That Standing Order 6 of Part A Appendix 3 to the Constitution (and the relevant procedure rules at Part E) be suspended, with the right of the public to speak at Council meetings being removed and the procedure detailed at Paragraph 16 being implemented. 2. That this suspension of standing orders and implementation of the temporary changes is to continue until further decision by the Council.
Word for word from the decision Chorley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.chorley.gov.uk
1. Members are asked to agree to a temporary suspension of Standing Orders to reduce in scope the right of the public to speak at Full Council and Executive Cabinet meetings.
Recommendations
2. That Standing Order 6 of Part A Appendix 3 to the Constitution (and the relevant procedure rules at Part E) be suspended, with the right of the public to speak at Council meetings being removed and the procedure detailed at Paragraph12 below being implemented.
3. That this suspension of standing orders and implementation of the temporary changes is to continue until further decision by the Council.
Reasons for recommendations
4. Whilst it is a requirement that meetings of the Council are held in public, there is no statutory right for the public to address the meeting.
5. At the meeting on 27 February last the meeting was disrupted when a member of the public abused their rights in the constitution, leading to the meeting being suspended and the police being called to clear the room.
6. There is a real risk of this happening again.
Other options considered and rejected
7. To not suspend standing orders. This was considered carefully as there is no real history of disruption of council meetings by the public at this authority. However, it was considered how serious the disruption was and the perceived threat to staff and councillors. Further, the matter which lead to the disruption (whilst being outside the control of the council) is ongoing and unlikely to be resolved I the immediate future.
8. To close the meetings to the public. This is viewed as a step too far. Peaceful protest should be permitted and indeed it is a legal requirement that the meetings should be open to the public. Should the disruption continue or become more significant then this decision can be revisited.
Background to the report
9. The Constitution permits members of the public to ask questions of the Council at council meetings. These are required to be related to an item on the agenda for that meeting and there are procedures to notify the council of their intention in order to make it a valid public questions.
10. This procedure enables the council to focus on appropriate business, ie matters within its control, but enable members of the public to raise directly with the council local issues of concern.
11. On 27 February last, a public question was submitted concerning housing (2 other questions were also correctly received). The question was responded to by the relevant executive member. The member of the public was invited to ask a supplemental question which the constitution permits. This should be related to the initial question.
12. The supplemental question quickly strayed away from the primary question and into the situation in Gaza. The member of the public was reminded on a number of occasions that the supplementary question must be related to the primary question. After being repeatedly ignored by the member of the public, the Mayor adjourned the meeting.
13. There were further issues which led to the police being called and the chamber being cleared of members of the public. On resumption of the meeting the substantive business of the meeting was concluded.
14. A number of councillors have expressed concern over their safety at the meeting as a result of this incident, feeling threatened by the public just by their participation at the meeting and by the actual conduct of the public at the meeting. To be clear other members did not feel threatened at all.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.