Item13
Resolved
That Cabinet: I. Considered the evidence of the impact and effect of the Order on the behaviours targeted. II. Considered the outcome of the statutory consultation undertaken from 23 November 2023 to 15 January 2024. III. Assessed all of the evidence presented and decided that it was proportionate and necessary to extend the Order and therefore authorised the Strategic Director for Housing & Environment to extend the period for which the existing Order has effect, for a period of 3 years with effect from 11 April 2024 until 10 April 2027. REASON FOR DECISION AND OPTIONS CONSIDERED: 1. As outlined in Section 4 of the report, since its introduction in 2018 the Order had been complied with for the most part and it had been successful in tackling the activities found to be having a detrimental effect on women accessing the Clinic, Clinic staff and others in the locality. 2. The Order was never intended to completely stop abortion related protest or prayer from occurring; it was designed to prevent the activities found to be having a detrimental effect from occurring within a very precise and clearly defined area where their impact was most acute. Since being in place it has almost entirely achieved that purpose. 3. As outlined, the Order permits some abortion related protest / vigil activities within the footprint of the Order, within a clearly identified designated area, in which certain requirements and prohibitions still remain . In addition, it was worth highlighting that the PSPO did not impose any restrictions on protests which take place in a location outside of the Safe Zone area. 4. There have been occasions during the period where groups of individuals who had been involved in protest / vigil in the immediate locality of the Clinic have attended Ealing civic centre (Perceval House) instead, where they have stood outside and displayed signs and images objecting to abortion. 5. The on-going near daily use of the designated area by the Pro-Life groups, the sporadic protests / vigils at Perceval House and the regular presence of groups involved in protest / prayer at the threshold of the area covered by the Order, all indicate a continued interest in the location by the Pro-Life groups who had previously been congregating at the entrance to the Clinic. The breaches committed by self-styled Pro-Life campaigners have also point to the likely recurrence of the behaviours targeted by the Order. It is reasonable to conclude from the continued presence of protestors and campaigners at these sites that, were the order to expire, they would return to the area outside the Clinic and continue the activities previously engaged in at this location. 6. The Pro-Choice group, Sister Supporter, that had been regularly present outside the Clinic prior to the introduction of the Order had chosen not to use the designated area to continue their activities, although it had always been open to them to do so, provided their activities complied with the provisions which apply to that space. ... view the full minutes text for item 13.
Word for word from the decision Ealing published for this meeting.
Source: ealing.moderngov.co.uk