AI summaryEast Devon District Council endorsed the 4-5-1 model for local government reorganisation in Devon, creating three unitary authorities that would merge East Devon with Exeter and northern districts, and proposed a 4-5-1+ modification to the Secretary of State.
Written from the decision and the officer reportPDF Pro
OutcomeDecidedSubmission to Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government
MoneyNot stated
What happens nextChief Executive to progress workIn consultation with the Deputy Leader
Who it affectsDevon residents and council staffAll local government services across former Devon County Council footprint
What was decided
The Council endorsed submission of the full proposal for the 4-5-1 model of local government reorganisation (Reimagining Devon: Believe in Better) to the Secretary of State, together with proposing the 4-5-1+ option as a modification.
The Council endorsed next steps in progression of work by the Chief Executive in consultation with the Deputy Leader.
Why
The proposal aims to create a single tier of local government with three unitary authorities: Torbay and Southern Devon; Exeter and Northern Devon; and Plymouth City Council, unlocking Devon's potential and delivering simpler, more sustainable services. Report P3, P4, P5, P6, P7
Evidence shows homelessness and fuel poverty in Devon are higher than in similar local authorities, deprivation is higher in the north and rural areas, and the current two-tier system struggles with service access in rural areas. Report P15, P16, P17
Demographic data shows a high proportion of older people compared to the national average, significant rurality and isolation, and more women than men in receipt of adult social care. Report P19
What happens next
A transition plan to ensure continuity of services and mitigate risks during the changeover is to be developed by July 2026, with weekly board reports and monitoring of statutory complaints. Report P44
Targeted Equality Impact Assessments for the design and location of critical frontline services, and a Workforce Transition Plan with formal consultation, are to be undertaken to mitigate impacts on protected groups. Report P45, P46
A neighbourhood empowerment model is to be implemented, with mapping of service delivery points to maintain accessible local offices, and multi-channel service navigation guidance from Day 1 to prevent confusion. Report P48, P49, P50
Options considered
Chosen: 4-5-1 model (three unitary authorities across Devon). Endorsed as the full proposal for submission, aiming to deliver simpler, stronger, more sustainable local government Report P3, P11
Chosen: 4-5-1+ option. Proposed as a modification to the Secretary of State Report P11
Rejected: 9-1-1 model (alternative LGR proposal) Report P20
Implications
Equalities: Significant opportunity for better outcomes for older people and children/young people through integration of services, but risk of service disruption and complex navigation during transition for disabled and older residents. Report P31, P32, P52
Equalities: Risk that workforce reorganisation and efficiency savings could disproportionately affect female employees and older workers, as the local government workforce is majority-female, particularly in social care and administrative roles. Report P38, P46
Equalities: Risk of inequitable access and outcomes disproportionately affecting existing disadvantaged ethnic groups if not monitored during transition. Report P36
Risk: Remaining negative impacts are primarily unavoidable transition risk inherent in any LGR process, with some short-term disruption and complexity in service access likely as systems merge. Report P52
Staffing: A Workforce Transition Plan with formal consultation, clear communication, redundancy, and support for all staff is to be developed to mitigate impact on protected groups. Report P46
Legal: The Public Sector Equality Duty requires the Council to eliminate discrimination, advance equality of opportunity, and foster good relations with protected groups, plus have due regard to armed forces personnel. Report P29, P40
Who and where
Older people in Devon, particularly in rural areas facing isolation and access challenges Report P19, P24, P31
Young people facing lack of affordable housing, public transport, and youth services Report P25
Disabled people, including those with SEND and mental health needs Report P32, P45
Women, particularly those in receipt of adult social care and the majority-female local government workforce Report P19, P38
Ethnic minority groups at risk of inequitable access if not monitored Report P36
Carers and care leavers, with high positive potential from integrated services Report P41
Armed forces personnel, families, and veterans, with legal duty of due regard Report P40
Local government staff across the former Devon County Council footprint facing organisational change Report P46, P52
Timeline
November 2025: Equality Impact Assessment completed by Andy Wood Report P53, P54
July 2026: Target date for completion of transition plan to ensure continuity of services and mitigate risks during changeover Report P44
TBC (post-decision, shadow authority, and re-formation): Workforce Transition Plan to be developed Report P46
TBC (pre-vesting day): Clear multi-channel service navigation guidance to be established from Day 1 Report P50
Plain English for the jargon
LGR: Local Government Reorganisation, the restructuring of councils in Devon from a two-tier to a single-tier system
4-5-1 model: A proposal creating three unitary authorities: Torbay and Southern Devon; Exeter and Northern Devon; and Plymouth
4-5-1+ option: A modification to the 4-5-1 model, including an option to expand Plymouth's boundary to accommodate parts of four adjacent parishes in the Plymouth Policy Area
EIA: Equality Impact Assessment, a document assessing how a policy might impact protected groups
Unitary authority: A single council responsible for all local government services in its area, replacing the current two-tier system of district and county councils
VSCE: Voluntary, Community and Social Enterprise sector organisations
SEND: Special Educational Needs and Disabilities
EDI: Equality, Diversity and Inclusion
Public Sector Equality Duty: A legal duty to eliminate discrimination, advance equality of opportunity, and foster good relations with protected groups
What was decided, why, and what happens next
Pro reads every officer report for you and explains each decision in plain English: the money, the options, the risks, the timeline, each with the paragraph it came from.
Written by AI from the council's published papers. AI can get things wrong: the council's own wording below is the record.Report a problem
Item71
Resolved
That the Council endorse the submission to the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government of the full proposal for the 4-5-1 model of local government reorganisation as set out in the Reimagining Devon: Believe in Better as the Council’s response to the Secretary of State’s invitation, together with the proposing of the 4-5-1 + option to the Secretary of State through a modification. 2. That Council endorses the next steps in terms of the progression of work by the Chief Executive in consultation with the Deputy Leader.
Word for word from the decision East Devon published for this meeting.Source: democracy.eastdevon.gov.uk
Equality Impact Assessment Before completing this EIA please ensure you have read the EIA guidance notes and other resources, available on the intranet Version 1.0 Date Completed November 2025
Description of what is being impact assessed
Description of what is being impact assessed The proposal under review is the submission of the 4-5-1 model for Local Government Reorganisation (LGR) in Devon, in response to an invitation from the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government. This model is designed to create a single tier of local government, consisting of three unitary authorities:
1. Torbay and Southern Devon Unitary - comprising South Hams, Teignbridge, West Devon, and Torbay.
2. Exeter and Northern Devon Unitary - Comprising North Devon, Torridge, Mid Devon, East Devon, and Exeter.
3. Plymouth City Council on its current boundaries – there is also an option to expand the boundary to accommodate parts of four adjacent parishes that fall within the Plymouth Policy Area
The new councils will be responsible for delivering all local government services (social care, education, housing, planning, waste, etc.) across the former Devon County Council footprint. The aim is to unlock Devon's full potential, transform local government, address long-standing challenges, and deliver a simpler, stronger, and more sustainable system that provides better outcomes for residents. The final reorganisation will have a significant impact on service delivery.
Evidence
What data/information have you used to assess how this policy/service might impact on protected groups?
The assessment is based on a rigorous, evidence-led process, combining quantitative analysis, qualitative assessment, and extensive engagement.
Equality Impact Assessment Form December 2023 • LGR Proposal Documents: The full Proposal for the 4-5-1 model ‘Reimagining Devon: Believe in Better’ and the accompanying Executive Summary detailing the case for change, options appraisal, and final recommendation for the 4-5- 1+ option. The proposal's core arguments for improved efficiency, capacity, and high-quality, sustainable public services (Criteria 2 & 3). Its commitment to working together to understand and meet local needs (Criteria 4) and stronger community engagement (Criteria 6).
• Public Engagement Data: Nearly 6,000 responses were received through public surveys, targeted workshops, forums, and meetings with stakeholders.
• Stakeholder Engagement: Engagement included local housing providers, landlords, and representatives from organisations such as the Citizens Advice Bureau (CAB), which assist vulnerable groups. Outreach was conducted to organisations such as VSCE groups, which often represent and advocate for communities with protected characteristics.
• Socio-economic/Geographic Data:
o Levels of homelessness and fuel poverty in Devon are higher than similar local authorities.
o Data shows deprivation is higher in the north and in rural areas.
o The current system struggles with access to services, transport, and digital connectivity in rural areas.
• Demographic/Service User Data:
o Devon-specific demographic data: High proportion of older people compared to the national average, significant areas of rurality/isolation, and known challenges in delivering complex services like SEND and accessible transport across a large, two-tier system. More women than men are in receipt of adult social care.
Alongside this the Equality Impact Assessment produced by Devon County Council has also been considered. This document provided a baseline assessment of an alternative LGR proposal (9-1-1 model) but contains relevant Devon-wide data and insights into the general impact of unitarisation on protected groups.
Equality Impact Assessment Form December 2023 Who have you consulted with to assess possible impact on protected groups and what have they told you? If you have not consulted other people, please explain why?
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.