Refuse on grounds of lack of parking places for disabled people and drop-off points. It was proposed by Councillor Kenneth Ball, seconded by Councillor Alistair Bradley, and subsequently RESOLVED that planning permission be refused for the following reason: “The proposed change of use as a doctor’s surgery is located within an area where there is limited parking and only short term on-street parking. There is no parking provided within the application site, resulting in longer distances to walk for the mobility impaired and less able patients. As there will be a high frequency of visitors to this expanded surgery the on-street short stay parking will not provide a suitable and capable solution and will result in longer travel distances that will for groups that need access to such facilities result in them being discouraged from visiting contrary to RSS Policy TR2 that requires disabled provision for such uses of 3 spaces and there is no justification in this case for a reduction.
Word for word from the decision Chorley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.chorley.gov.uk
Item 4 09/01016/COU Permit Full Planning Permission
Case Officer [name removed] Chorley East
Proposal Conversion of retail units to form Doctors Surgery - change of use from A1 to D1
Location 225 - 227 Eaves Lane Chorley Lancashire PR6 0AG
Applicant J Y Kinsha
This application was deferred for a site visit at the previous Development Control Committee.
Proposal The proposal involves the conversion of former shop premises to form a doctor’s surgery for two GPs and a health nurse. There will be no changes to the front elevation and on the rear elevation an existing door will be built up and a high level window put in its place and the insertion of an additional high level window.
Policy SP6, GN5, TR4
Planning History 07/01151/FUL: Conversion of one shop back into two Withdrawn Decision Date: 22 November 2007
Consultations Lancashire County Highways – There is a controlled pedestrian crossing directly outside the front of this property and the controlled zone for the same prevents on street parking for staff and patients alike. Nonetheless, it is expected that the catchment area for the surgery will be local and given that there is alternative parking in nearby bays and side streets there are no highway objections.
Representations • Lack of off –street parking will result in patients and staff parking on adjoining residential streets • Need a residents parking scheme in the area • Loss of residential amenity due to potential overlooking from rear windows
Applicant’s Case - proposal is to replace an existing surgery premises 0.5km to the north on Eaves Lane which are becoming inadequate and difficult to comply with DDA - envisaged that the majority of patients will visit on foot as is the case for with the existing surgery - parking is available on Eaves Lane and drop off points for disabled people are close to the premises - the building will be secure as there are already shutters to the front windows and the new high level windows will have security grills to the inner faces Assessment The property is within a terrace predominantly of shops and is identified on the Local Plan Proposals as being within a neighbourhood shopping centre. The Local Plan explains that these serve as locations for local and specialist uses, including retailing, food and drink as well as offices. A doctor’s surgery comes within the range of uses appropriate to a local centre and the only issue to be resolved concerns car parking. The Eaves Lane centre has no dedicated off-street parking for any of the units but it is relevant that may patients to the existing premises visit on foot. The Highway Authority have no objections and it is not considered that a refusal on the grounds of lack of parking could be substantiated on appeal. There will be no problem of overlooking of properties to the rear as the windows proposed are high level and are into the nurses room and a toilet.
Conclusion The proposed change of use will replace an existing surgery with larger more usable premises. It is located in the neighbour centre to serve the local community, many of whom may walk. The issue of car parking is relevant but given the nature of the centre the use is unlikely to make the situation worse given that the property could be used for a high traffic generating use such as food and drink. It is considered that the use is a valuable amenity the community benefit of which overcomes the objection on lack of off – street parking.
Recommendation: Permit Full Planning Permission Conditions
1. The proposed development must be begun not later than three years from the date of this permission. Reason: Required to be imposed by Section 51 of the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.