Resolved
Minded to refuse full planning permission. Members of the Committee were reminded that the applicant had appealed to the Planning Inspectorate against non-determination of the application as the Council had not made a decision on the application within the 8 week statutory period. It was proposed by Councillor Ralph Snape, seconded by Councillor Simon Moulton and subsequently unanimously RESOLVED – Members of the Committee were minded to refuse full planning permission for the following reasons: 1. Part of the proposed development (the 4 dwellings backing onto Shaw Hill Drive) is on land which is presently garden land not allocated for housing in the Chorley Borough Local Plan Review. In response to recent changes to Planning Policy Statement 3 (PPS3), the Council has prepared an Interim Policy on Private Residential Garden Development which seeks to resist residential development taking place on private garden land unless certain criteria area met or there are exceptional circumstances. In this case, the proposed dwelling does not meet one of the three criteria listed in the Policy nor are there considered to be exceptional circumstances that weight in favour of approving the development. 2. The Shaw Hill area is made up of large individually designed detached properties on generously proportioned plots. The individual nature of the properties and the size of the plots mean that the character of the area has its own local distinctiveness which is dominated by landscaping. The provision of large detached dwellings that have not been designed in response to the local character results in a development that would erode this local distinctiveness whilst the density of the development, being higher than that of Shaw Hill, results in dwellings on smaller plots. The smaller plot sizes result in less space between the dwellings and less space for landscaping. The development would therefore be harmful to the local character and distinctiveness of Shaw Hill contrary to Policy GN5 and criteria (b) of Policy HS4 of the Chorley Borough Local Plan Review and Planning Policy Statement 1 (PPS1) and Planning Policy Statement 3 (PPS3). 3. Part of the development (the 4 dwellings backing onto Shaw Hill Drive) is on a site within the settlement boundary of Whittle-Le-Woods on an unallocated and un-developed ‘Greenfield’ garden land site. It has not been demonstrated that there are no other suitable allocated or previously developed sites available within the settlement and as such the proposal is contrary to criteria (f) of Policy HS6 of the Chorley Borough Local Plan Review and PPS3: Housing.