It was proposed by Councillor Danny Gee, seconded by Councillor Geoff Russell, to grant planning permission of the retrospective planning application. An amendment to the motion was proposed by Councillor Dennis Edgerley, seconded by Councillor Eric Bell, and was subsequently RESOLVED (7:6) with the Chair using his casting vote to refuse planning permission for the follows reasons: 1. The site is located within the Green Belt wherein caravan storage is not expressly in any of the categories of appropriate development allowable in such areas given in Policy DC1 of the Chorley Borough Local Plan Review, Policy 6 of the Joint Lancashire Structure Plan and PPG2. Caravan storage is therefore by definition inappropriate development and as such, very special circumstances must exist in order to justify planning permission being granted. In this case, the very special circumstances advanced in support of the application are not considered to be of sufficient weight to justify planning permission being granted. 2. The caravan storage results in detrimental harm to the open rural character and appearance of the Green Belt and is therefore prejudicial to the purposes land being included within the Green Belt, contrary to Policy DC1 of the Adopted Chorley Borough Local Plan Review, Policy 6 of the Joint Lancashire Structure Plan and PPG2. 3. The imposition of a Grampian style condition to secure the proposed highway junction improvement works would be unenforceable and therefore inappropriate as the use to which this application relates is already taking place. Given the vehicular access to the site is as existing substandard in terms of width and visibility, the increased vehicular movements are likely to increase the risk of accidents to the detriment of highway safety, contrary to Policy TR4 of the Adopted Chorley Borough Local Plan Review if the said works were not carried out.
Word for word from the decision Chorley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.chorley.gov.uk
Item B. 6 07/00453/COU Refuse Full Planning Permission
Case Officer [name removed] Euxton North
Proposal Retrospective application for the change of use of residential curtilage and a further parcel of land to enable the storage of 25 additional caravans
Location Park View Runshaw Lane Euxton Chorley PR7 6HD
Applicant Mr & [name removed] application relates to land to the rear of the property known as Park View, which is located on Runshaw Lane, Euxton in the Green Belt.
The application relates to the continued use of the land, which comprises of part residential curtilage and a further parcel of land abutting the northern boundary of this for caravan storage. The application increases the number of caravans from the presently lawful 10 that can be stored within the residential curtilage up to 35 caravans comprising of an additional 20 within the residential curtilage and a further 5 on the adjoining land. The positions of the caravans are shown on the attached plan although it should be noted that both parcels of land are already being used to store caravans hence the requirements of the Enforcement Notice are being breached.
Background Members will recall authorising the issue of an Enforcement Notice when the unauthorised storage of caravans on the land in question was reported to Development Control Committee in March 2004 following an earlier enforcement investigation. An appeal against this Enforcement Notice was subsequently dismissed in November 2004 although in his decision, whilst upholding the Enforcement Notice, the Inspector varied its terms by allowing the storage of up to ten caravans together with any caravan used solely for a purpose incidental to the enjoyment of Park View as a dwelling house on the southern half of the appeal site (the residential curtilage/garden). This was because the Inspector considered that the appellant had demonstrated a lawful use for the storage of ten caravans on this particular part of the site.
Planning History Apart from the aforementioned upholding of the Enforcement Notice at appeal, albeit encompassing a variation of its terms, a planning application for the change of use of land from residential to private leisure and caravan park (the applicant’s intention being to operate a low key recreational facility for users of caravans parked on the site) was refused in 2004 (9/04/00279/COU). A subsequent appeal against this decision was withdrawn by the applicant.
Members will also recall that in 2005 a further planning application (05/00198/COU), for the change of use of the applicant’s residential curtilage to caravan storage only was submitted following the Inspectors decision on the Enforcement Notice appeal. This application proposed the storage of 30 caravans in addition to the 10 allowed following the Inspectors decision. This application was reported to Development Control Committee on the 5th April 2005 and refused planning permission. Following this, an appeal was made and heard at a Hearing. The Inspector dismissed this appeal as he concluded that the storage of caravans was inappropriate development in the Green Belt. The Inspector also concluded that the proposed highway improvement works could not be the subject of a Grampian condition because the use of the land had already commenced.
Three planning applications for the erection of a dwelling were submitted in the late 1950s and early 1960s and refused although they have no relevance to this application.
Applicant’s Case Further to the refused 2005 application (05/00198/COU) and subsequent dismissed appeal, by virtue of the application now to hand, the applicant proposes storage of 5 caravans on the further portion of land to the north of the residential curtilage as well as 20 within the residential curtilage although this use is already taking place. The applicant asserts the following in support of this new application: -
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.