RESOLVED t o REFUSE PLANNING PERMISSION. 1. In the opinion of the Borough Council, the garage element of the development results in an unduly prominent and incongruous feature in the street-scene due to the elevated position of the garage in very close proximity to the highway boundary. As such, the proposed development would be contrary to Policy ENV1 of the Replacement Local Plan (Certain Policies Saved 2014), Policy 10 of the Aligned Core Strategy for Gedling Borough, NPPF Part 7 'Requiring good design' as well as the Policy LPD 35 'Safe, Accessible and Inclusive Development' of the emerging Local Planning Document.
Word for word from the decision Gedling published for this meeting.Source: democracy.gedling.gov.uk
Application Number: 2017/0154 6 Jessops Lane Gedling Nottinghamshire NG4 4BQ Location: Report to Planning Committee
Application Number: 2017/0154
Location: 6 Jessops Lane Gedling Nottinghamshire NG4 4BQ
Proposal: Variation of condition 2 (approved plans) - 2016/0148 (ground & first floor extensions, and a detached garage) Repositioning of garage towards front boundary, and minor alterations to dwelling
Applicant: [name removed]:
Case Officer: Amy Cockayne
Site Description
Located within the urban area of Gedling, the application site formally comprised of a detached bungalow set back from the boundary with the highway by approximately 10m. The land level of the site is set approximately 1m above the level of the road.
The levels in and around the site fall to the north-east, setting the application site at a higher level than the neighbouring property, 8 Jessops Lane (a detached bungalow) and lower than the neighbouring property 4 Jessops Lane (a two storey detached dwelling). All Hallows Church borders the site to the south-east.
The boundaries of the site are delineated by a 1m brick wall to the boundary with the highway, 1.8m close-board timber fencing and 2m brick wall to the boundary with the church grounds at the rear.
The original permission for the extensions and alterations to the existing property was granted on 10th June 2016 for ground and first floor extensions and a detached garage (planning ref. 2016/0148). This permission allows a two storey dwelling on the site. Works started on site around September 2016. An enforcement case was opened in October 2016 after a complaint was received that the garage to the front of the dwelling was not being built in accordance with the approved plans.
As of March 2017, building works are not completed and the works to the main dwelling are still being carried out at the site.
Proposed Development
The application seeks to vary Condition 2 of the original permission 2016/0148 in relation to the positioning of the garage to the front of the dwelling and alterations to the single storey aspect rear of the dwelling. As works have commenced, permission is sought retrospectively.
The detached single garage has been built forward of the position approved. The garage is set-back approximately 1.2m from the front boundary with the highway. The garage has a footprint of 5.5m x 3.95m. The roof is dual pitched with gabled front and rear elevations. The eaves are 2.59m, and maximum ridge height of 3.87m.
The alterations to the single storey projection to the rear of the property include an increase of the width of the ground floor by 0.5m to the north-eastern elevation. The original flat roof is proposed to be altered to a double gable to a maximum ridge height of 4.2m. It was established through a site visit in March 2017 that this element of the development has not been constructed in accordance with the original permission or the revised plans, and the roof of the single storey extension includes a single gable and mono-pitch design.
Consultations
Neighbours were notified and a site notice posted near to the site. Five letters of objection were received (two letters from the same address) in relation to the garage. The grounds of objection include the following:- Overpowering in size and height Out of character Intrusive appearance Untidy/chaotic appearance on street-scene Overshadowing Applicant has a disregard for planning process Materials should be brick not render
In addition, one letter in support of the application has been received with grounds of support summarised as:- Structure will remain in clear view from each position, all be it 200cm further from the road ‘Uneven’ appearance in respect of street-scene Moving garage back would be poor decision
Planning Considerations
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.