Resolved
Planning permission refused. It was proposed by Councillor Harold Heaton, seconded by Councillor David Dickinson, and upon being put the recorded vote at the request of Councillor Julia Berry was subsequently RESOLVED (11:0) to refuse planning permission, with Councillors Julia Berry, Alistair Bradley, Terry Brown, Henry Caunce , David Dickinson, Harold Heaton, Roy Lees, June Molyneaux , Greg Morgan, Simon Moulton, Mick Muncaster and Geoff Russell voting for the proposal for the following reasons: 1. The proposed development would be located within the Green Belt as defined by the North West Regional Spatial Strategy Policy RDF4 and the Adopted Chorley Borough Local Plan Review. The proposed development is contrary to Policy DC1 of the Adopted Chorley Borough Local Plan Review and PPG2: Green Belts as in the Green Belt there is a presumption against inappropriate development, which this would be. It is not considered that the arguments put forward in support of the application are sufficient very special circumstances to outweigh the presumption against it in the Green Belt. 2. Although the position of the building on the site is acceptable, it is considered a layout more closely reflecting the footprint of the public house that originally stood on the site would be more appropriate. The scale of the proposal is considered unacceptable in terms of its mass (particularly when viewed from the front), being too great, particularly the large dormer window and the unacceptably large front roof slope. The layout and scale is therefore considered contrary to Policy HT7 of the Adopted Chorley Borough Local Plan Review. 3. The proposal would result in the felling of a significant protected tree to enable the access to be widened. The application is therefore contrary to Policy EP9 of the Adopted Chorley Borough Local Plan Review which states that proposals which would result in the loss of trees which make a valuable contribution to the character of the landscape or a building or settlement or its setting will not be permitted.