Recommendation from Cabinet - Delivery Vehicle for Marlcombe
ApprovedCommittee2 papers
AI summaryEast Devon Council approves £350,000 from its new communities reserve to develop the business case for the Marlcombe new town delivery vehicle, matching potential Homes England funding.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeApprovedBudget released to progress business case
Money£350,000 from new communities reserveMatches potential Homes England funding
What happens nextFull Business Case developmentInterim Vehicle expected early 2026
Who it affectsMarlcombe new community and wider areaIncludes Cranbrook expansion and Enterprise Zone
What was decided
Council approved £350,000 from the new communities reserve to develop the business case and progress further technical work, matching potential Homes England funding. Report P5, P16
Cabinet had earlier supported the Strategic Outline Business Case for a Marlcombe delivery vehicle and recommended further reports on the interim vehicle terms of reference and the full business case. Report P4, P5
Why
The Marlcombe new community is large and complex, and lessons from Cranbrook show a dedicated delivery vehicle is needed from the outset to focus resources and integrate physical and social development. Report P4, P10, P17
The Strategic Outline Business Case found the project commercially viable, with Benefit Cost Ratios of 3.17 to 3.40, indicating high value for money, and strong alignment with government new towns policy. Report P12, P15
What happens next
Develop a Full Business Case to determine the precise form of the delivery vehicle, with a further Cabinet report on the terms of reference for an Interim Vehicle. Report P4, P5, P15
Provisionally establish the Interim Vehicle in early 2026 and aim to set up a Development Corporation by March 2027, subject to Secretary of State and parliamentary approval. Report P15, P16
Continue partnership working with Homes England, Devon County Council and other stakeholders, drawing on the completed Memorandum of Understanding with Homes England. Report P16
The money
£350k Additional budget from the new communities reserve to develop the business case and technical work Report P5, P16, P19
£305k Potential Homes England funding this financial year for masterplanning and technical work Report P16
up to £100m Proposed project infrastructure funding to forward fund critical infrastructure improvements Report P12
£57m to £70m Economic costs (discounted and after optimism bias) across 20%, 35% and 40% affordable housing scenarios Report P12
£182m to £239m Economic benefits across the modelled affordable housing scenarios Report P12
Options considered
Shortlisted: Locally Led Urban Development Corporation (LLUDC). Statutory vehicle with advantages given the scale, complexity and timescales of the programme Report P14
Shortlisted: Locally Led New Town Development Corporation (LLNTDC). Statutory vehicle aligning with post-war new towns model and government new towns programme Report P14, P15
Shortlisted: Public owned development company. Non-statutory option identified as a possibility in the shortlist Report P14
Rejected: Informal delivery vehicles. Range from informal to statutory considered, with statutory options preferred Report P13, P14
Implications
Financial: An additional £350k budget is required from the new communities reserve, which has this sum available, alongside potential £305k from Homes England and proposed infrastructure funding of up to £100m. Report P12, P16, P19
Legal: Establishing a development corporation is a multi-step process under the New Towns Act 1981, Neighbourhood Planning Act 2017 and Levelling-up and Regeneration Act 2023, requiring Secretary of State approval and a parliamentary Statutory Instrument; external legal advice will be needed. Report P14, P15, P19
Equalities: Equalities impact assessed as Low. Report P9
Climate: Climate change impact assessed as Medium, with sustainability credentials to be considered in ongoing technical work. Report P9
Risk: Risk assessed as Medium, reflecting the substantial technical work, stakeholder engagement and procedural requirements needed to present a persuasive case to the Secretary of State. Report P9, P15
Staffing: External legal advice will be required due to the specialist nature of the project, and capacity funding is proposed to bolster key teams. Report P12, P16, P19
Who and where
Residents and future residents of the Marlcombe new community, currently proposed for 8,000 to 10,000 homes Report P12
Cranbrook new community and its expansion area Report P4, P5, P12
Exeter and East Devon Enterprise Zone and the Airport area Report P5, P12
Devon County Council, as a key partner and consenting authority Report P10, P12, P15
Homes England, MHCLG and the Secretary of State, as funders and approvers of any development corporation Report P12, P14, P15
Local enterprise, education providers, landowners and other stakeholders in the proposed area Report P12
Timeline
30 July 2025: Cabinet considered entering a Memorandum of Understanding with Homes England, now completed Report P16
Early 2026 (provisional): Interim Vehicle anticipated to be established Report P15
1 October 2025: Cabinet considered the Strategic Outline Business Case and recommended the budget to Council Report P3, P5
15 October 2025: Council approved the £350,000 budget from the new communities reserve
By March 2027 (provisional): Development Corporation targeted for establishment, subject to Secretary of State and parliamentary approval Report P15
Plain English for the jargon
SOBC: Strategic Outline Business Case, the initial stage in the business case development process
FBC: Full Business Case, the comprehensive document that confirms the final plan and financial details
LLUDC: Locally Led Urban Development Corporation, a statutory delivery vehicle
LLNTDC: Locally Led New Town Development Corporation, a statutory delivery vehicle for new towns
NTDC: New Towns Development Corporation, the post-war statutory body model
BCR: Benefit Cost Ratio, a measure of value for money used in the economic case
MHCLG: Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item44
Resolved
That Council approve that a budget of £350,000 is made available from the new communities reserve to enable the development of the business case alongside progressing further technical work, matching potential funding being made available by Homes England.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk
Date of Meeting 1 October 2025 Document classification: Part A Public Document Exemption applied: None Review date for release N/A
Delivery Vehicle for Marlcombe Report summary: This report presents the Strategic Outline Business Case for the establishment of a delivery vehicle for the Marlcombe new community. The delivery of a new town is a complex, long-term endeavour that necessarily involves multiple different stakeholders. A key learning point from Cranbrook is the need to establish a dedicated delivery vehicle from the outset to provide the necessary focus and resources to realise the ambitious vision for a place including integrating both physical and social development. The report seeks support for the Strategic Outline Business Case such that work can then progress, with benefit of additional funding, to develop a Full Business Case. This will consider the precise form that the delivery vehicle should take and would be foreshadowed by the creation of an Interim Vehicle, the terms of reference for which will be the subject of a further report to Cabinet. Is the proposed decision in accordance with: Budget Yes ☐ No ☒ Policy Framework Yes ☒ No ☐ Recommendation: It is recommended that Cabinet;
• Supports the Executive Summary of the Strategic Outline Business Case for the establishment of a delivery vehicle for the Marlcombe new community • Receives a further report setting out the full Strategic Outline Business Case • Receives subsequent reports regarding: o the terms of reference for an interim vehicle, and o the full business case for a delivery vehicle for the integrated proposal including the Cranbrook expansion and Enterprise Zone areas • Recommends to Council that a budget of £350k is made available from the new communities reserve to enable the development of the business case alongside progressing further technical work, matching potential funding being made available by Homes England
Reason for recommendation: To support the future establishment of a delivery vehicle that is capable to ensuring that the vision for Marlcombe is translated into practical delivery on the ground.
Officer: Andy Wood, Director of Place, email [email protected] PAPER A
Portfolio(s) (check which apply): ☐ Assets and Economy ☐ Communications and Democracy ☐ Council, Corporate and External Engagement ☐ Culture, Leisure, Sport and Tourism ☐ Environment - Nature and Climate ☐ Environment - Operational ☐ Finance ☒ Place, Infrastructure and Strategic Planning ☐ Sustainable Homes and Communities
Equalities impact Low Impact Climate change Medium Impact. The sustainability credentials of the new community will need to be carefully considered as part of the ongoing technical work. Risk: Medium Risk; The establishment of a statutory delivery vehicle such as a development corporation very much aligns with both government policy and the learning from the delivery of Cranbrook but will require substantial technical work and stakeholder engagement to ensure that all procedural requirements are met and that a persuasive case is presented to the Secretary of State. Links to background information Building new towns for the future Link to Council Plan Priorities (check which apply) ☒ A supported and engaged community ☒ Carbon neutrality and ecological recovery ☒ Resilient economy that supports local business ☒ Financially secure and improving quality of services
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.