Item71
Resolved
That, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 9, the Committee proceeds with the business remaining on the agenda.) When asked to clarify his reasons for approving the application, Councillor Bond stated that, since he considered Policy DM1 to be out-of-date, the tilted balance approach of the NPPF was engaged which presumed approval of sustainable development proposals. He was also of the view that there would be no visual harm to the countryside given that the plot was situated in a valley and providing a condition was imposed restricting development to a bungalow. The PDM stressed that the Cross Road development was a completely different scheme where a range of planning considerations had been relevant, including the provision of works and measures to facilitate sustainable travel. In contrast, this proposal would be contrary to the NPPF. It was unlikely that occupants would use the footpath to access services and the development would therefore encourage an unsustainable form of travel. The Planning Solicitor added that, whilst there was no definition of an infill site, it was generally considered to be a vacant plot within existing development that could be developed to increase density. The site in question did not appear to fit that description. He emphasised that the starting point for assessing the application was the existing Local Plan and Policy DM1 of the Plan still carried some weight. He reminded the Committee that approving the application was likely to set a precedent and suggested that this was another reason why the application should not be approved. (a) That, notwithstanding the Officer’s recommendation, Application No DOV/22/00170 be APPROVED for the following reasons: (i) The Committee considered that Policy DM1 was out-of-date. The tilted balance approach of paragraph 11 of the National Planning Policy Framework was therefore engaged and, on balance, the Committee was of the opinion that the benefits of the proposal significantly and demonstrably outweighed any harm that would be caused. (ii) The Committee reached the above view on the proviso that any new dwelling would be single storey and would not be visible within the surrounding landscape. (b) That powers be delegated to the Head of Planning and Development to settle the matters described in the report and to impose conditions as required.
Word for word from the decision Dover published for this meeting.
Source: moderngov.dover.gov.uk