RESOLVED To give authorisation to the Corporate Director to: 1) alter condition 4 of 2013/0497 to remove the reference to the Chevron Ltd Hazardous Substance Consent, so that the condition reads:- 'The public house or restaurant element shall not be brought into use until either: a) The hazardous substances consents for the Total Lindsey Oil Refinery Ltd has been revoked or b) A report relating to the respective element has been submitted to the LPA outlining the level of risk posed by the presence of the Total Lindsey Oil Refinery Ltd together with details of any proposed mitigation measures and the LPA have agreed in writing that they are satisfied with the conclusions of the Report so to allow the respective element to be occupied. Any mitigation measures proposed in the report to be approved in writing by the Borough Council shall be implemented in accordance with the approved report.’ 2) Write to the HSE to advise that no alteration should be made to condition 4 of 2013/0497 part b in relation to the ability for the applicants to submit a report for a risk assessment in relation to the risk posed by the presence of the Total Oil Refinery. 3) Write to the HSE to advise that they will be consulted in relation to the risk based report set out in in condition 4 of (2013/0497) and also any proposed mitigation measures. 4) Write to the HSE to agree an extension of 14 days from the 22 nd November to enable to HSE to further consider whether to call in application number 2013/0497.
Word for word from the decision Gedling published for this meeting.Source: democracy.gedling.gov.uk
Planning Applications 2013/0497 and 2013/0500 were presented to Planning Committee on the 30th October 2013; members were minded to grant planning permission for both applications subject to a number of planning conditions. As a result of Hazardous Substances Consents in place for Total Oil Refinery Ltd and for the former Esso Petroleum Company Ltd and Chevron Ltd and the Development Proximity Zones that have been established by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) the applications were subject to consultation with the HSE.
The HSE advised against both developments. In relation to application 2013/0497 the HSE advised against because of the existence of the Total Oil Refinery Ltd and Chevron Ltd Hazardous Substance Consents. Whilst in relation to 2013/0500 the HSE advised against the application because of the existence of the Esso Petroleum Company Ltd and Chevron Ltd Hazardous Substance Consents. The Esso and Chevron hazardous consents were revoked after the Committee Reports were drafted.
Given the nature of the applications there remained a requirement for both applications to be referred to the HSE following the resolution to grant both applications at Planning Committee on 30th October 2013. The 0497 application was referred because of the ‘advise against’ decision made and because the HSE need to be kept informed of decisions made in relation to applications that could affect sites where hazardous substances are stored. The 0500 application was referred to the HSE for the latter reason. The HSE have powers to call in the applications so that they could be determined by the Secretary of State.
As a consequence of this referral the HSE e-mailed the Council on the 6th November and have made the following comments in relation to the applications:
HSE Comments 2013/0497
“The HSE wrote to Gedling Borough Council on 27 June 2013, providing HSE's advice in respect of planning application 2013/0497, which is that there are sufficient reasons, on safety grounds, for advising against the granting of planning permission. There were two reasons for this;
a) the proposed development involves an 'indoor use by the public' development type (sensitivity level SL2), which is sited within the inner zone of the Chevron Ltd site;
b) the proposed development involves a public house/restaurants and a takeaway restaurant which will be located within the Development Proximity Zone (DPZ) of Total Lindsey Oil Refinery Ltd, a large-scale petrol storage site. HSE's 'Land use planning advice around large-scale petrol storage sites' set out in circular SPC/Tech/Gen/43, explains that HSE will advise against any proposals to site occupied buildings with the DPZ.
As the hazardous substances consent of the Chevron Ltd site has now been revoked, (a) no longer applies. However, the hazardous substances consent for the Total Lindsey Oil Refinery Ltd site remains in place so HSE's advice is still that we advise against the granting of planning permission.
On pages 10 and 16 of the Report to the Planning Committee of 30 October 2013, it is suggested that HSE's concerns could be addressed by including the following condition in the planning permission;
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.