AI summaryCornwall Council's Audit Committee took assurance on risk management and counter-fraud arrangements, noting that the Climate Change and Financial Sustainability strategic risks both increased in score this quarter.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedOn risk management and strategic and counter-fraud risk arrangements
MoneyNo direct financial implicationsCommittee is not being asked to approve spending
What happens nextWorkshop in October 2026Risk appetite statement to November Audit Committee
Who it affectsCouncil's customers and residentsThrough strengthened risk and counter-fraud controls
What was decided
The Committee took assurance that arrangements are in place to provide it with relevant risk management information in year, in line with its Terms of Reference. Report P1, P7
The Committee took assurance that arrangements for strategic risks and the fraud risk assessment framework are in place, and that these risks have been identified and assessed. Report P2, 2.1
Why
The Audit Committee's remit is to obtain assurance that risk management arrangements are in place and working effectively, including fraud risk assessment and monitoring of risk-related issues. Report 1.1, P4, 8.2
Two strategic risk scores rose this quarter: Climate Change and Ecological Breakdown moved from 16 to 20, and Financial and Economic Sustainability from 20 to 25, against a backdrop of a forecast Q1 overspend of £17.008m and £9.915m of red-rated financial risks. Report 2.10, P19
What happens next
A workshop with the Council Director's Team is planned for October 2026 to refresh the strategic risks, with any changes to be reported back to the Audit Committee. Report 2.11, P21
A draft risk appetite statement, including assessment of statutory officers' risk appetite, will be presented to the Audit Committee at its November meeting, alongside plans for member engagement. Report 2.11, P21
The strategic risks and priority risk narratives are to be considered by Cabinet on 23 September as part of the quarter one performance report. Report 2.9
The money
£17.008m Forecast Q1 overspend identified in the Financial and Economic Sustainability risk Report 2.10, P19
£9.915m Red-rated financial risks noted within the Financial and Economic Sustainability risk Report 2.10, P19
83.7% Forecast saving delivery against the approved MTFP target Report 2.10, P19
87.9% Saving delivery forecast when mitigated savings are included Report 2.10, P19
14% Reduction in operational greenhouse gas emissions in the last financial year Report 2.10, P19
45% Overall reduction in operational greenhouse gas emissions from the 2019 baseline Report 2.10, P19
Options considered
Chosen: Take assurance from the report's details on risk and counter-fraud arrangements. Preferred option as set out by officers; arrangements were judged adequate Report 10.1, P42, P44
Rejected: Decline to take assurance and request further information. Not taken up by the Committee Report P42, P44
Implications
Financial: No direct financial implications arise from the recommendations, though effective risk and counter-fraud arrangements support the Council's overall financial sustainability, including exposure to fraud, cyber incidents and economic volatility. Report 6.1, 6.2, 6.3, P30
Legal: The Accounts and Audit Regulations 2015 require adequate financial management and internal control arrangements, including risk management; no adverse legal or governance implications arise from this report. Report 7.1, 7.3, P34
Risk: Two of eight strategic risks have worsened in score this quarter, with continued reliance on external funding and new delivery partnerships flagged for the climate risk, and significant financial pressures flagged for the Financial and Economic Sustainability risk. Report 2.10, P19, 2.8
Staffing: Work to map the audit and fraud universe has begun within the Community and Wellbeing Directorate, with the aim of covering all directorates ahead of next year's audit planning process. Report 2.6, P13
Other: Data quality exceptions in the corporate risk dashboard will continue to be monitored, and a channel shift to a new risk data warehouse will allow a data cleansing exercise to be undertaken. Report 2.10, P19
Who and where
The Council's customers and the residents of Cornwall, who benefit from a strong control environment and effective risk and governance arrangements Report 3.1, P23, P25
Council officers and members, who can access the strategic risk dashboard Power BI through the performance hub Report 2.9
Service areas scheduled for 2026-2027 Counter Fraud reviews: Procurement, Housing Allocations, Concessionary Travel and School Placements Report P12
Timeline
22 May 2026: Risk Management Framework approved by the Audit Committee at its previous meeting Report 2.8, P15, 4.1, P26
23 September: Strategic risks and priority risk narratives to be considered by Cabinet as part of the quarter one performance report Report 2.9
26 June 2026: Strategic risks and associated scores agreed by the Council Directors Team Report 5.1, P28
October 2026: Workshop planned with the Council Director's Team to refresh strategic risks against the latest global risk intelligence Report 2.11, P21
November: Draft risk appetite statement to be presented to the Audit Committee Report 2.11, P21
2026-2027: Counter fraud reviews scheduled for Procurement, Housing Allocations, Concessionary Travel and School Placements Report P12
Plain English for the jargon
MTFP: Medium Term Financial Plan, the Council's multi-year spending and savings plan
NAFN: National Anti-Fraud Network, a body sharing fraud intelligence
CIFAS: Credit Industry Fraud Avoidance System, a fraud data sharing organisation
Three lines of assurance: Model mapping risk controls across operational management, oversight functions and independent internal audit
Residual risk: The level of risk remaining after controls and mitigations are applied
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemA/191
Resolved
RESOLVED that : 1. The Committee takes assurance that arrangements are in place to provide the Committee with the relevant information, in year, to allow them to discharge their duties in regard to Risk Management and in line with its Terms of Reference. 2. The Committee takes assurance that the arrangements in respect of the Council’s strategic risks and the framework by which fraud risks are assessed are in place and that all of these risks have been identified and assessed.
Word for word from the decision Cornwall published for this meeting.Source: democracy.cornwall.gov.uk
1. That the Committee takes assurance that arrangements are in place to provide the Committee with the relevant information, in year, to allow them to discharge their duties in regard to Risk Management and in line with its Terms of Reference. Information Classification: PUBLIC
2. That the Committee takes assurance that the arrangements in respect of the Council’s strategic risks and the framework by which fraud risks are assessed are in place and that all of these risks have been identified and assessed.
Executive summary
1.1It is the remit of the Audit Committee to obtain assurance that risk management arrangements are in place and are working effectively. In line with the Committee’s terms of reference this includes:
• Considering the Council’s framework of assurance and ensure that it adequately addresses the risks and priorities of the Council • Reviewing the assessment of fraud risks and potential harm to the Council from fraud and corruption • Monitoring the effective development and operation of Risk Management in the Council • Monitoring progress in addressing risk-related issues reported to the Committee.
2. Purpose of Report and key information
2.1This report assists the Committee in that it provides assurance in respect of the arrangements currently in place to assess fraud risks to the Council and details plans to support services identify potential fraud risks and ensure that appropriate counter fraud controls are in place. It also provides assurance that the Council has identified, assessed and reviews its strategic risks to the delivery of the business plan and that these risks are aligned to its priorities.
Risk Management Assurance
2.2The Committee is in receipt of reports, in year, in regard to internal audit, risk and counter fraud activities which provide assurance that Risk Management arrangements are in place and working effectively. Together, these reports provide the required assurance as determined in the Committee’s Terms of Reference in relation to Risk management. The diagram below demonstrates the type of reports and details of activities the Committee receives linked to each of the responsibilities. Information Classification: PUBLIC
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Audit Update and Sector BriefingRESOLVED that: That the Audit Committee reviews the External Auditor’s Update and Sector Briefing for Cornwall Counci...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.