What was decided
Cabinet noted the content of the government consultation and agreed the proposed responses to each consultation question for submission as the council's response. Report P4
The council's response argues that Marlcombe meets the programme's scale, economic growth and deliverability objectives and should be added to the priority locations. Report P34, P35, P56, P57
The council disputes the accuracy of the Strategic Environmental Assessment for Marlcombe, citing an over-large study area, overstated flood risk, an assumed build-out rate that is too high, and incorrect statements about loss of employment land and Cranbrook's identity. Report P43, P48, P54
Why
Members had previously committed at the 1 April Cabinet to contest the proposed priority locations and to receive a further report setting out a consultation response. Report P9
Marlcombe was assessed in the SEA but not taken forward as one of the seven priority locations, which the council considers risks underusing a deliverable, infrastructure-first standalone new town. Report P22, P25, P56, P57
The council argues that the advanced local plan and masterplanning evidence for Marlcombe gives stronger mitigation assurance than the SEA indicates. Report P36, P47, P52
What happens next
Submit the agreed response to the government consultation, with any financial or resourcing implications to be brought back to Cabinet and Council in future reports. Report P4, P87
Continue progressing Marlcombe through the Regulation 19 draft Local Plan examination, with development discussions aiming for a 2030 start. Report P36
Work with government, Homes England and partner authorities to progress Marlcombe and support the broader programme objectives. Report P86
The money
- £2.1bn Local transport funding associated with the Leeds South Bank proposal in the Taskforce report Report P18
Options considered
- Chosen: Agree the drafted responses and submit them as the council's consultation response. To ensure members were aware of the consultation and had the opportunity to comment on the proposals Report P4, P5
- Rejected: Government's proposed seven priority locations (Tempsford, Crews Hill and Chase Park, Leeds South Bank, Manchester Victoria North, Thamesmead, Brabazon and West Innovation Arc, Milton Keynes). Council argues Marlcombe should be included and that some selected sites are urban regeneration rather than new towns Report P22, P56, P57
- Rejected: A 40% affordable housing target in new town policy. Council considers the target unviable without significant grant funding and warns it could limit grant access and reduce overall affordable delivery Report P71
Implications
- Legal: No direct legal implications identified in the report at this stage. Report P87
- Financial: No new funding requested now; future reports to Cabinet and Council will set out cost implications of contesting and delivering Marlcombe. Report P87
- Equalities: Council says the programme can deliver equalities benefits through affordable housing, accessible design, services access and inclusive engagement, but flags risks of displacement and digital exclusion. Report P80, P81, P82
- Climate: Council supports low-carbon, climate-resilient design, enhanced biodiversity net gain, transport decarbonisation and water efficiency, all of which it says are already built into Marlcombe's policy framework. Report P32, P51, P52
- Risk: Low risk and low impact assessments recorded; main risk is loss of Marlcombe's place in the priority programme and the credibility of the SEA findings for that site. Report P8, P54
- Other: Marlcombe is in a Regulation 19 draft Local Plan due for examination later this year, with development discussions aiming to start in 2030. Report P36
Who and where
- Residents and future residents of a proposed Marlcombe new town in East Devon Report P18, P36
- Cranbrook expansion area, which is linked to the Marlcombe proposal Report P35, P36
- Landholders and developers in discussions on Marlcombe with the council Report P36, P40
- Exeter and the Exeter and East Devon Enterprise Zone growth corridor Report P18, P35
- Other 12 new town locations considered in the New Towns Taskforce report Report P18, P22
Timeline
- September 2025: New Towns Taskforce report recommending 12 sites for at least 10,000 homes each Report P10, P16
- 1 April 2026: Earlier Cabinet meeting at which members committed to contest the proposed priority locations and receive a further report Report P9
- 6 May 2026: Cabinet meeting at which the consultation response was agreed Report P2
- Later this year: Government aims to adopt the New Towns Programme following consultation and assessments; Marlcombe's Regulation 19 draft Local Plan is also due to be submitted for examination Report P10, P36
- 2030: Discussions ongoing with landholders and developers to commence development at Marlcombe Report P36
Plain English for the jargon
- Marlcombe: Proposed standalone new town in East Devon of 10,000-14,000 homes near the Exeter and East Devon Enterprise Zone, identified in the New Towns Taskforce report but not chosen as a priority location in the consultation.
- New Towns Programme: Government programme to deliver large-scale new settlements of at least 10,000 homes, with infrastructure-first delivery, a New Towns Unit and a draft planning policy.
- SEA (Strategic Environmental Assessment): Programme-level environmental assessment of the proposed new town locations, including air quality, biodiversity, climate, flood risk, heritage, landscape, water and other topics.
- Regulation 19 draft Local Plan: The final pre-submission stage of a local plan, which is then sent for independent examination.
- BNG (Biodiversity Net Gain): A requirement for development to deliver measurable improvements to biodiversity, with higher targets possible above the statutory minimum.