Item33
Resolved
That, under Section 100(A)(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, the public be excluded from the meeting for part of this item on the grounds that it involved the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in paragraph 1 of Part I of Schedule 12A of the Act. The Committee heard the speech from [name removed] . Members then asked questions and debated the personal circumstances of the applicant and his family. The Chairman advised the Committee that it was necessary to resolve to readmit members of the press and public to the meeting. It was moved by Councillor J S Back, duly seconded and That members of the press and public be readmitted to the meeting. The Planning Consultant advised that there was a five-year supply of gypsy and traveller pitches within the district. It was Officers’ view that there was space for the applicant and his family at the Meadows site. When weighing the applicant’s personal circumstances against the harm caused, Members were reminded that land within the AONB should be given the greatest level of protection. Any development outside the confines should be strictly limited and this proposal would undoubtedly cause significant harm to the AONB. Officers believed that the applicant’s circumstances did not carry sufficient weight to justify granting planning permission in this case. The issue of conflict between English and Irish travellers often came up, but there was no Government guidance on this matter. There were sites, such as Hay Hill, which accommodated travellers from both communities. In respect of human rights, the Planning Consultant advised that a decision made in the public interest could outweigh the rights of the applicant where it was aimed at protecting the AONB and promoting sustainable development. The Planning Solicitor added that the Public Sector Equality Duty required the Council to eliminate discrimination and harassment, and to foster good relations between people who shared protected characteristics. The Government’s Planning Policy Statement for Travellers did not distinguish between English and Irish travellers , and the facts did not appear to substantiate claims of antipathy between the two communities. Councillor Biggs commented that he did not believe the applicant’s personal circumstances justified permitting development in the AONB and in such an unsustainable location. Councillor Bates agreed, commenting that the conflict between English and Irish travellers appeared to be the underlying reason behind the proposal. Councillor Biggs noted that the Council’s gypsy and traveller policy was under review as part of the emerging Local Plan. He understood that this issue had come up during consultation on the draft Plan, and questioned why it was apparently now being ignored. The TLDM reported that she had sought advice from the Planning Policy and Projects Manager who had advised that the policy was at an early stage and evidence was still being gathered. The majority of gypsy/ traveller sites were Irish sites, but there were five sites available for English travellers . (a) That Application No DOV/21/00967 be REFUSED on the following grounds: ( i ) The proposed development, by reason of the scale of the site, development and associated works on and around the site, gives rise to significant harm to the open landscape character, appearance and scenic beauty of the countryside contrary to Policies DM1, DM15 and DM16 of the Core Strategy, the principles of SD2, SD3, SD7 and LLC1 of the Kent Downs AONB Management Plan and Paragraphs130, 174 and 176 of the National Planning Policy Framework; and (ii) The proposed development would be over-reliant on the use of the private motor car to reasonably access education, health, welfare and employment and social infrastructure contrary to Policies DM1, DM7 and DM11 of the Core Strategy, Paragraph 25 of the Planning Policy for Traveller Sites and Paragraphs 110 and 112 of the National Planning Policy Framework. (b) That powers be delegated to the Head of Planning and Development to settle any necessary wording in line with the recommendations and as resolved by the Planning Committee. ( Councillor D G Beaney left the meeting after he had spoken in support of the application.)
Word for word from the decision Dover published for this meeting.
Source: moderngov.dover.gov.uk