CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cornwall Council
Cabinet, Wednesday 11 November 2026 at 10.00am

Farms Strategy 2019-2039 (2026 Review)

Decided Executive 2 papers

AI summaryCornwall Cabinet selected Scenario 3 for the farms estate, using individual farm assessments and retaining flexibility, with £2.216m of additional investment subject to budget approval. [P3, 6.3, 6.6]

AI summaryIn plain English

Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedIt balances financial performance with the four ambitions. [P7, P112]
Money£2.216m additional investment [6.3]Funding remains subject to affordability, prioritisation and budget approval. [P7, 6.3]
What happens nextFinalise and adopt management plan [P4]Delegated authority covers policy adoption through 2027-2032. [P4]
Who it affectsFarms estate and rural economy [P97]New entrant opportunities remain available. [P97]

What was decided

Cabinet selected Scenario 3 as the preferred approach for the Farms Strategy Operating Business Management Plan. Report P3

The scrutiny committee's findings and recommendations were accepted. Report P2

Authority was delegated to the Head of Property to finalise and adopt the plan for 2027-2032. Report P4

Why

Scenario 3 balances financial and non financial outcomes while meeting the scrutiny recommendations. Report P7, P112

Scenario 2 offers higher returns but would reduce fully equipped holdings and make commitment to all four ambitions harder. Report 6.4, 6.5

Scenario 3 is forecast to improve trading results, maintain capital receipts and retain fully equipped holdings for new entrants. Report P92, P93, P97

What happens next

The Head of Property will amend and finalise the plan with the Monitoring Officer and Section 151 Officer, then adopt it as policy. Report P4

Scenario 3 investment will enter the Capital and Investment Strategy and Medium Term Financial Plan, subject to affordability, Council priorities and the 2027/28 budget process. Report P7, 6.3

Each farm will be considered circa 2 years before its tenancy ends, with unsuitable elements removed where needed. Report P87, P88

The money

  • £4.810m Capital investment over ten years for Scenario 3 Report 6.3
  • £8.835m Sale proceeds over ten years for Scenario 3 Report 6.3
  • £2.594m Existing capital budget provision retained in the model Report 6.3
  • £2.216m Further additional investment required for Scenario 3 Report 6.3
  • £0.123m Revenue surplus forecast in years 1-5 Report 6.3
  • £0.404m Revenue surplus forecast in years 6-10 Report 6.3
  • £0.264m Five year deficit if CPI is 4% per annum from 2028 onwards Report 6.7
  • £1.287m Ten year deficit under the same CPI assumption Report 6.7

Options considered

  • Rejected: Scenario 1: relet farms as tenancies end and continue programmed investment. The estate would face a growing deficit and increasing liabilities because no further rationalisation would occur. Report P72, P74, P76
  • Rejected: Scenario 2: sell farmhouses and cottages as tenancies end. Past investment is not recognised, farm clusters are fragmented and new entrant opportunities fall. Report P78, P85, P87
  • Chosen: Scenario 3: assess whole farms and remove unsuitable elements. It balances revenue, capital receipts, flexibility and the four ambitions. Report P96, P112
  • Rejected: Scenario 4: release the most expensive sites lacking recent investment. It would lose about 7% of the estate and lacks clear long term direction. Report P104
  • Rejected: Scenario 5: release isolated farms with limited amalgamation potential. It would lose about 10% of the estate, carries delivery risk and harms long term revenue. Report P109

Implications

  • Financial: Scenario 3 forecasts revenue surpluses of £0.123m in years 1-5 and £0.404m in years 6-10. Report 6.3
  • Financial: Capital investment is £4.810m, assuming £2.594m of existing budget provision and £2.216m additional, subject to approval. Report 6.3
  • Financial: If CPI is 4% per annum from 2028 onwards, the forecast changes to deficits of £0.264m over five years and £1.287m over ten years. Report 6.7
  • Legal: The Council must hold and manage the estate as a smallholding authority under the 1970 Agriculture Act. Disposals must obtain the best price reasonably obtainable and follow the Council's constitution and property transaction code. Report 7.3, 7.4, P145
  • Risk: Without sufficient investment, the expected financial and operational benefits may not be achieved. Report 8.1
  • Risk: Government support payments, farm gate prices, fuel and other input costs could pressure farm income and rents. Report 8.5
  • Staffing: No additional staff resources are assumed because existing staff can shift towards rationalisation work. Report 2.39
  • Other: Housing and renewable returns are excluded from modelling and would be windfall income, with housing subject to separate decisions and business cases. Report 2.37, 2.38, P60

Who and where

  • Council taxpayers Report P39
  • New entrant farmers Report P97
  • Existing farm tenants Report P40, P42
  • Dairy farm businesses Report P42
  • Rural businesses Report P97
  • Local communities Report P45
  • Prospective renewable energy developers Report 2.38
  • Potential affordable housing beneficiaries Report P60

Timeline

  • 2019: Cabinet adopted the Farms Strategy for the period 2019-2039. Report 1.1
  • 16 June 2026: The scrutiny committee endorsed 11 key findings and recommendations. Report P128
  • 2026/27: The current operating deficit is estimated at c£0.300m. Report 6.1
  • 2027/28: Additional Scenario 3 investment will be considered through the budget process. Report P7, 6.3
  • 2027-2032: The management plan will provide policy for managing the farms estate. Report P4
  • over the next 6-18 months or so: Further estate sales are expected to produce £10.077m. Report 2.13
  • 2031/32: Scenario 3 projects 10,340 acres, 62 fully equipped holdings and 16 dairy farms. Report P95
  • 2036/37: Scenario 3 projects 10,299 acres, 57 fully equipped holdings and 14 dairy farms. Report P95

Plain English for the jargon

  • Scenario 3: Whole farm asset management assessments, followed by targeted removal of unsuitable elements. [P87]
  • FEH: Fully Equipped Holdings, the farm units counted separately from bare land in the estate model. [P14, P15, P16]
  • MTFP: Medium Term Financial Plan. [P4, P7]
  • SGPOSC: Sustainable Growth and Place Overview and Scrutiny Committee. [P38]
  • NOSC: Neighbourhoods Overview Scrutiny Committee. [2.2]
  • CPI: Consumer Price Index. [2.30]
  • CDD Wheel: Cornwall Development and Decision Wheel. [P118, 9.1]
  • Smallholding authority: The status required when the Council holds and manages the Agricultural Estate under the 1970 Agriculture Act. [7.3]
What was decided, why, and what happens next

Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.

Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
ItemCAB/605

Resolved

DECISION:
Word for word from the decision Cornwall published for this meeting. Source: democracy.cornwall.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cornwall's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

Recommendation

That Cabinet:

a) accepts the Sustainable Growth and Place Overview and Scrutiny Committees findings and recommendations.

b) approves the choice of Scenario 3 (referred to in the report) as the preferred approach for the Farms Strategy Operating Business Management Plan

c) delegates authority to the Head of Property the decision making necessary to amend and finalise, (in consultation with the Monitoring Officer, Section 151 Officer), the Farms Strategy Operating Business Management Plan to incorporate scenario 3 and to adopt it as policy to manage the farms estate over the 2027–2032 period that is consistent with the Medium Term Financial Plan

Executive summary

1.1Cabinet adopted a Farms Strategy for the period 2019-2039 in 2019. 1.2 A requirement of that adoption was that the relevant scrutiny committee would be provided with annual update reports on its implementation, as well as, for a more detail review to take place every 5 years. 1.3 In 2025, the Sustainable Growth and Place Overview Scrutiny Committee (SGPOSC) convened a Task and Finish Group to undertake the 5 year review of the Farms Strategy. That group concluded its report earlier this year and presented it to the wider members of that committee in June, when 11 key findings and recommendations were endorsed. 1.4 It is recognised that the Council continues to experience financial pressures and therefore it is prudent, at this juncture, to present to Cabinet options available to it in relation to the Council’s Farms Estate and Service taking into account the findings of the SGPOSC Task and Finish Group’s recommendations and the financial pressures being experienced.

1.5This report sets out 5 scenarios (options) that could be taken to further the implementation and adaptation of the Farms Strategy with their anticipated financial and non-financial impacts over the next period of 5 years and towards 10 years as best as can be predicted with the information available at this point in time. Information Classification: PUBLIC

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Farms Strategy 2019-2039 (2026 Review): Appendix 2 /605Appendix 4.7 MB Download
PDF
Farms Strategy 2019-2039 (2026 Review)Report 693 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

0 of 11 attended
LF
Leigh FrostChairman, expected
AP
Adam PaynterVice-Chairman, expected
TD
Tim DwellyCommittee Member, expected
HF
Hilary FrankCommittee Member, expected
PL
Peter La BroyCommittee Member, expected
TM
Thalia MarringtonCommittee Member, expected
JM
Jim McKennaCommittee Member, expected
SP
Sarah PreeceCommittee Member, expected
LR
Loic RichCommittee Member, expected
DR
Dan RogersonCommittee Member, expected
AK
Andy KeelingOfficer, expected

More from Cornwall Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
11 Nov 2026 Minutes of the Meeting Held on 23 September 2026 / Kovnotennow an Kuntelles Synsys 23 mis Gwynngala 2026It was proposed by Councillor Frost, seconded by Councillor Paynter and RESOLVED that the minutes of the Cabinet meet... Decided Open
11 Nov 2026 Council Performance Report 2026/27(Q2)DECISION: As contained within the report. Decided Open
11 Nov 2026 Digital Connectivity Investment ProgrammeDECISION: As contained within the report. Decided Open
11 Nov 2026 Cornwall Education Partnership Education StrategyDECISION: As contained within the report. Decided Open
29 Jul 2026 Minutes of the Meeting Held on 17 June 2026 / Kovnotennow an Kuntelles Synsys 17 mis Metheven 2026RESOLVED that the minutes of the Cabinet meeting held on 17 June 2026 were correctly recorded and that they be signed... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies