RESOLVED (unanimously) – 1. That delegated authority be given to the Director of Public Protection, Streetscene and Community, to be exercised in consultation with the Chair of Development Control Committee to allow the removal of the requirement for a section 106 agreement where such an obligation had been imposed by a resolution made at Development Control Committee contrary to the Ministerial Statement relating to tariff based contributions for Public Open Space and / or affordable housing. 2. Such delegated authority would be exercised in accordance with a decision made on a Judicial Review application challenging the validity of the Ministerial Statement.
Word for word from the decision Chorley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.chorley.gov.uk
Report of Meeting Date Director of Public Protection, Development Control Committee 16 June 2015 Streetscene and Community
DELEGATION FOR APPLICATIONS TO ADDRESS THE JUDICIAL REVIEW CHALLENGE OUTCOME
PURPOSE OF REPORT 1. To seek authority to amend resolutions for approval made by Development Control Committee which impose a section 106 agreement contrary to the Ministerial Statement of November 2014, in the event a Judicial Review challenge to this statement fails. RECOMMENDATION(S)
2. That delegated authority is given to the Director of Public Protection, Streetscene and Community, to be exercised in consultation with the Chair of Development Control Committee to allow the removal of a the requirement for a section 106 agreement where such an obligation has been imposed by a resolution made at Development Control Committee contrary to the Ministerial Statement relating to Tariff based contributions for Public Open Space and / or affordable housing. 3. Such delegated authority to be exercised in accordance with a decision made on a Judicial Review application challenging the validity of the Ministerial Statement.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY OF REPORT 4. There are at least 10 applications where a resolution to approve has been made at a Committee meeting in the past 6 months and a section 106 agreement has been imposed to secure Public Open Space payments. The Government has clarified its position in respect of removing the ability to secure Tariff style contributions to state that the Ministerial Statement is National Policy. A legal challenge has been made to the original Ministerial Statement and decision to remove the ability to impose tariff style contributions and the outcome was due to be handed down before the agenda for this Committee was released but was not. If the outcome of the legal challenge is that the Government’s decision to prevent tariff style contributions was legally compliant then in order to be efficient and effective in the handling of applications and issuing decisions at the earliest possible date, authority is sought to allow those applications, already determined and approved to be issued without a section 106 agreement.
Confidential report Yes No Please bold as appropriate
CORPORATE PRIORITIES
5. This report relates to the following Strategic Objectives:
Involving residents in improving their local A strong local economy Y area and equality of access for all Clean, safe and healthy communities An ambitious council that does more Y to meet the needs of residents and the local area BACKGROUND
6. The Government issued a Ministerial Statement in November, the purported aim was to address alleged significant costs to small scale developments that Tariff style contributions. The Statement directed that such contributions could not be imposed on developments of 10 or less dwellings or where there is a scale of development of less than 1000m2. This decision was challenged in the High Court by several Councils on the basis that the issuing of the Ministerial Statement was procedurally flawed, was not supported by evidence, failed to address responses to a consultation exercise and did not address the stated aims of the Minister. The hearing took place on 14 and 15 May 2015 and it was estimated that the outcome would be released in about 4 weeks and that period was due to finish by 5 June.
Assessment
7. The decision on the Judicial Review has not yet been handed down. The absence of this judgement leads to continuing uncertainty for both the public and the planning service who are unable to confidently process some planning applications. This uncertainty in the correct approach to these applications provides opportunity to applicants to appeal.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.