Resolved
RESOLVED That the questions asked by members of the Council pursuant to Procedure Rules no. 9.2 and 9.3 and the responses given are noted. Question Question from Question Response 1 Cllr Peter Faithfull In your reply to me at the last full council meeting you stated that, in the last General Election, 'none of your election literature, published in your name, commended a target number.' Would you be willing to retract that statement? The Leader of Council confirmed that the information related to national housing figures included in promotional information distributed. 2 Cllr Mike Goodman In 2022/23 it was reported by Grant Thornton that the EDDC housing department were amongst the worse in the country for maladministration complaints at 87% as reported by the Ombudsman which focused on inspections and timeliness within damp and mould complaints. Can Councillor Dan Ledger explain why the Ombudsman's report 2023/24 shows there has been no improvement and what actions have been taken to improve the performance. PFH Sustainable Homes & Communities response: In 2023/24, EDDC’s maladministration rate was 89%. It should be noted, however, that this is relating to 89% of cases referred to the Housing Ombudsman for determination, not 89% of EDDC’s total complaints. In 2023/24, 9 complaints were taken on by the Housing Ombudsman for determination, and 8 of those cases had a maladministration finding. Only one of these cases related to damp and mould. In the 2023/24 Landlord Performance Report for East Devon, published by the Housing Ombudsman, they state “The Landlord performed similarly when compared to similar landlords by size and type”. 3 Cllr Mike Goodman Could Councillor Jackson explain what progress has been made to develop an East Devon online petition as most councils have this in place and is valuable to our residents. PFH Communications & Democracy response: The Overview Committee have requested a paper to set out the options for introducing an online petition for residents. The report is due to be reported to the committee on 23 January 2025. 4 Cllr Mike Goodman Members were confidentially received the important long-awaited Stock condition survey, when is this report going to be made public. PFH Sustainable Homes & Communities response: On November 7 th 2024 , all members were invited to attend a briefing session held by Currie and Brown to hear the initial headline data from the stock condition survey, not the full stock condition survey data. Aside from one preparatory meeting, this was also heard by Officers at the same time. This approach was taken to demonstrate the desire of Officers to work collaboratively and transparently with Members on the basis that further work would be needed to validate the data and complete internal quality assurance processes before moving forward. As has been explained, this validation and scrutiny will take time and the first stage of this is already underway and will be due to complete by the end of January. Until we are certain that the information we have been issued is a true reflection of our position and adopt it as such, we will not be able to publish a public report. In response to a follow up question the Portfolio Holder confirmed that the stock condition survey was currently subject to an internal quality assurance process and would be available to councillors when that work had concluded. 5 Cllr Mike Goodman The Grant Thornton internal report 2023/24 identifies a weakness in the Councils financial sustainability arrangements to fund the Housing stock. Can Councillor Hawkins outline what arrangements are being put in place. PFH Finance response: Council will be aware that a revised Housing Revenue Account (HRA) budget was approved for 2024/25 (July 2024), close monitoring is in place with weekly meetings between Finance and the Service to ensure the budget is not exceeded. Members of Cabinet, Housing Review Board and the Audit & Governance Committee have received regular and timely financial monitoring reports giving the assurance of this position. In agreeing to the revised budget a sustainability plan was presented and approved, this outlined the implications for the 2025/26 budget and the longer term work required linked to the stock condition survey. To update and provide progress against this programme a HRA position statement was presented to the Housing Review Board on 7 th November which covered the current financial position, the stock condition survey, CIPFA Health check, the HRA Sustainability Plan, the Business Plan and Options Appraisal work, the Asset management Strategy, and the Housing Investment & Delivery Plan. It is acknowledged that the financial sustainability of the HRA is a risk, but the Council has put in place the right mitigations as evidenced. I look forward to this being reflected in the 2024/25 outturn report. 6 Cllr Mike Goodman Having a place to call home is important to our residents could Councillor Ledger, confirm how many people are on the housing waiting list for each year from 2020 please. PFH Sustainable Homes & Communities response: At EDDC we hold a housing waiting list, this includes any persons who wish to register for social housing, not just those who have a housing need. It is important to note the key difference between an applicant assessed as being in housing need and those that are on a housing waiting list. I n answer to a follow up question the Portfolio Holder confirmed that the figures included housing need and waiting list details and it was hoped that the data could be reviewed to indicate the housing wait list numbers only. Question 6: As at Total Housing Need Housing Waiting List Total Housing Need % No Housing Need % 1st April 2020 2214 2494 4708 47% 53% 1st April 2021 ? 2652 2254 4906 54% 46% 1st April 2022 ? 2221 2326 4547 49% 51% 1st April 2023 ? 2588 2786 5374 48% 52% 1st April 2024 3065 3140 6205 49% 51% 1 st Nov 2024 2881 2884 5765 50% 50%