CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Coventry City Council
Ethics Committee, Friday 17 March 2017 at 10.00am

Hearing into Complaint Under Code of Conduct

Decided Committee 1 paper

Ethics Committee decided this item on Friday 17 March 2017. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item26

Resolved

RESOLVED that the conclusion of the Committee be as set out in the Decision Letter attached as Appendix 1 to these Minutes. APPENDIX 1 COVENTRY CITY COUNCIL DECISION NOTICE OF ETHICS COMMITTEE A Complaint by: [name removed] (“the Complainant”) B Subject Member: Councillor Jaswant SinghBirdi C Introduction 1. On 17 March 2017, the Ethics Committee of Coventry City Council considered a report of an investigation into the alleged conduct of Councillor Jaswant Singh Birdi, a member of Coventry City Council. A general summary of the complaint is set out below. D Complaint summary 2. The Complainant made a number of allegations about the behaviour of Councillor Birdi. These can be summarised asfollows: 2.1 By raising concerns about litter near a property that he owned, Councillor Birdi was acting in his own interests and not in the public interest. This was contrary to Paragraphs 2(a) and 3(a) of the Code of Conduct. 2.2 Councillor Birdi should have referred his concerns to a councillor for the ward where the litter was located and this was contrary to Paragraph 3(b) of theCode. 2.3 Councillor Birdi should have remained objective and should not have assumed that the litter was the fault of the Complainant; he shouldnot have become angry and personal when raising his concerns with the Complainant. This was in breach of Paragraph 3(e) of theCode . 2.4 Councillor Birdi should have been clear, from the outset of his interaction with the Complainant, ... view the full minutes text for item 26.
Word for word from the decision Coventry published for this meeting. Source: edemocracy.coventry.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Coventry's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Ethics Committee

Executive summary

This report sets out brief details of a complaint made by [name removed] (“the Complainant”). The complaint is against Cllr Jaswant Singh Birdi (the “Subject Member”) and relates to an incident which took place on 4th January 2016.

The Complainant alleged that Cllr Birdi breached the Council’s Code of Conduct for Elected and Co- opted Members in a number of ways.

A Stage One review of the complaint concluded that an independent investigator should be appointed to investigate the complaint. An independent investigator was initially appointed to carry out the investigation. He concluded that Cllr Birdi had breached the Code of Conduct as did a second independent investigator.

The Subject Member does not agree with the Investigators’ conclusions and has requested that the complaint be referred to a hearing of the Ethics Committee.

The purpose of this report is to provide the Ethics Committee with all the relevant information to enable it to determine whether or not there has been a breach after hearing from the Investigating Officer and from Councillor Birdi. Recommendations

The Committee is requested to:

(1) Hear the complaint against the Subject Member and determine whether he has breached the Code of Conduct;

(2) if the Committee considers that there has been a breach or breaches of the Code of Conduct, determine what sanction or sanctions, if any, should be applied; and

(3) authorise the Acting Monitoring Officer, in consultation with the Chair of Ethics Committee, to publish the Full Decision on the Council’s website at the same time that copies are made available to the parties to the hearing.

List of Appendices included:

Appendix 1: Code of Conduct for Elected and Co-opted Members

Appendix 2: Complaints Protocol

Appendix 3: Complaint dated 15th January 2016

Appendix 4: Stage One Report

Appendix 5: Report of First Investigating Officer

Appendix 6: Written opinion of the First Independent Person

Appendix 7: Response of Subject Member to First Investigator’s Report

Appendix 8: Report of Second Investigator

Appendix 9: Response of Subject Member to Second Investigator’s Report

Appendix 10: Written Opinion of Co-opted Independent Person

Appendix 11: Hearing Procedure

Other useful background papers:

None

Has it been or will it be considered by Scrutiny? No

Has it been or will it be considered by any other Council Committee, Advisory Panel or other body? No

Will this report go to Council? No

2 Report title: Hearing into Complaint under Code of Conduct

1. Context (or background)

1.1The Council adopted the Code of Conduct for Elected and Co-opted Members (“the Code”) at its meeting on 3rd July 2012. A copy of the Code is attached to this report at Appendix 1. In addition the Ethics Committee on 30th August 2012 approved a Complaints Protocol for use when dealing with Code of Conduct complaints. This is attached at Appendix 2.

1.2On 15th January 2016, [name removed] (the Complainant) made a statement of complaint to the Deputy Monitoring Officer.

1.3The complaint is against Councillor Jaswant Singh Birdi (“the Subject Member”) and relates to an incident which took place at the Complainant’s shop on 4th January 2016. The complaint alleged that the Subject Member had breached the Code in the following ways:

(a) By raising concerns about litter near a property that he owned, Cllr Birdi was acting in his own interests and not in the public interest. This was contrary to Paragraphs 2a) and 3a) of the Code of Conduct.

(b) Cllr Birdi should have referred his concerns to a councillor for the ward where the litter was located and this was contrary to Paragraph 3b) of the Code.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Hearing into Complaint Under Code of ConductReport 7.6 MB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

6 of 7 attended
AR
Councillor Allan Robert AndrewsCommittee Member, present
LB
Councillor Linda BighamCommittee Member, present
CB
Carol BradfordOfficer, in attendance
DG
Councillor Damian GannonCommittee Member, present
HL
Helen LynchOfficer, present as substitute
KM
Councillor Keiran MulhallCommittee Member, present
SW
Councillor Seamus WalshChair, present

On this subject at Coventry

Search all
  1. Hearing into Complaint Under Code of ConductThis decision
  2. Hearing into Alleged Breach of the Code of ConductDecided
  3. Hearing into Complaints Under Code of ConductDecided

More from Coventry Ethics Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
19 Mar 2026 Six Monthly Review of Members' Gifts and HospitalityRESOLVED that the Committee:- 1) Notes the Members’ Gifts and Hospitality Register entries from 1 July to 31 December... Decided Open
19 Mar 2026 Six Monthly Review of Officers' Gifts and HospitalityRESOLVED that the Committee:- 1) Notes the Officers’ Gifts and Hospitality Register entries from 1 July to 31 Decembe... Decided Open
19 Mar 2026 Code of Conduct UpdateRESOLVED that the Ethics Committee:- 1) Notes the position with regard to matters concerning local authorities nation... Decided Open
19 Mar 2026 Work Programme for the Ethics Committee 2026/27RESOLVED that approval be given to the Work Programme for 2026/27 as appended to the report with the inclusion of an ... Approved Open
8 Jan 2026 Prospective Councillor InformationRESOLVED that the Ethics Committee:- 1) Notes, welcomes and commends the content of the report and the “Becoming a Co... Decided Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies