Item7
Resolved
Decision We were informed by the Planning Inspector yesterday that the Council has unfortunately lost the planning appeal in relation to land east of Newgate Lane east. This was a co-joined appeal for outline applications in both Fareham and Gosport Borough Council’s administrative areas, as the access to the site for 99 homes would lie in Gosport. The Inspector concluded that despite issues of strategic gap, best and most versatile land and conflict with our adopted plan development strategy, in light of our persistent lack of five-year supply, outline permission for 99 homes was granted. The Council’s Publication Local Plan does not include this site, nor the fields to the north which were previously included in earlier Local Plan consultations as the site ‘HA2 Land east of Newgate Lane’. Reasons for excluding this site from the more advanced stages of the plan weigh heavily on the conflict with the strategic gap policy and the most recent technical evidence which finds that this area of the borough cannot accept development in a way that complies with our policy. This view was upheld by the Inspector who said that when taking the Fareham -Stubbington Strategic gap as a whole this site’s size is relatively modest but there would be harm to the Strategic gap by way of a reduction in the physical and visual separation between Peel Common and Bridgemary. Despite the outcome, the Inspector attributed significant weight to the conflict with the Strategic Gap policy. Therefore, the development strategy in the Publication Plan, which is currently out to consultation, to exclude development in this area requires no amendment and the Council will continue to defend this part of the Strategic Gap from harmful speculative developments. This disappointing news is tempered by a more positive position with regards to affordable housing provision in the Borough as a result of the appeal decision. The successful Appeal was made by Bargate Homes who are owned by Vivid Homes, a large registered provider of affordable housing. It is the appellant’s intention to develop the site as a 100% affordable housing scheme although as only 40% can be secured as affordable housing via the Planning Obligations, there can be no guarantee that more than 40% will be delivered as part of the development. Notwithstanding the Appellant’s stated intention to deliver 100% affordable housing on the site, there is no policy requirement to provide more than 40% affordable housing and doing so would apparently cause the Appellant difficulties in securing certain types of funding. At the hearing the Council was clear that the Inspector should only give the provision of affordable housing at the site weight in the planning balance proportionate to the 40% provision secured in the section 106. In effect the Council reminded the Inspector that he ought not to give the provision of 100% affordable housing more weight than it should bearing in mind only 40% was legally guaranteed. The Appellant and the Council did agree to an additional planning condition at the request of Officers which the Inspector has agreed to impose which provides some control over the additional affordable housing to be provided. This condition does not require a higher level of affordable housing provision but means that, in the event more than 40% is provided the Council will be able to ensure a suitable community lettings plan is followed. Housing Rose Court Development The Executive Member put forward his thanks to the Mayor for officially opening the Rose Court development on Highlands Road. The development has delivered 18 social housing units within the Borough which are very much needed. The Executive Member stated that he looks forward to reporting on further Council built developments in the future.
Word for word from the decision Fareham published for this meeting.
Source: moderngov.fareham.gov.uk