CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cornwall Council
Cornwall Harbours Board, Thursday 19 March 2026 at 2.00pm

Fal Fishery Cooperative C.I.C

Decided Committee 3 papers

AI summaryCornwall Harbours Board will exercise the break clause on the Fal Fishery Cooperative CIC lease at Lower King Harry Reach and clear the site in the most cost-effective way for the Port of Truro.

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedTerminate CIC lease and clear the site
MoneyUp to £30,000 clearanceLikely funded by Port of Truro reserve
What happens nextEngage with CIC, give notice3 months prior written notice required
Who it affectsLower King Harry Reach Aquaculture AreaPort of Truro site used for oyster culture

What was decided

Cornwall Harbours Board will exercise the Break Clause on the lease with Fal Fishery Cooperative CIC and engage with them to clear the site in the most cost-effective way for the Port of Truro.

Why

The CIC has not paid rent, with £25,620 in invoiced arrears and £22,560 un-invoiced since invoices were put on hold in January 2024, and the site is neither generating income nor available for other Port of Truro use. Report 3.2, 6.1

The site has not been observed to be active or maintained for some time, creating a risk to the safety of navigation should infrastructure fixings fail. Report 8.1

Repeated communications with the CIC have not closed the matter, despite earlier suggestions they would surrender the site. Report 1.9

What happens next

Give the CIC three months' prior written notice and enforce the break clause terms, including payment of arrears, vacant possession and material compliance with repair covenants. Report 1.10, P10, 2.1

If the CIC does not clear the site, fund clearance from the Port of Truro reserve, with treatment of the outstanding debt considered under the financial regulatory framework. Report 6.1, 10.1

Obtain legal advice throughout the process, escalating any major problems to the Chairman of the Board.

The money

  • £7,000 Year 1 rent agreed in Heads of Terms Report 1.4, P5
  • £8,500 Year 2 rent agreed in Heads of Terms Report 1.4, P5
  • £10,000 Year 3 rent agreed in Heads of Terms Report 1.4, P5
  • £2,000 Rent deposit received to date Report 6.1
  • £25,620 Invoiced rent arrears at January 2024 Report 6.1
  • £22,560 Un-invoiced rent outstanding Report 6.1
  • £48,180 Total CIC debt as of Q1 2026 had account not been on hold
  • in the region of £30,000 Estimated cost to Port of Truro of clearing the site
  • a little under £100,000 Award to CIC from Co-op Foundations Carbon Innovation Fund Round 1 in 2022

Options considered

  • Chosen: Approve process to give notice, terminate the lease, enforce the Break Clause and use Port of Truro Reserve to fund clearance if needed. The CIC is not paying and the site is unused; clearing it allows the Port of Truro to recover the area and limit ongoing financial exposure. Report 10.1
  • Rejected: Do not terminate the lease and allow the CIC to continue operating with a suitable payment plan Report 10.2

Implications

  • Financial: Outstanding invoiced rent of £25,620 and un-invoiced rent of £22,560 is unlikely to be recovered; treatment of the debt will be considered under the financial regulatory framework. Report 6.1
  • Financial: Site clearance could cost around £30,000, to be funded from the Port of Truro reserve account if the CIC cannot pay.
  • Legal: Use of the site is subject to a Lease agreement between Cornwall Council and the CIC; legal advice will be obtained throughout the break clause process. Report 7.1
  • Risk: Failure of infrastructure fixings below the surface poses a risk to the safety of navigation while the site remains inactive. Report 8.1
  • Risk: There is a risk of negative publicity from termination of the lease. Report 8.3

Who and where

  • Fal Fishery Cooperative CIC Report 1.1
  • Port of Truro Report 1.2, 3.1
  • Cornwall Council taxpayers (via the Port of Truro reserve) Report 3.1

Timeline

  • 30/3/2019: Fal Fishery Cooperative CIC was incorporated Report 1.1
  • April 2019: CIC approached the Port of Truro to lease the Lower King Harry Reach Aquaculture Area Report 1.1
  • 16 July 2019: Heads of Terms (ref TH/10037) drafted for a 10-year lease Report 1.2
  • 2022: CIC awarded just under £100,000 from the Co-op Foundations Carbon Innovation Fund Round 1
  • January 2024: Invoices put on hold after CIC fell behind on payments; £25,620 in rent arrears at that point
  • 15/1/2026: Cornwall Harbours Board Members consulted
  • 21/1/2026: Cornwall Marine Network consulted Report 5.2
  • 25/2/2026: Port of Truro Stakeholder Group consulted Report 5.1
  • Q1 2026: CIC would owe £48,180 to date had the account not been put on hold
  • 19 March 2026: Cornwall Harbours Board resolved to exercise the Break Clause

Plain English for the jargon

  • Break Clause: A lease provision allowing the landlord to end the tenancy on specified conditions, including notice, payment of arrears, vacant possession and repair compliance.
  • CIC: Community Interest Company, a type of limited company set up for community benefit.
  • Lower King Harry Reach Aquaculture Area: The Port of Truro site leased to the CIC for shellfish cultivation.
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemCHB32

Resolved

RESOLVED that Cornwall Harbours Board exercise the Break Clause and engage with the CIC to clear the site in the most cost-effective manner for the Port of Truro.
Word for word from the decision Cornwall published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cornwall.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cornwall's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cornwall Harbours Board, 5 pages

Executive summary

1.1Fal Fishery Cooperative CIC was incorporated on 30/3/2019. In April 2019 the CIC approached the Port of Truro and sought to lease the Lower King Harry Reach Aquaculture Area. This followed initial engagement, by a founding Director, in January 2019 seeking information of the availability of the area.

1.2The proposal, detailed in an email received by the Port of Truro on 3rd May 2019, confirmed the use of the site to be for the storage and growth of native oysters. Heads of Terms (ref TH/10037) were drafted for the Lease on 16th July 2019 for a 10-year period.

1.3Permitted use of the site was for the culture and study and processing of native oysters (Ostrea Edulis). For the storage of Mussels (Mytilus Spp.), variegated Scallops (Aquepectin Opucularis) and other shellfish harvested by license under the Fal Fishery Regulatory Order 2016 with prior approval.

1.4The agreed rent was:

• Year 1 rent - £7,000 • Year 2 rent - £8,500 • Year 3 rent - £10,000

1.5A 3-month rent free period was detailed in the Heads of Terms, increased to 5 months at the request of the CIC, was granted from the commencement of the lease order to get his infrastructure in place and begin farming oysters. 1.6 The CIC commenced fundraising in 2019 via Crowdfunder as detailed in Appendix 1. In 2022 the CIC was awarded a little under £100,000 from the Co- op Foundations ‘Carbon Innovation Fund – Round 1’. 1.7 To date the only payment received by the Port of Truro is the rent deposit of £2000. Invoices were put on hold in January 2024 when it became clear the CIC were not making payments against their account despite efforts by Credit Management and Truro Harbour Office. At the time of placing the account on hold, in January 2024, the CIC owed £25,620 in rent payments. The CIC overall would owe £48,180 as of Q1 2026 to date had the account not been put on hold.

1.8The CIC claimed that their debt was not owed and referred us to a Motion presented to Cornwall Council in March 2021. This motion was tabled by Cllr Kirkham on Tuesday 23 rd March 2023. The minutes state that the Motion was referred to Cabinet. At the July 2021 Cornwall Council meeting the Leader confirmed that Members had met to discuss the motion on support for Cornwall’s shell fishing industry. The discussions noted that representations to government made by Cornwall Council had resulted in changes to the support on offer and, whilst gaps remained, it was felt that the current offer was comprehensive and was being accessed by industry. Further funding had been secured from the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) to support the cost of Export Health Certificates until 1 September 2021. Consultation with industry stakeholders would establish an interim, but still discounted level, for 6 to 12 months with full cost recovery fee after that if no further funds could be secured.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
20260319 Harbours Board: Fal Fishery Cooperative C.I.C: Appendix 1: PUBLICAppendix 1 pages Download
PDF
20260319 Harbours Board: Fal Fishery Cooperative C.I.C: Appendix 2: PUBLIC.docxAppendix 4 pages Download
PDF
Fal Fishery Cooperative C.I.CReport 5 pages DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

More from Cornwall Cornwall Harbours Board

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
9 Jul 2026 Election of ChairmanRESOLVED that Councillor Rogers be elected Chairman. Councillor Rogers thereupon took the Chair and thanked Members f... Noted Open
9 Jul 2026 Election of Vice-ChairmanRESOLVED that Councillor Alvey be elected Vice-Chairman. To note: Drystan Jones was not present and left the room dur... Noted Open
9 Jul 2026 Minutes of the Meeting Held on 19 March 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the meeting of the Cornwall Harbours Board held on 19 March 2026 were correctly recorded... Decided Open
9 Jul 2026 Cornwall Harbours Board Budget Outturn April 2025 - March 2026RESOLVED that the Board noted and approved the Harbour’s performance against budget and subsequent reserve movements. Noted Open
9 Jul 2026 Cornwall Harbours Board Budget Monitor April 2026 - May 2026RESOLVED that the Board noted and approved the Harbour’s performance against budget and subsequent reserve movements. Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies