CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Cotswold District Council
Cabinet, Monday 9 May 2022 at 6.00pm

Cabinet/Scrutiny Protocol - draft for consideration by the Cabinet

Deferred Executive 2 papers

Cabinet deferred this item on Monday 9 May 2022. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item134

Resolved

RESOLVED : That the Cabinet/Scrutiny Protocol, be deferred to the Cabinet meeting on 6 th June 2022.
Word for word from the decision Cotswold published for this meeting. Source: meetings.cotswold.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Cotswold's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Cabinet

Annex A

DRAFT CABINET SCRUTINY PROTOCOL FOR COUNCILLORS OF COTSWOLD DISTRICT COUNCIL

May 2022

1. Introduction 1.1 Overview & Scrutiny must be located at the strategic heart of the authority and is a key element of the decision making process acting as a 'critical friend'. 1.2 This Protocol applies to all members of Overview & Scrutiny, any Member who may sit on an Overview & Scrutiny Task & Finish Group, and all Members of the Cabinet.

2. Trust 2.1 All Members should promote an atmosphere of openness at Overview & Scrutiny Committee meetings and should strive to ensure that questioning and debate takes place within a climate of mutual respect and trust. 2.2 Overview & Scrutiny Members need to trust that Cabinet Members are being open and honest. 2.3 Cabinet Members need to trust Overview & Scrutiny Members with information and to trust in their views.

3. Policy Development and Pre-Decision Scrutiny 3.1 The importance of early input from Overview & Scrutiny into policy development is recognised. Scrutiny can act as a sounding board and a think tank in investigating issues coming up on the horizon, bringing in added value. Cabinet Members and Officers should draw to the attention of Overview & Scrutiny Committee any key policy that is being developed or is due for review to ensure timely input. 3.2 All policy development will be carried out in an informal setting with a report submitted to Overview & Scrutiny Committee (‘’Scrutiny’’) for consideration. The Cabinet and relevant lead Officer will consider the views of Scrutiny Members in the development of the policy and provide a response to the recommendations of Scrutiny within 28 days or earlier should the report of the Cabinet require publication. The detail of Scrutiny’s involvement shall also be included within the body of the Cabinet report. The Cabinet/Full Council will continue to be responsible for approving and adopting policy. 3.3 Cabinet Members may wish to request views from Scrutiny Members on a decision before it is taken. The Cabinet Member will be responsible for circulating the details to the relevant Scrutiny Committee Members, through Democratic Services. Utilising this as an option does not exclude the decision from being subject to call-in.

1 Annex A

However, it will give the Cabinet Member the ability to consider different views and perspectives of a decision to be taken before it is taken.

4. Holding the Cabinet to Account 4.1 A key role of Scrutiny is in holding the Cabinet to account for decisions taken and performance of services. In holding the Cabinet to account Scrutiny Members will:

 Consider decisions taken by the Cabinet, individually and collectively and items on the Forward Plan through formal Scrutiny Committee meetings;  Review service performance and performance against policy and targets;  Be prepared to ask searching questions that provide a constructive challenge;  Be positive and respectful in their interactions with Cabinet Members;  Represent the voice of the public;  Listen to the responses provided and assist the Cabinet in identifying areas for further consideration and improvement.

4.2In return, Cabinet Members will:

 Be willing to be open, honest and engaged in providing a response to constructive challenge;  Value the importance of Scrutiny;  Be supportive of the scrutiny process and invite and seek opinion from Scrutiny Members on decisions to be taken, where appropriate;  Provide a positive contribution to Scrutiny meetings;  Attend meetings when invited to do so to answer questions and present information:

o By way of a direct answer o By reference to published publications o By referring a matter to an Officer in attendance, if they are not able to respond o If an answer cannot immediately be given, by providing a written answer within five working days unless it is not reasonable to do so. If considered unreasonable, an explanation as to why will be given. o A combination of the above four options.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Cabinet Scrutiny Protocol May 2022Report 351 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Cabinet/Scrutiny Protocol: draft for consideration by the CabinetReport 77 KB Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

8 of 8 attended
RC
Rachel CoxcoonCommittee Member, present
TD
Tony DaleCommittee Member, present
AD
Andrew DohertyCommittee Member, present
ME
Mike EvemyCommittee Member, present
JF
Jenny FordeCommittee Member, present
JH
Joe HarrisCommittee Member, present
JL
Juliet LaytonCommittee Member, present
LS
Lisa SpiveyCommittee Member, present

On this subject at Cotswold

Search all
  1. Cabinet/Scrutiny Protocol - draft for consideration by the CabinetThis decision
  2. Cabinet/Scrutiny Protocol - draft for consideration by the CabinetAgreed
  3. Draft Cabinet Scrutiny ProtocolNoted

More from Cotswold Cabinet

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
10 Sep 2026 MinutesThe purpose of this item was to consider the minutes of the previous two meetings of Cabinet of the meeting of Cabine... Noted Open
10 Sep 2026 Schedule of Decisions taken by the Leader of the Council and/or Individual Cabinet MembersDecision Meeting 30 June 2026 Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Housing and Planning Delegated Decision Meeting 3 ... Decided Open
10 Sep 2026 Suitable Alternative Natural Greenspace Spending 2026The purpose of this item was to ask Cabinet to consider officer recommendations on external bids for funding from the... Noted Open
10 Sep 2026 Corporate Performance Report - Q1 2026/27The purpose of this item was to provide an update on Corporate Performance from April to the end of June 2026. Counci... Noted Open
10 Sep 2026 Establishing a Voluntary Joint Committee - Local Government ReorganisationThe Leader announced that this item was being withdrawn from the agenda in light of the government’s announcements on... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies