning Committee agreed this item on Thursday 17 August 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item183

Resolved

Permit Letters of Rep: 3 Update Report: None CC introduced the application to remove the whole horse chestnut tree, which takes up the whole front garden of the house. It has a TPO, so the recommendation is to permit, subject to a replacement tree of a more appropriate nature being planted in its place. Public Speaking: None. Member debate: BF: surely it would be unwise to plant a replacement tree in the same spot; the residents could end up with the same problem in 70 years. AH: would like to make the case to keep the tree. It has been there substantially longer than the buildings, and is one of very few trees in the area. Cheltenham is known for its trees; they are part of the town’s heritage. This is a healthy tree, and cannot agree with it being ripped away. MC: doesn’t like chopping down beautiful trees, and this has been there for ever. But has been on site and read the officer report; this tree has a few problems. The report talks about removing and replacing the tree, saying that it would have to be removed in 15 or so years anyway; if a tree is planted in its place now, it will be reasonably mature in 15 years. Will be sad to see it go, as it is beautiful tree; wouldn’t normally support its removal. SW: is a great tree lover, and will be sad to see this tree removed, but it does carry disease. It was there before the houses, before the current residents moved in – so it could be said that if they didn’t like the tree, they shouldn’t have moved in. However, CC wouldn’t recommend the removal of a tree without good cause. This tree is diseased and far too large for the site. Will vote for it to go, though reluctantly. Will be happier if something more suitable is planted in its place. LS: the report states that the horse chestnut has leaf miner. Is no expert in lepidoptery but the issue is the health of the tree, and there isn’t enough detail about this in the report. Is it likely to fall down, to fall on the house, will it recover from the leaf miner or not? Is it part of the eco system, or terminal for the tree? This is an important consideration, and is uncomfortable if a precedent is set to take trees down at the first sign of disease. HM: supports SW. CBC is fortunate to have a professional, dedicated tree officer who does his best to support and preserve trees wherever he can. If he says it should go, it should go. CC, in response: - horse chestnut leaf miner is a perennial problem, causing the leaves of the tree to turn brown and crispy. It will look healthy and verdant in Spring ... view the full minutes text for item 183.
Word for word from the decision Cheltenham published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cheltenham.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cheltenham's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Committee

APPLICATION NO: 17/01369/TPO OFFICER: [name removed] REGISTERED: 14th July 2017 DATE OF EXPIRY: 8th September 2017

WARD: St Marks PARISH:

APPLICANT: [name removed]: Falcon Lettings

LOCATION: 37 Griffiths Avenue, Cheltenham

PROPOSAL: Horse Chestnut in front garden - complete removal

RECOMMENDATION: Permit

This site map is for reference purposes only. OS Crown Copyright. All rights reserved Cheltenham Borough Council 100024384 2007 1. DESCRIPTION OF SITE AND PROPOSAL 1.1 This is a 20m+ high and wide Horse Chestnut tree within in a small courtyard garden within St. Marks Conservation Area. This property development is 11 years old and the tree is considerably older. The tree owner wishes to fell the tree entirely.

2. CONSTRAINTS AND RELEVANT PLANNING HISTORY Relevant Planning History: 00/00937/FUL 11th September 2000 REF Proposed conversion of existing dwelling(s) to six flats, two new dwellings and garaging

01/01641/FUL 6th February 2002 PER Proposed amendments to approved scheme under 00/00937/FUL, (three additional dwellings) within approved new structures (Revised Plan)

04/01434/DEMCON 23rd September 2004 NPRIOR Demolition of existing building

04/01811/OUT 29th November 2004 WDN Construction of four storey building comprising 21 apartments and pair of semi-detached houses

04/02137/OUT 23rd February 2005 REF Construction of four-storey building comprising 21 apartments and pair of semi-detached houses - resubmission of revised scheme following withdrawal of application under CBC Planning Ref. 04/01811/OUT

05/00520/OUT 23rd June 2005 PER Construction of residential development comprising two pairs of semi-detached dwellings, three storey terrace comprising 4no. townhouses and 5no. apartments with associated car parking

05/01749/REM 20th February 2006 APREM Approval of reserved matters following grant of 05/00520/OUT (two pairs of semi-detached dwellings, three storey terrace comprising 4no. townhouses and 5no. apartments with associated car parking)

3. POLICIES AND GUIDANCE Local Plan

Policy GE5: The Borough will resist the unnecessary felling of trees on private land and will make Tree Preservation Orders in appropriate places. For protected trees the Council will require: a) Any tree which has to be felled to be replaced where practicable.

4. CONSULTATIONS

Cheltenham Tree Group 6th August 2017 Site visited on 06/08/17. Noted too are the photos in relation to the surrounding buildings, which clearly have been built after the tree. In that area, there is little such amenity from other trees in the close locale, though it is noted that there is support for complete removal on safety and other grounds. Given that there may be other options available - a factual check on the health of the tree, pruning or branch removal as an alternative, would be two examples - we would 'object' to complete removal, until the CBC Tree Officer is satisfied no other alternative exists. Replacement with a more suitable tree is noted and welcomed.

5. PUBLICITY AND REPRESENTATIONS 6. Number of letters sent 15 Total comments received 3 Number of objections 1 Number of supporting 2 General comment 0

6.115 adjacent neighbours were written to and 2 site notices erected nearby.

7. OFFICER COMMENTS 7.1 Determining Issues

This is a fully grown mature pollarded Horse Chestnut which pre-dates the adjacent property. It is growing in a small courtyard garden and several neighbouring properties are within falling distance. However, the tree is in good structural condition and branch or limb failure is not anticipated during normal weather conditions.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
17/01369/TPO 37 Griffiths AvenueReport 140 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
37 Griffiths Avenue: additional representation, 17th AugustReport 51 KB Withheld: personal details
PDF
37 Griffiths Avenue: representationsReport 32 KB Withheld: personal details

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

16 of 18 attended
GB
Councillor Garth BarnesChair, present
BF
Councillor Bernard FisherVice-Chair, present
PB
Councillor Paul BakerCommittee Member, present
MC
Councillor Mike CollinsCommittee Member, present
CH
Councillor Colin HayCommittee Member, expected
KH
Councillor Karl HobleyCommittee Member, present
AL
Councillor Adam LillywhiteCommittee Member, present
HM
Councillor Helena McCloskeyCommittee Member, present
CN
Councillor Chris NelsonCommittee Member, present
TO
Councillor Tony OliverCommittee Member, present
LS
Councillor Louis SavageCommittee Member, present
DS
Councillor Diggory SeacomeCommittee Member, apologies, sent representative

All 18 on the meeting page

More from Cheltenham Planning Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
21 Aug 2025 Declarations of InterestIt was agreed that this does not constitute a prejudicial interest, and he was therefore not required to leave the Ch... Agreed Open
17 Jun 2021 Any other items the Chairman determines urgent and requires a decisionIt was agreed that it was not relevant, the Chair disagreed as he thought that it was good to see that it was a mix o... Agreed Open
17 Dec 2020 20/01371/FUL Balcarras School, East End Road, Charlton Kings, Cheltenham GL53 8QFAgreed that the proposal was positive and had to be supported to cover the capacity required. It was the best that co... Agreed Open
17 Sep 2020 Minutes of last meetingRESOLVED THAT The minutes of the meeting held on 20 th August 2020 were approved and signed as a correct record. Approved Open
18 Jun 2020 ApologiesRESOLVED THAT Councillor McCloskey be appointed as Vice-Chair on a temporary basis. Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies