RESOLVED (9:3) that the Councils case at appeal is that the Council would have recommended approval of the application on the basis of the change of circumstances resulting from the recent appeal being allowed, with Councillors Alistair Bradley, Alan Cain, Henry Caunce, Harold Heaton, Adrian Lowe, Simon Moulton, Mick Muncaster, Geoff Russell and Shaun Smith voting for the proposal and Councillors Ken Ball, Julia Berry, and David Dickinson voting against the proposal, with Councillors Terry Brown, Roy Lees, Greg Morgan and June Molyneaux abstaining.
Word for word from the decision Chorley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.chorley.gov.uk
Corporate Director (Business) Development Control Committee 22 July 08
APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL OF PLANNING PERMISSION FOR ERECTION OF 16 DWELLINGS AT 54 LANCASTER LANE.
PURPOSE OF REPORT 1. To highlight advice provided by the Councils barrister regarding the Councils case and the likely success at appeal including the potential for incurring costs. There has been change to the material considerations as a result of the appeal decision on a smaller site at Lancaster Lane.
RECOMMENDATION(S)
2. That the Council’s case at appeal is that the Council would have recommended approval of the application on the basis of the change in circumstances resulting from the appeal being allowed.
REASONS FOR RECOMMENDATION(S) (If the recommendations are accepted) The Council must reconsider its position in light of the recent appeal decision and the award of costs against the Council. Failure to assess the risk of continuing with the appeal would increase the liability and an award of costs against the Council from fighting the appeal based on the members concerns and the reasons for refusal.
CORPORATE PRIORITIES
3. This report relates to the following Strategic Objectives:
Put Chorley at the heart of regional √ Develop local solutions to climate economic development in the change. Central Lancashire sub-region Improving equality of opportunity √ Develop the Character and feel of √ and life chances Chorley as a good place to live Involving people in their √ Ensure Chorley Borough Council is √ communities a performing organization
Updated Template December 2007 BACKGROUND
6. Following the submission of the appeal against the refusal of planning permission Giles Cannock was instructed to provide the Council with advice on the Councils case and the implications of maintaining its opposition to the appeal proposal. At the previous appeal an award of costs was made against the Council and Giles Cannock’s advice was also sought regarding the likelihood of cost being awarded on the current appeal.
7. The advice from Giles Cannock is copied below in full.
ADVICE
1. On 20th December 2007, Wainhomes Developments Limited (“the Appellant”) made an application for demolition of 54 Lancaster Lane and the erection of 19 new dwellings including associated infrastructure on land to the rear of 46 to 60 Lancaster Lane. In a notice, dated 14th March 2008, Chorley Borough Council (“the LPA”) refused planning permission. The Applicant has appealed. The Planning Inquiry to determine the appeal is listed for 2 days from 25th September 2008.
2. I am asked to advise the LPA on the presentation of its evidence at the Public Inquiry.
3. I have had sight of:
(i) Decision letter dated 23rd June 2008 (Application Ref: 07/00685/FUL);
(ii) Appeal Questionnaire (Application Ref: 07/01423/FULMHA).
Factual Background 4. On 5th June 2007, Wainhomes Developments Limited (“the Applicant”) made an application to the LPA for the erection of 5 detached houses and 2 bungalows at 54 Lancaster Lane, Clayton-le-Woods, Leyland (“Application 1”).
5. In a notice, dated 13th September 2007, the LPA refused planning permission for the first application (contrary to Officer Recommendation) for the following reason:
“The proposal would constitute over development of the site and would be out of character with the surrounding area. In particular the surrounding area is characterised by residential properties with large garden areas. As such the proposal is considered to be contrary to Policy HS4 of the Adopted Chorley Borough Local Plan Review and Government advice contained in PPS3: Housing.”
6. On 20th December 2007, Wainhomes Developments Limited made an application for demolition of 54 Lancaster Lane and the erection of 19 new dwellings including associated infrastructure on land to the rear of 46 to 60 Lancaster Lane (“Application 2”).
7. In a notice dated 14th March 2008, the LPA refused planning permission for the following reason:
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.