Scrutiny Co-ordination Committee One Coventry Plan Deep Dive Recommendations
ApprovedExecutive2 papers
AI summaryCabinet approved nine recommendations for One Coventry Plan performance reporting. [D] These cover measurable indicators, annual scrutiny reviews, reporting frequency and strategy alignment, with no direct financial implications. [D] [P3] [P20]
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedCabinet approved nine recommendations covering review, reporting, alignment and scrutiny [D] [P3].
MoneyNo direct financial implications [P20]Governance and delivery affect finances and Value for Money assessment [P20].
What happens nextNot stated
Who it affectsNot stated
What was decided
Cabinet approved review of all One Coventry Plan Key Performance Indicators through reporting by Cabinet and Scrutiny, to keep them relevant as services are redesigned and changed [D] [P3]. Report P3
Key Performance Indicators must be measurable or able to demonstrate service improvements. Each must be marked as national or locally determined, and the frequency must be identified and reported where data is not annual [D] [P3]. Report P3
Cabinet approved consideration of possible conflicts between targets to protect green and blue spaces and targets to build houses, including any other potentially contradictory targets. Council Strategies and plan indicators must be cross referenced and aligned. Each Scrutiny body must review indicators within its remit annually, achieved targets must be recognised and celebrated, and indicators in Appendix 1, Sections 1 to 16, must be reviewed with the Scrutiny Coordination Committee’s comments and suggestions [D] [P3]. Report P3
Why
The deep dive examined plan indicators whose performance targets had not been met, plus Biodiversity Net Gain. It covered five sessions with relevant Cabinet Members and officers [1.1]. Report 1.1
Performance scrutiny is a key part of Scrutiny’s role in checking whether the Council is achieving its strategic objectives [2.1]. Report 2.1
The recommendations should produce a more effective and streamlined use of performance data, with better reflection on One Coventry Plan outcomes [P20]. Report P20
What happens next
Cabinet and Scrutiny should review all plan indicators through reporting. Indicators should be measurable or able to demonstrate service improvement and be marked as national or locally determined. The reporting frequency should be identified for data that is not annual [D] [P3]. Report P3
Council Strategies and plan indicators should be cross referenced and aligned. Possible conflicts between green and blue space protection and housebuilding targets should be considered. Achieved targets should be recognised and celebrated, and indicators in Appendix 1, Sections 1 to 16, should be reviewed with the committee’s comments [D] [P3]. Report P3
Each Scrutiny body should review indicators within its remit annually. The appropriate Scrutiny body should undertake Appendix 1 Section 17 work, Cabinet Members and Scrutiny Councillors should be included in future reviews, and the Scrutiny Coordination Committee should receive a progress report in 12 months’ time [D] [P1] [2.1] [P20]. Report P1, 2.1, P20
Options considered
Rejected: Do not review Council performance. This option was not considered because performance scrutiny is a key part of Scrutiny’s role in checking whether the Council is achieving its strategic objectives [2.1]. Report 2.1
Rejected: Maintain the status quo. Detailed scrutiny of Key Performance Indicators is not possible at one meeting, so the option was not recommended [2.1]. Report 2.1
Chosen: Endorse the performance deep dive outcome. The Scrutiny Coordination Committee agreed this approach on 21st August 2025 [2.1]. Report 2.1
Implications
Financial: There are no direct financial implications. Governance and delivery of the Council’s objectives will affect its overall financial position and external Value for Money assessment [P20]. Report P20
Legal: No legal implications arise at this time. Legal Services will continue to provide advice and support as the recommendations are implemented [P20]. Report P20
Legal: The Local Government Transparency Code sets minimum publication data, frequency and method. It does not require performance reports or publication on any indicators or metrics, and the Council publishes this information as good practice [P20]. Report P20
Equalities: A full Equality Impact Assessment was completed for the original One Coventry Plan, and the recommendations do not affect that assessment [P20]. Report P20
Climate: Tackling the causes and consequences of climate change is one of three key priorities. The recommendations do not affect these priorities [P20]. Report P20
Risk: There are no direct risks from the recommendations, but each service area is responsible for its own risk management [P20]. Report P20
Other: Performance data should be used more effectively and efficiently, with better reflection on One Coventry Plan outcomes [P20]. Report P20
Other: All recommendations affect internal Council services. No implications are stated for partner organisations [P20]. Report P20
Cabinet Members and Scrutiny Councillors Report 2.1
Internal Council services Report P20
Timeline
April 2024: Start of the reporting period for the One Coventry Plan Annual Performance Report [P7]. Report P7
March 2025: End of the reporting period for the One Coventry Plan Annual Performance Report [P7]. Report P7
21st August 2025: The scrutiny coordination committee considered the annual performance report and agreed a deep dive into unmet indicators and Biodiversity Net Gain [1.1]. Report 1.1
26th August 2025: Cabinet date recorded for the background One Coventry Plan Annual Performance Report [P7]. Report P7
30 October 2025: The Scrutiny Coordination Committee considered this report [P11]. Report P11
annually: Each Scrutiny body reviews plan indicators within its remit as part of the annual One Coventry Plan review [D] [P3]. Report P3
12 months’ time: The Scrutiny Coordination Committee will require a progress report on the recommendations [P20]. Report P20
Plain English for the jargon
Key Performance Indicator: A measure for checking whether a performance target has been met and whether services improve [D] [1.1].
One Coventry Plan: The Council plan containing the indicators, priorities and outcomes reviewed through performance reporting [P3] [P20].
Deep dive: Detailed questioning of performance areas by Cabinet Members and officers, with recommendations on specific indicators [1.1].
Scrutiny Coordination Committee: The committee that regularly receives One Coventry Plan performance reports and coordinates scrutiny [1.1] [P3].
Equality Impact Assessment: An assessment completed for the original One Coventry Plan, which these recommendations do not affect [P20].
Local Government Transparency Code: A Government code setting minimum publication data, frequency and method for local authorities [P20].
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item36
Resolved
RESOLVED that Cabinet approve:- 1) That all One Coventry Plan Key Performance Indicators (KPI’s) are reviewed as part of the reporting process by Cabinet and Scrutiny to ensure relevance as the Council goes through service re-design and change. 2) That KPI’s are measurable and/or can demonstrate service improvements. 3) That KPI’s reported in the One Coventry Plan are designated as either being national indicators or locally determined. 4) That where data isn’t available on an annual basis, the frequency of the data is identified and reported accordingly. 5) That consideration be given to the potential discord between targets to protect green and blue spaces and targets to build houses, and whether there are any other targets that could potentially be contradictory. 6) That all Council Strategies and One Coventry Plan KPI’s are cross-referenced and aligned. 7) That each Scrutiny body reviews performance on the Key Performance Indicators (KPI’s) related to their remit on an annual basis as part of the One Coventry Plan review process. 8) That recognition is given where performance targets have been achieved, and that this is celebrated. 9) That the specific KPI’s identified in Sections 1-16 of the Appendix to the report are reviewed alongside Scrutiny Co-ordination Committee’s comments and suggestions.
Word for word from the decision Coventry published for this meeting.Source: edemocracy.coventry.gov.uk
Scrutiny Co-ordination Committee is recommended to: 1) Approve the proposed recommendations to Cabinet as detailed below. 2) Request that the appropriate Scrutiny Body undertakes the work detailed in Appendix 1 Section 17. 3) Ensure that each Scrutiny body reviews performance on the Key Performance Indicators (KPI’s) related to their remit on an annual basis as part of the One Coventry Plan review process.
Cabinet is recommended to agree:-
1) That all One Coventry Plan Key Performance Indicators (KPI’s) are reviewed as part of the reporting process, by Cabinet and Scrutiny to ensure relevance as the Council goes through service re-design and change. 2) That KPI’s are measurable and/or can demonstrate service improvements. 3) That KPI’s reported in the One Coventry Plan are designated as either being national indicators or locally determined. 4) That where data isn’t available on an annual basis, the frequency of the data is identified and reported accordingly. 5) That consideration be given to the potential discord between targets to protect green and blue spaces and targets to build houses, and whether there are any other targets that could potentially be contradictory. 6) That all Council Strategies and One Coventry Plan KPI’s are cross-referenced and aligned. 7) That each Scrutiny body reviews performance on the Key Performance Indicators (KPI’s) related to their remit on an annual basis as part of the One Coventry Plan review process. 8) That recognition is given where performance targets have been achieved, and that this is celebrated. 9) That the specific KPI’s identified in Appendix 1 Sections 1-16 are reviewed alongside Scrutiny Co-ordination Committee’s comments and suggestions.
List of Appendices included:
The following appendices are attached to the report:
Appendix 1 – One Coventry Plan Deep Dives KPI Specific Recommendations
Background papers
Report titled “One Coventry Plan Annual Performance Report (April 2024 – March 2025)” dated 21st August 2025 (Scrutiny Co-Ordination Committee) and 26th August 2025 (Cabinet) 04 One Coventry Plan Annual Performance Report April 2024-March 2025.pdf
Other useful documents
One Coventry Plan Annual Performance Report (April 2024-March 2025) Appendix One Coventry Plan 2022-2030.pdf
Has it or will it be considered by Scrutiny?
Yes Scrutiny Co-ordination Committee – 30 October 2025
Has it or will it be considered by any other Council Committee, Advisory Panel or other body?
No
Will this report go to Council?
No Report title: Scrutiny Co-ordination Committee One Coventry Plan Deep Dive Recommendations
1. Context (or background)
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Revenue and Capital Outturn 2025/26RESOLVED that Council be recommended to approve the contribution to reserves of £3.2m for the purposes described in S...
Transport Capital Programme 2026/27RESOLVED that, the Cabinet: 1. Approve delivery of the 2026/27 programmes of Local Network Improvement schemes and Hi...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.