CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Dacorum Borough Council
Council, Wednesday 24 February 2021 at 6.30pm

Motion

Decided Committee 1 paper

Council decided this item on Wednesday 24 February 2021. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item5

Resolved

The following motion was proposed by Councillor Pringle and seconded by Councillor Taylor: 1. This council recognises the significant changes of circumstances following the launch of the consultation on the Local Plan in November 2020, namely that Dacorum escalated quickly to tier 4 and then national lockdown meaning that: a. residents have been severely impeded from engaging in the consultation process, or comprehending the implications of the proposals, due to distractions caused by the dramatic rise in coronavirus cases, hospitalisations and bereavements across Dacorum that was unforeseen at the time this Council voted to proceed with the consultation in November 2020 b. opportunities to publicise the local plan through volunteer leafleting, public meetings and question and answer sessions that would normally be an essential element of any such consultation have not been available c, due to the national lockdown, those who cannot access the consultation documents through the DBC portal, because of lack of an appropriate device or skills, have effectively been excluded in any meaningful way from participating in the consultation d. that this excluded cohort of residents is likely to contain a high proportion of elderly and vulnerable people and that encouraging such residents to travel to public libraries, in breach of the government’s guidance on essential journeys to view the consultation documents presents a risk to public health during the current emergency, e. making a journey to a public library in order to view consultation documents on the local plan is not an essential journey according to government guidelines, it is unlawful — and therefore irrational — for Dacorum Borough Council to have encouraged residents to travel to public libraries during lockdown to view documents as an element of the consultation process f. that there is evidence of a high proportion of residents who have not been informed of the local plan though official DBC communications whatsoever and many residents remain unaware of the consultation g. that the published communications that have managed to reach a proportion of the public, suggest that only responses by email or via the portal are acceptable, meaning that those who can only respond by post have effectively been excluded 2. In addition some weeks into the public consultation, on 16th December 2020, the government published its response to the local housing need proposals on the consultation on changes to the current planning system, setting out important changes to the standard method, which clearly stated, amongst other things, that meeting housing needs is never a reason to cause unacceptable harm to protected landscapes and the Green Belt. The council acknowledges that the publication of the new guidelines: a. has confused many residents, some of whom believed on hearing these government proposals, that the consultation would be suspended and will have decided not to respond b. has altered the method of calculation and therefore the fundamental premise upon which the consultation was originally based, effectively changing the goal posts such that responses submitted at the beginning of the process are now based on ... view the full decision text for item 5.
Word for word from the decision Dacorum published for this meeting. Source: democracy.dacorum.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from Dacorum's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Council

Proposed by Cllr Lara Pringle

1. This council recognises the significant changes of circumstances following the launch of the consultation on the Local Plan in November 2020, namely that Dacorum escalated quickly to tier 4 and then national lockdown meaning that:

a. residents have been severely impeded from engaging in the consultation process, or comprehending the implications of the proposals, due to distractions caused by the dramatic rise in coronavirus cases, hospitalisations and bereavements across Dacorum that was unforeseen at the time this Council voted to proceed with the consultation in November 2020

b. opportunities to publicise the local plan through volunteer leafleting, public meetings and question and answer sessions that would normally be an essential element of any such consultation have not been available

c, due to the national lockdown, those who cannot access the consultation documents through the DBC portal, because of lack of an appropriate device or skills, have effectively been excluded in any meaningful way from participating in the consultation

d. that this excluded cohort of residents is likely to contain a high proportion of elderly and vulnerable people and that encouraging such residents to travel to public libraries, in breach of the government’s guidance on essential journeys to view the consultation documents presents a risk to public health duriing the current emergency,

e. making a journey to a public library in order to view consultation documents on the local plan is not an essential journey according to government guidelines, it is unlawful — and therefore irrational — for Dacorum Borough Council to have encouraged residents to travel to public libraries during lockdown to view documents as an element of the consultation process

f. that there is evidence of a high proportion of residents who have not been informed of the local plan though official DBC communications whatsoever and many residents remain unaware of the consultation

g. that the published communications that have managed to reach a proportion of the public, suggest that only responses by email or via the portal are acceptable, meaning that those who can only respond by post have effectively been excluded

2. In addition some weeks into the public consultation, on 16th December 2020, the government published its response to the local housing need proposals on the consultation on changes to the current planning system, setting out important changes to the standard method, which clearly stated, amongst other things, that meeting housing needs is never a reason to cause unacceptable harm to protected landscapes and the Green Belt. The council acknowledges that the publication of the new guidelines:

a. has confused many residents, some of whom believed on hearing these government proposals, that the consultation would be suspended and will have decided not to respond

b. has altered the method of calculation and therefore the fundamental premise upon which the consultation was originally based, effectively changing the goal posts such that responses submitted at the beginning of the process are now based on an out-of- date premise

c. there is such confusion around the process that it is unreasonable to expect residents to now understand the basis of the formula and therefore evaluate the proposal or to be able to meaningfully respond

3. This council recognises that in view of these material changes of circumstances since the consultation was launched in November 2020, it would not be advisable to proceed with this consultation as it will leave any Local Plan based on such a consultation vulnerable to legal challenge and will lead to a loss of public confidence in the outcome of the consultation and undermine public confidence in Dacorum Borough Council should it choose to proceed under all of these circumstances

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
MotionReport 107 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

On this subject at Dacorum

Search all
  1. MotionThis decision
  2. MotionsAgreed
  3. MotionAgreed
  4. MotionsDecided
  5. MotionsAgreed
  6. MotionsDecided

More from Dacorum Council

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
13 May 2026 MayorThat Councillor Garrick Stevens be appointed Mayor to the Borough of Dacorum until the appointment of a successor at ... Decided Open
13 May 2026 Deputy MayorCouncillor Johnson be appointed Deputy Mayor of the Borough of Dacorum until the appointment of a successor at the An... Decided Open
2 Apr 2025 Appointment of the Leader of the CouncilThe Mayor announced that the motion to adjourn the appointment of the Leader of the Council to 14 th May had not carr... Deferred Open
2 Apr 2025 Cabinet Member UpdatesCouncil agreed the formal appointment of Cllr Allen on the Hertfordshire Building Preservation Trust. 6.2 The Mayor i... Agreed Open
19 Feb 2025 Cabinet referralsRecommendations agreed 8.2 Cllr England introduced CA/111/24 from the Cabinet meeting of 10/12/2024 ‘Treasury Managem... Agreed Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies