RESOLVED The Cabinet: 1. approves the Council’s participation as a Founding Member of the new Local Government Mutual. 2. nominates the Leader of the Council to be appointed as a Founding Member committee member and to oversee and make strategic decisions in respect of the Mutual’s build phase activity pending trading. 3. delegates the authority to the Head of Finance, Revenues and Benefits in consultation with the Leader of the Council to approve and execute any documentation necessary to give effect to recommendation 2.1 (a) above. (Generic Delegation 8 will be used to enact this recommendation). 4. notes that a further report with a business case for utilising the mutual would come back to Cabinet when the Council’s current long term agreement for insurance cover comes to an end. Reasons for the Recommendations Local Government Mutual aims to offer the prospect of affordable, high quality risk transfer and risk management through a mutual structure for the benefit of the local government sector. It may make a valuable contribution to sector-wide efficiencies and financial stability. Participation in the manner described above allows the Council to contribute to the establishment of the new Mutual without exposing itself to any financial or operational risk. To confirm there is no commitment to using the services of the Mutual at this stage or in the future, unless there is a justifiable business case.
Word for word from the decision Crawley published for this meeting.Source: democracy.crawley.gov.uk
a) Approve the Council’s participation as a Founding Member of the new Local Government Mutual.
b) Nominate the Leader of the Council to be appointed as a Founding Member committee member and to oversee and make strategic decisions in respect of the Mutual’s build phase activity pending trading.
c) Delegate authority to the Head of Finance, Revenues and Benefits in consultation with the Leader of the Council to approve and execute any documentation necessary to give effect to recommendation 2.1 (a) above. (Generic Delegation 8 will be used to enact this recommendation).
d) To note that a further report with a business case for utilising the mutual would come back to Cabinet when the Council’s current long term agreement for insurance cover comes to an end.
Reasons for the recommendations
3.1Local Government Mutual aims to offer the prospect of affordable, high quality risk transfer and risk management through a mutual structure for the benefit of the local government sector. It may make a valuable contribution to sector-wide efficiencies and financial stability. Participation in the manner described above allows the Council to contribute to the establishment of the new Mutual without exposing itself to any financial or operational risk.
3.2To confirm there is no commitment to using the services of the Mutual at this stage or in the future, unless there is a justifiable business case.
Background
4.1Councils currently spend hundreds of millions of pounds on insurance nationally. The Local Government Association (LGA) has been exploring options to develop a cost effective alternative to the conventional insurance market products and services available to local authorities. 4.2 A phase of research has been undertaken with a broad range of local authorities including interviews with LGA members, analysis of the current insurance models and talking to key providers in the market. A viable potential alternative identified is pooling the risk of LGA members to form a discretionary mutual, where all surpluses are retained in the mutual.
4.3The LGA wants to work with a small number of leading authorities with a view to developing a new mutual for local government which will aim to offer comparable cover to LGA members at a competitive rate.
4.4The LGA is confident that a local government mutual can deliver better cover and service at a reduced cost. By way of example, The Fire & Rescue Indemnity Company – set up in 2015 by nine fire authorities – achieved a surplus of £471,428 in its first year of trading – 12.5 per cent of their contributions, and has been nominated for industry awards.
4.5Mutuals have an inherent interest in sharing best practice and supporting their members to manage risks more effectively, thereby helping to reduce risk related incidents over time.
4.6The LGA is not asking founding members to change their insurance arrangements – the Mutual’s board will operate a methodical admissions process.
4.7Founding members would need to provide an elected member to join the Mutual’s Board and help establish its governance and management arrangements and oversee its launch.
5. Proposal
5.1There is an opportunity for Crawley Borough Council to join the Local Government Mutual as a founding member.
5.2There is no obligation on Crawley Borough Council to utilise the Mutual subsequently. The existing contracts for insurance are due to be replaced on 1st April 2019 and a further Cabinet report would be come forward when the Council’s agreement for insurance cover expires.
5.3The Mutual would be owned and controlled by its members and professionally managed by Financial Conduct Authority authorised industry experts.
5.4Founding Member Tasks
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Financial Outturn 2025-2026 (Quarter 4)RESOLVED That the Cabinet: a) notes the outturn for the financial year 2025/26 as summarised in report FIN/745 . b) a...
Treasury Management Outturn 2025 – 2026RESOLVED That the Cabinet: a) notes the Treasury Management Outturn 2025/2026 report FIN/746 . b) approves the actual...
2026-2027 Budget Monitoring - Quarter 1RESOLVED That the Cabinet notes the projected outturn for the financial year 2026/27 as summarised in report FIN/747 ...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.