CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cornwall Council
Standards Committee, Tuesday 27 October 2026 at 10.00am

Review of the Code of Conduct and Assessment Procedures

Agreed Committee 4 papers

AI summaryCornwall Council's Standards Committee recommended that full Council approve the amended Code of Conduct and agreed complaint procedure changes, including a limit of 1,000 words and delayed publication of complaint details [D]. No direct financial implications were identified [6.1].

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeAgreedComplaint procedures and form revised [D]
MoneyNo financial implications [6.1]None arise directly from this report [6.1]
What happens nextWorking Group review [D]Required before implementation [D]
Who it affectsComplaint handling [D]Complainants, councillors and councils [D]

What was decided

The committee recommended that full Council approve the Code of Conduct as amended at the meeting. Report 7.1

Members agreed that the complaint form should refer to a limit of 1,000 words. The discussion covered submission methods, a direct link to Code provisions, removal of an obsolete fax number, consistency with revised procedures, and inclusion of abuse with harassment.

The revised procedures are intended to reduce publicity about complaint details and identities until assessment concludes. Multiple complaints on the same matter would be assessed on their merits, not their number, to avoid duplication while ensuring complainants receive a formal decision notice, with the Standards Committee Chairman consulted in appropriate exceptional circumstances. Wording for findings of no breach was discussed, with the separate wording for no finding on whether a breach occurred to be clarified; specialist internal or external advice could be sought, and purdah would be replaced with wording for a formal pre election period.

Why

The Code needed amendment because the mandatory part of member training had been removed. Failure to complete training should therefore no longer be treated automatically as a breach. Report 2.3

Cornwall Council has a statutory duty to promote high standards and keep procedures for deciding whether the Code may have been breached. Report 2.1, 3.1

Confidentiality was central to the review, and the working group thought publicity might be driving complaint numbers. The multiple complaint changes aim to avoid duplication while ensuring complainants receive a formal decision notice. Report 2.11

What happens next

The revised procedures and complaint form are to go to the Working Group for a final review before implementation.

The amended Code is to be recommended to full Council for approval. Report 7.1

Internal or external specialist advice may be sought when needed to assist complaint assessment.

Options considered

  • Rejected: Note the report and do no more. The current Code, procedures and complaint form would remain in place. Report P26
  • Chosen: Recommend the Code for approval and approve the procedures and complaint form. The committee made amendments and requested final review by the Working Group before implementation. Report P26

Implications

  • Legal: Code amendments must be referred to full Council for approval under the Constitution. Report 7.1
  • Financial: No financial implications arise directly from this report. Report 6.1
  • Risk: No risks are associated with the report. Report 8.1
  • Legal: No adverse legal or governance implications arise directly from this report. Report 7.1
  • Other: Failure to complete member training is no longer automatically a breach because the mandatory requirement has been removed. Report 2.3
  • Legal: A statutory Code and associated procedures are likely to be introduced in the near future. Report 2.1
  • Other: The revised procedures are intended to reduce complaint publicity until assessment concludes.
  • Other: Some town and parish councils have local variations, while key Code principles and requirements remain broadly consistent.

Who and where

  • Cornwall councillors Report 2.1, 2.3
  • A complainant Report 2.11
  • Town and parish councils
  • Cornwall Council Report 2.1, 7.1
  • A resident Report P11, 3.1

Timeline

  • 20 May 2025: Council approved Code amendments concerning mandatory online training. Report 1.1
  • 31 July 2025: Standards Committee approved changes to the Ethical Standards Complaints Procedures. Report 1.2
  • 2026/27: The work schedule included the Procedures review. Report 1.2
  • 30 July 2026: Committee referred the Procedures to its Working Group. Report 1.2
  • October 2026: Revised assessment procedures were attached for approval. Report P29
  • 09.10.2026: Governance and Legal report clearance. Report P33
  • 12.10.2026: Finance report clearance. Report P33
  • 19.10.2026: Equality and Diversity report clearance. Report P34

Plain English for the jargon

  • Code of Conduct: Council rules for members' conduct and possible breach allegations [2.1].
  • Assessment Procedures: Rules for considering ethical standards complaints [2.5] [3.1].
  • Complaint form: Preferred complaint submission form, including how personal data is used [2.14].
  • Decision Notice: Formal notice of the outcome after complaint assessment [D].
  • Localism Act 2011: Law requiring council Codes and complaint procedures [2.1].
  • formal pre election period: Replacement wording for purdah [D].
  • Working Group: Group asked to review procedures and complaint form before implementation [1.2] [D].
  • Independent Persons: Roles whose involvement in complaint assessment was questioned [D].
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemS/43

Resolved

It was agreed that the complaint form should refer to a limit of 1,000 words. 2. Members discussed the proposed changes relating to confidentiality and publication of complaint details, noting that the intention was to reduce publicity associated with complaints until the assessment process had been concluded. Members also considered the proposed arrangements for exceptional circumstances and noted that the Chairman of the Standards Committee would be consulted where appropriate. 3. It was suggested that references to harassment within the assessment procedures and complaint form should also include abuse. 4. Members discussed the proposed arrangements for dealing with multiple complaints relating to the same matter and noted that complaints would be assessed on their merits rather than the number received. The purpose of the changes was to avoid unnecessary duplication whilst ensuring complainants received a formal decision notice. 5. Members agreed that the term "purdah" should be replaced with "formal pre-election period". 6. Members discussed the wording relating to findings of no breach and no finding of whether there had been a breach, and considered that the latter wording should be clarified to avoid misunderstanding. 7. Members discussed the sources of advice used when assessing complaints and were advised that specialist internal or external advice could be sought where necessary to assist decision-making. 8. A Cornwall Councillor attending for this item welcomed the proposal to withhold the identity of complainants and subject Members until completion of the assessment process and raised questions regarding the role of Independent Persons and the use of external legal advice. 9. Members discussed a number of drafting amendments to the complaint form, including clarification of submission methods, the inclusion of a direct link to the relevant Code of Conduct provisions, removal of an obsolete fax number and amendments to improve consistency with the revised procedures. 10. Clarification was sought regarding the application of the Code of Conduct to town and parish councils and Members were advised that, whilst some councils had adopted local variations, the key principles and requirements of the Code remained broadly consistent. 11. Members requested that the revised procedures and complaint form be circulated for a final review by the Working Group prior to implementation. It was moved by Councillor Alvey, seconded by Councillor Clemens, and RESOLVED to recommend to the Council that the Code of Conduct, as amended at the meeting, be approved.
Word for word from the decision Cornwall published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cornwall.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cornwall's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Standards Committee

Executive summary

1.1At the meeting of Council which was held on 20 May 2025, amendments to the Code were approved which related to mandatory online training however, as mandatory aspect of the online training for members has been removed, the Code now requires further amendment.

1.2At the meeting of the Standards Committee held on 31 July 2025 changes to the Ethical Standards Complaints Procedures were approved and, in accordance with the Standards Committee work schedule for 2026/27, when the Committee met on 30 July 2026 the Procedures, which are attached at Appendix 2, were referred to the Committee’s Working Group for review.

2 Purpose of Report and key information

2.1Whilst it is known that it is likely that a statutory Code (and associated procedures) will be introduced in the near future, at this time Localism Act 2011 requires that all Councils have in place a Code of Conduct and procedures to deal with complaints which are received relating to a potential breach of the Code. 2.2 The Code of Conduct adopted by Cornwall Council meets the requirements of the 2011 Act and the provisions within it are similar to those adopted by all Councils in England. There is also a local advantage in that all Town and Parish Councils in Cornwall have adopted the same Code, making it easier to administer and for a dual hatted Councillor to know which Code binds them when they are acting in their official capacity.

2.3Because of the introduction of mandatory training for Members as from May 2025 the Code for Cornwall Councillors was amended to include the provision that if the mandatory training was not complied with this was automatically seen as a breach of the Code. However, as the requirement for mandatory training has now been removed it follows that these provisions should be removed from the Code which has been amended to reflect this. Information Classification: PUBLIC

2.4As a result, it is recommended that the Committee recommend to Council that the amended Code of Conduct, as attached to this report at Appendix 1, is adopted.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Review of the Code of Conduct and Assessment Procedures: Appendix 1 /43Appendix 212 KB Download
PDF
Review of the Code of Conduct and Assessment Procedures: Appendix 2 /43Appendix 399 KB Download
PDF
Review of the Code of Conduct and Assessment Procedures: Appendix 3 /43Appendix 290 KB Download
PDF
Review of the Code of Conduct and Assessment ProceduresReport 182 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

0 of 19 attended
LJ
Loveday JenkinChairman, expected
PM
Pete MitchellVice-Chairman, expected
MA
Martyn AlveyCommittee Member, expected
RB
Richard BarkerCommittee Member, expected
BC
Brian ClemensCommittee Member, expected
JH
Jay HodgettsCommittee Member, expected
JL
Juliet LineCommittee Member, expected
RM
Robin MoorcroftCommittee Member, expected
AT
Anna Thomason-KenyonCommittee Member, expected
RB
Robert Bishop Non Elected Independent MemberCommittee Member, expected
RD
Reg Davison Non Elected Independent MemberCommittee Member, expected
MD
Meryll Dean Non Elected Independent MemberCommittee Member, expected

All 19 on the meeting page

More from Cornwall Standards Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
27 Oct 2026 Minutes of the Meeting held on 30 July 2026RESOLVED that the Minutes of the Standards Committee meeting held on 30 July 2026 we re correctly recorded and that t... Decided Open
27 Oct 2026 Organisational Complaints Report Quarter 1 - 2026 - 2027RESOLVED that the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman Complaints Report is noted. Noted Open
27 Oct 2026 Ethical Standards Complaints Report - Quarter 2 - 2026 - 2027RESOLVED that the Ethical Standards Complaints Report - Quarter 2 - 2026 – 2027 is noted. Noted Open
27 Oct 2026 Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman - Annual Review Letter 2025 - 2026RESOLVED that the Standards Committee note the Annual Review Letter and the Statistics found at the Appendices to thi... Noted Open
30 Jul 2026 Election of ChairmanRESOLVED that Councillor Jenkin be elected Chairman of the Standards Committee. Councillor Jenkin thereupon took the ... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies