Resolved
RESOLVED that the application for variation of the premises licence be granted as outlined in the decision notice below: DECISION OF THE LICENSING PANEL REGARDING APPLICATION FOR VARIATION OF PREMISES LICENCE AT FAREHAM WORKING MEN’S CLUB, 8 MILL ROAD, FAREHAM, PO16 0TN. All parties shall receive written notification of the decision and reasons. The Panel has considered very carefully the application for variation of a premises licence at the Working Men’s Club. The Panel has given due regard to the Licensing Act 2003, the Licensing Objectives, statutory guidance and the adopted statement of Licensing Policy. Human Rights legislation has been borne in mind whilst making the decision. It has paid due regard to all representations and evidence both written and given orally today and attached due weight accordingly in light of all the circumstances. It was noted that no representation had been received from any responsible authority and that residents’ representations generally related to the potential for an increase in crime and disorder and public nuisance. Legal advice was accepted that the Panel was considering the variation application only and not the Club Premises Certificate relating to adjoining parts of the building. Having heard all the evidence the Panel has determined to grant the application. REASONS The Panel was presented with evidence from a number of residents relating to the potential for nuisance and crime and disorder resulting from the proposed licensable activities. Much of this concern related to historic operation under the Club Premises Certificate (“CPC”), rather than recent use of the area now intended to be licensed (in accordance with regular TEN notification). The Applicant confirmed that the application sought to bring the use of the Concert Hall in line with the hours permitted for the Club under the CPC and that, if granted, the licence would not increase the frequency of use or the intensity of use to that already existing via use of TENs. The lack of representation from, notably, the Police or Environmental Health means that the Panel is bound to infer that no objection is held and that responsible authorities are satisfied with the application. Representations of residents expressed concern regarding those leaving the premises, particularly late at night and whilst under the influence. The Panel had to consider whether the application being considered would lead to an increase in those issues or present further risk to the Licensing Objectives. Given the nature of planned events i.e. dance classes and daytime wakes it was not considered appropriate to impose restrictions or to refuse the grant of the licence. The Act includes strong powers on review and other measures under other legislation exists to take enforcement action with regards to the CPC or premises licence where this is relevant. Residents were advised during the course of the hearing to contact the Police where instances of crime and disorder occur and Environmental Health when issues relating to noise nuisance emanating from the building are witnessed. Both the CPC and the premises licence can be reviewed where there is evidence relating to issues arising from their operation. Reviews may be commenced by responsible authorities or residents. In this regard, should issues arise due to the premises not being run in a manner asserted by the Applicant during the hearing there are means of addressing this in future. The Panel noted evidence given by the Applicant indicating that the residents’ concerns are understood and that attempts will be made to ensure these are taken on board and acted upon where appropriate. The Panel strongly recommends that the Premises Licence Holder makes every effort to foster good relations with neighbours and undertakes a thorough risk assessment of events at the premises – to consider, in particular, whether SIA doorstaff are required (e.g. where the number attending, the hours of hire and whether alcohol is to be available indicate a higher risk) to monitor those leaving the premises. The Panel did consider imposing a condition requiring the same but did not feel it was currently appropriate at this stage. There is a right of appeal to the Magistrates' Court for all parties and formal written notification of the decision will set out that right in full.