(i) Cabinet agrees to the removal of Caddies from Collection Rounds on a phased approach. (ii) Cabinet agrees to the provision of Capital (Approximately £6.125M) for the waste Collection Vehicles and changing to single bodies vehicles. (iii) Cabinet agrees to the proposal from CMT of moving to a co-mingled collection rather than separate fibre collections. For the following reasons: (a) There has been a consistent decline in Paper Tonnages from 2014. (b) Waste collection vehicles are no longer sustainable and need replacing with single bodied vehicles, which support both collection options. (c) Co-mingled collections are more flexible and do not require additional bins.
Word for word from the decision Gateshead published for this meeting.Source: democracy.gateshead.gov.uk
1.1To update Cabinet on the potential alternative collection models for dry recycling as provided through the recent support received from the Waste Resources Action Programme (WRAP) and advise on the MRF contract extensions.
Background
2.1It has been reported at previous OPB and Joint Executive Committee (JEC) meetings that separately collected paper tonnages have declined dramatically in all three partner authorities since this system was implemented in 2014 (See Appendix 1). This follows a year-on-year trend with separately collected paper tonnages now being minimal. With such low paper tonnages, this means the current kerbside dry recycling collection system is not sustainable as the authorities continue to operate split body vehicles which are not being utilised effectively i.e. one of the compartments is effectively empty most of the time.
2.2Therefore, STWWMP are currently considering alternative collection models available, to identify the most appropriate method of maximising the quality of household recycling collected at the kerbside which will also assist preparations for the next MRF processing contract procurement. To help with this exercise, we have been working with and received some further support from the Waste Resources Action Programme (WRAP). Work was initially carried out in 2019, but WRAP have been reviewing the appraisal of options based on updated tonnage data, in case there has been a change in composition of dry recycling since the COVID-19 pandemic as well as impact on commodity prices. WRAP’s final report, which referenced forthcoming proposals under Simpler Recycling, was presented to Officer Project Board on 22 February 2024. This note should be read in conjunction with WRAP’s final report.
3 Summary of the Report and Presentation
3.1WRAP used data received from the Partnership and outputs from the previous options appraisal report that WRAP provided to the Partnership in 2019/20. This enabled the cost models to project the likely cost and performance of a short-list of alternative collection scenarios. The short-list, proposed by OPB was essentially, the options previously modelled but excluding food waste. WRAP agreed to update the outputs on each of these, free of charge, on the basis that there have not been any major changes to waste and recycling services since the original report.
3.2The short-listed scenarios assessed by WRAP are shown below in table 1. 1 Table 1: short-listed options
3.3A number of inputs and assumptions were used for the short-listed alternative collection scenarios. These are listed below.
i) Latest Tonnage data ii) Waste Composition Data (actuals from sampling and assumptions) iii) Capture rates (assumed) iv) Contamination rates (actuals and assumptions) v) Vehicle and Staff Resources vi) Container costs vii) Disposal and Treatment costs (actuals and assumptions)
3.4The report looked at projected performance in terms of kerbside recycling levels relative to the baseline service. There were only minor differences in recycling rate percentages for the modelled options.
3.5Combining the collection and disposal costs plus overheads produces projected ‘whole system’ costs. Comparing the projected ‘whole system’ costs for the short-listed scenarios against the baseline shows that Scenario 1a is projected to deliver the greatest saving for all 3 authorities. Projected collection, disposal and overhead costs of the future collection scenarios relative to the baseline by authority are set out in table 2 below.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
NEMSA Adult Skills Fund Acceptancei) To approve acceptance of grant funding from the North East Mayoral Strategic Authority for delivery of the Skills ...
Local Council Tax Support Scheme 2027/28i) To approve the consultation exercise set out in paragraphs 10 to 13 of the report. ii) To receive a further report...
Procurement and Contracts Reporti) To authorise the Strategic Director, Resources and Digital, to: a) Invite or negotiate tenders. b) Undertake other...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.